- openstack-discuss - lists.openstack.org

Kubernetes cluster on top of OpenStack with kops
by Jaime Ibar 01 Oct '24

01 Oct '24

Hi all, anyone is using kops for deploying a kubernetes cluster on top of Openstack? Thanks Jaime -- Jaime

2 1

[all][tc][ptl][ptg] TC Discussions at the PTG - Sign Up and Suggest Topics
by Goutham Pacha Ravi 01 Oct '24

01 Oct '24

Hello Stackers, I'd like to highlight the Technical Committee's PTG planning etherpad [1], where we're organizing our discussions for the upcoming PTG. Over the next week, I aim to finalize time slots and prioritize discussion topics. Since TC discussions are cross-project, we'll do our best to avoid scheduling conflicts with project team meetings. To help with this, I encourage all interested parties to sign up or vote on the topics listed in the etherpad. Feel free to add any additional topics you'd like to discuss as well. Thank you! Best regards, Goutham Pacha Ravi (gouthamr) OpenStack TC Chair [1] https://etherpad.opendev.org/p/oct2024-ptg-os-tc

1 0

[all] [security] [ptls] Please review core security teams
by Jay Faulkner 01 Oct '24

01 Oct '24

Hi all, I'm writing on behalf of the Vulnerability Management Team (VMT). We often use the ${project}-coresec teams to determine who is best to help triage initial issues. These groups do not appear to be universally up to date. If you are in charge of a repo managed by the VMT ( https://security.openstack.org/repos-overseen.html#repositories-overseen ) please ensure the associated launchpad ${project}-coresec group has active, trusted members of your community -- or otherwise reach out to the VMT in #openstack-security to arrange other contacts if needed. For example, https://launchpad.net/~ironic-coresec/+members contains four longtime Ironic cores and former PTLs. (I'll note: I likely need to audit the equivalent group for Ironic-adjacent repos, and will do that after hitting send). This is extremely important! If we can't get an issue triaged and dealt with in time, it gets opened to the public. If there's any questions, feel free to respond here or reach out in #openstack-security on OFTC. Thanks, Jay Faulkner

1 0

[ironic] Postgres CI job broken
by Julia Kreger 01 Oct '24

01 Oct '24

Greetings folks, We had a little bit of a discussion on this subject in #openstack-ironic IRC earlier today[0], but the tl;dr is it appears the postgres integration CI job Ironic has had as a "canary" of support is now failing. This time it appears to be rooted in keystone[1]. Like our prior times of raising awareness, we're sending this email to the mailing list. Given the overall deprecation of postgres support many years ago, and the decline in postgres CI jobs in OpenStack, we believe it is time for us to remove this CI job. That being said, if someone wants such support to be fixed and rejuvenated, please consider this email your call to action. Thanks, -Julia [0]: https://meetings.opendev.org/irclogs/%23openstack-ironic/%23openstack-ironi… [1]: https://7d12977942ed9fbb75e4-56d2480851ef91de1634aa83a3abd804.ssl.cf1.rackc…

2 1

[Kolla-Ansible] [Ironic] Node Deploy Failed with MissingAuthPlugin
by Ali Hussain 01 Oct '24

01 Oct '24

Hi Kolla and Ironic folks, While playing with stable/kolla release to fix the No VIF found error. Looks like adding Readers role to ironic user fixed it. But run into Missing Auth plugin [2] issue while image is being deployed to ironic node. Openstack endpoint list command [1] shows the correct IP of the controller. My question is: 1. Kolla-Ansible needs explicite Ironic keystone configuration in Ironic.conf? Following this link <https://docs.openstack.org/kolla-ansible/yoga/reference/bare-metal/ironic-g…> which does not seems to need any keystone configurations. This issue is observed when 1. --boot-interface redfish-virtual-media 2. --deploy-interface ramdisk 3. --driver-info deploy_iso= 4. -instance-info kernel & ramdisk 2. My passwords.yaml has 1. ironic_database_password: 2. ironic_inspector_database_password: 3. ironic_inspector_keystone_password: 4. ironic_keystone_password: Any suggestions please. Thank you. Ali [1] openstack endpoint list | grep ironic | <ID> | <Region> | ironic-inspector | baremetal-introspection | True | internal | http://<IP>:5050 | | <ID> | <Region> | ironic | baremetal | True | public | http://<IP>:6385 | | <ID> | <Region> | ironic-inspector | baremetal-introspection | True | public | http://<IP>:5050 | | <ID> | <Region> | ironic | baremetal | True | internal | http://<IP>:6385 [2] *Error: *Detected change in error condition on node Node1. Deploy step deploy.deploy failed with MissingAuthPlugin: An auth plugin is required to determine endpoint URL.. An unhandled exception was encountered while aborting. More information may be found in the log file.

