Open Stack

On 11/05/2012 02:33 PM, Jay Pipes wrote:
> On 11/02/2012 12:56 PM, Mark McLoughlin wrote:
>> My opinion - the GCE work looks awesome, it's an exciting new feature
>> and it's the kind of awesome new feature by awesome developers that we
>> should be facilitating.
>>
>> We have a long term goal of facilitating work like this happening
>> outside of Nova, but no real sign of that goal coming about in the
>> medium term.
>>
>> We shouldn't let our idealistic long term plans get in the way of
>> pragmatic, exciting progress happening now.
> 
> Yeah, I mostly agree with what you're saying above and in the rest of
> the post. That said, however, the rub is that while the GCE work looks
> awesome, this whole topic came up, IIRC, because of the OCCI-compatible
> work that had been proposed. I personally didn't care for the OCCI work
> and didn't want it in Nova core.
> 
> While I personally wouldn't mind seeing the GCE work in core, because I
> think the work is better, it sets a precedent vs. the current
> "exception" of the EC2 API being in core.
> 
> Once there is precedent, we either need to let everything in, or we need
> to be picky about the winners and losers. The intent 6 months ago was to
> NOT pick winners and losers intentionally, and make a statement that we
> intended to only have the native REST API in core long-term.
> 
> If that decision is to be reversed, are nova-core folks willing to pick
> the winners and losers or if not, are they willing to let all comers
> into the code base?

I'm willing to help pick winners and losers.  Hopefully the standard
review process handles most of that already/  The code needs to be solid
to get in.  It also needs to be maintained.  If not, it shouldn't go in
or should get ripped out if it starts rotting (like Hyper-V).

-- 
Russell Bryant