Open Stack

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA256

On 06/17/2015 08:53 AM, Emilien Macchi wrote:
> Hi Serg,
> 
> On 06/17/2015 05:35 AM, Serg Melikyan wrote:
>> Hi Emilien,
>> 
>> I would like to answer your question regarding 
>> stackforge/puppet-murano repository asked in different thread:
>> 
>>> Someone from Fuel team created first the module in Fuel, 6
>>> months ago [1] and 3 months later someone from Fuel team
>>> created an empty repository in Stackforge [2]. By the way,
>>> Puppet OpenStack community does not have core permissions on
>>> this module and it's own by Murano team.
>> 
>> Murano was included to Fuel around 2 years ago, our first
>> official release as part of Fuel was Icehouse - yes, we have
>> puppet module for Murano for a long time now. But until recently
>> we didn't had a Big Tent in place and that is why we never
>> thought that we able to upstream our module.
>> 
>> Once policy regarding upstream puppet modules in Fuel changed and
>> Big Tent model was adopted we decided to upstream module for
>> Murano. I am really sorry that I didn't contact you for more
>> information how to do that properly and just created
>> corresponding repository.
> 
> Well, in fact, I'm sorry for you; you could not benefit of Puppet 
> OpenStack community. Let's fix that.
> 
>> I didn't give permission to Puppet OpenStack community for this 
>> repository because it would be strange, given I didn't even
>> contact you. We thought that we would upstream what we have now
>> and then make sure that this repo will be integrated with Puppet
>> OpenStack ecosystem.
>> 
>> We still have big desire to upstream our puppet module. Fuel is
>> not only user of this module, there are other projects who would
>> like to use Murano as part of they solution and use puppet module
>> from Fuel for deployment.
>> 
>> Can you advise how we should proceed further?
> 
> The more recent patch to add a module in OpenStack is zaqar: 
> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/191942/
> 
> Two things we need to solve is the fact if you move your module to
> the big tent: * bring the module compliant (I'm working on a
> blueprint to explain what is that, but you can already read what we
> said at the Summit: 
> https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/liberty-summit-design-puppet-compliant
>
> 
* figure out Gerrit permissions. If the module is official, it has to be
> maintained by Puppet OpenStack group, but that would mean you won't
> be core on it, which is weird to me at this stage. We are facing
> the same situation with puppet-monasca, (except the module lives in
> Stackforge for day1).
> 

When we suck sub-projects into infra, we often make the person or team
who was maintainer on it before it came into infra core on just that -
with the infra-core team on it as well. For instance:

puppet-murano-core:
  serg melikyan
  puppet-core

Or something. Not saying it's the right choice- just that it's the
pattern we've followed before over in our neck of the woods.

>> 
>> References: [1]
>> https://github.com/stackforge/fuel-library/tree/master/deployment/puppet/murano/
>>
>> 
[2] https://review.openstack.org/155688
>> 
> 
> Thanks for taking care of that!
> 
> 
> 
> __________________________________________________________________________
>
> 
OpenStack Development Mailing List (not for usage questions)
> Unsubscribe:
> OpenStack-dev-request at lists.openstack.org?subject:unsubscribe 
> http://lists.openstack.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/openstack-dev
> 

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1
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=4o2B
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----