[openstack-tc] Incubation process
Gabriel.Hurley at nebula.com
Tue Jan 29 23:44:42 UTC 2013
Thanks for the summary. The full doc is interesting, too, and the diagram is helpful.
That seems reasonable to me so far. I will be very curious to know what the Board decides the criteria for "Core" to be since we basically punted the ambiguous part of the question out of the TC's bailiwick and into the Board's. ;-)
All the best,
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Mark McLoughlin [mailto:markmc at redhat.com]
> Sent: Tuesday, January 29, 2013 2:26 PM
> To: openstack-tc at lists.openstack.org
> Subject: [openstack-tc] Incubation process
> The "Incubation Update" committee meetings are still going on, but Thierry
> and I made the point at the last meeting that the TC will soon need to be able
> to proceed with evaluating Ceilometer and Heat for graduation from
> We came up with a summary of how we think the TC should proceed based
> on the committee discussions so far. I think it closely matches what the TC
> agreed previously its position on the issue.
> I'm giving the Foundation Board a run through of this on Thursday (as the TC
> rep) to give them an opportunity to raise any red flags. Assuming all is well
> there, I expect we'll need to quickly go about updating the TC's policies on
> To be clear - all of this is still subject to a final TC vote.
> The full summary is here:
> but the tl;dr is:
> * Graduating from Incubation means a project is "Integrated", meaning
> it will be part of the next coordinated release
> * Which projects are accepted into - and graduate from - Incubation
> is the TC's decision
> * The "Core" designation is closely tied to the trademark programme
> managed by the Foundation Board
> * There should be no expectation that projects which graduate from
> Incubation will eventually be designated "Core". Projects will work
> with the Foundation Board - either before, during or after
> Incubation - to understand whether they are likely to be suitable to
> be "Core" in future
> Thierry did an excellent job of drawing this:
> Does this all make sense to everyone?
>  - I double-checked exactly what we agreed since it has been a while :)
> The position we voted for was:
> Separate the trademark question from the "developed under OpenStack
> umbrella" question, have incubation be the process by which you become
> supported, potentially with multiple categories as far as associated
> resources are concerned
> We called this the "annemark" motion which was a summary of this:
> The concepts of "what is core" and "what is in OpenStack" have been
> conflated until now. The TC cares far more about the process for new
> projects to be included in the coordinated release than it cares about
> which projects are required to be used by providers in order to access
> the trademark.
> We would like to take an inclusive but measured approach to accepting
> new OpenStack projects. We should evaluate any given proposed project
> on a well defined set of criteria like whether it embraces our values
> and processes, is useful to OpenStack users, well integrated with
> other projects and represents a sensible broadening of the scope of
> We see Incubation as a trial period where promising projects have the
> opportunity to demonstrate their suitability for inclusion in our
> coordinated releases.
> We see the term "Core OpenStack Project" in section 4.1.b of the
> bylaws as being solely related to trademark guidelines. The Foundation
> should simply maintain a list of projects required for trademark
> usage. We would be happy for that list to be called "Core Projects"
> or for a new name to be chosen to describe that list.
> with the addition of Anne's suggestion that some projects which are "in
> OpenStack" (what we're now calling "Integrated") might potentially receive
> different levels of resource commitment in terms of e.g.
> - track time at the Summit every six months
> - release management time at the weekly Project meeting
> - testing gated via DevStack and/or tempest
> - CI guidance
> - documentation guidance
> OpenStack-TC mailing list
> OpenStack-TC at lists.openstack.org
More information about the OpenStack-TC