2 6

Automating Network VLAN Reconfiguration Post-Bare Metal Provisioning with OpenStack Ironic
by Hajasolo 01 Oct '24

01 Oct '24

Hello OpenStack Community, I am currently working with OpenStack Ironic for provisioning bare metal servers and facing a specific challenge related to network security and automation. I would appreciate any insights or experiences you could share! We use Ironic to provision bare metal servers, which involves utilizing a management VLAN during the PXE boot and initial OS installation process. Post-provisioning, the server’s management interface remains accessible, posing a security risk as it can potentially access the management network. I need to ensure that once a server is provisioned and handed over to a user, it cannot access the management VLAN until it is deprovisioned. 1. How can we automate the process of removing the management VLAN from the server’s network interface post-provisioning to prevent unauthorized access to the management network? 2. Upon server deprovisioning, how can we automatically re-enable the management VLAN to allow for server re-provisioning? 3. Are there any built-in OpenStack tools or common practices within the Ironic or larger OpenStack community to handle such scenarios? Our goal is to maintain a high level of automation and self-service capability in our OpenStack environment while ensuring rigorous network security standards. Solutions that integrate seamlessly with OpenStack’s existing architecture would be ideal. Thank you for your time and help! Best regards, Haja, Joel

2 1

[largescale-sig] Next meeting: September 18, 9utc
by Thierry Carrez 01 Oct '24

01 Oct '24

Hi everyone, The Large Scale SIG will be meeting this Wednesday in #openstack-operators on OFTC IRC, at 9UTC. You can doublecheck how that UTC time translates locally at: https://www.timeanddate.com/worldclock/fixedtime.html?iso=20240918T09 Feel free to add topics to the agenda: https://etherpad.opendev.org/p/large-scale-sig-meeting Regards, -- Thierry Carrez

3 3

[Glance] Weekly Meeting Cancelled (OCT 3)
by Pranali Deore 30 Sep '24

30 Sep '24

Hi All, As discussed during last week's meeting[1], the meeting for 3rd OCT has been cancelled. See you all next week!! [1]: https://meetings.opendev.org/irclogs/%23openstack-meeting/%23openstack-meet… Thanks, Pranali

1 0

[tc][all] OpenStack Technical Committee Weekly Summary and Meeting Agenda (2024.2/R-0)
by Goutham Pacha Ravi 30 Sep '24

30 Sep '24

Hello Stackers, After 26 weeks of effort across the community, we're finally at the release week for the 2024.2 release [1], codenamed 'Dalmatian'. I'll cue "Who Let the Dogs Out" for 2024-10-02 and toast the successful delivery of the 30th release of OpenStack with all of you. Congratulations, and thank you for your contributions in making this yet another on-time release. Please tune into the OpenInfra Live episode at 1400 UTC on 2024-10-03 [2], where you'll hear from a few Project Team Leads about the new and exciting things included in this release. Over the past week, the OpenStack TC assisted the release team in tagging a few deliverables, and on its behalf, I'd like to commend the release team for pulling out all the stops to ensure yet another on-time release. It takes a village, as Jeremy Stanley (fungi) noted on IRC — the happy, buzzing Stackerton village. We also merged some governance changes in the meantime. Notably, we adopted a community goal to move all existing Ubuntu testing to the latest LTS [3], and we retired several charms repositories after their consolidation into the Sunbeam-charms project [4]. I am pleased to welcome Dmitriy Rabotyagov (noonedeadpunk) as the Vice Chair for the TC, and I thank the outgoing Vice Chair, Dr. Jens Harbott (frickler), for his contributions during the 2024.2 release cycle. Next week, as we step into the 2025.1 ("Epoxy") release cycle formally [5], we'll switch into PTG and planning mode and chart out the remaining release priorities early. === Weekly Meeting === The Technical Committee's weekly meeting was held over IRC on 2024-09-24 [6]. We began the meeting by welcoming new members and thanking outgoing ones. We appointed a TC Chair (me) and a Vice Chair (noonedeadpunk) for the 2025.1 release cycle. We then worked through several 2024.2 release issues. We were presented with a peculiar, but familiar problem involving release deliverables that couldn't proceed without help from project maintainers who were unavailable during the release crunch. The release team prepares release candidate patches a week before the RC1 deadline and encourages project maintainers to vote on them. They also submit changes to the respective repositories to verify the state of the CI system to prevent releasing broken code. However, when a project team doesn't respond, there's a risk to the coordinated release. We brainstormed strategies to deal with the current conundrum. Thanks to noonedeadpunk and the attentiveness of project maintainers in Zun and Barbican, we were able to fix broken CI jobs and tag release candidates for some projects. However, we couldn't determine the state of "kuryr-kubernetes" and "kuryr-tempest-plugin." These projects, flagged earlier as unmaintained, are expected to be retired soon, so there are no releases from these projects in the 2024.2 release stream. If you depend on these projects, please let us know. We are looking for maintainers who can commit to reviving the CI and furthering these projects. The next OpenStack TC meeting is on 2024-10-01 at 1800 UTC. This meeting will be held simultaneously via video and IRC. Please find the agenda and other meeting details in our meeting wiki [7]. I hope you'll be able to join us. Remember, you can always edit the agenda and propose new topics! === Governance Proposals === ==== Merged ==== - Retire all single charm repositories | https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/governance/+/903490 - Select community-wide goal: migrate CI/CD jobs to Ubuntu Noble | https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/governance/+/929703 - Add 2025.1 TC chair and vice-chair | https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/governance/+/930376 - Add chair nomination folder for 2025.1 | https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/governance/+/929970 - Add GouthamR nomination for 2025.1 TC chair | https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/governance/+/929971 ==== Open for Review ==== - Appoint Tim Burke as PTL for Swift | https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/governance/+/928881 - Add Axel Vanzaghi as PTL for Mistral | https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/governance/+/927962 - Mark kuryr-kubernetes and kuryr-tempest-plugin as Inactive | https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/governance/+/929698 - Retire kuryr-kubernetes and kuryr-tempest-plugin | https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/governance/+/922507 === Upcoming Events === - 2024-10-02: OpenInfra Live - Introducing OpenStack Dalmatian 2024.2 [2] - 2024-10-08: OpenInfra Monthly Board Meeting: https://board.openinfra.dev/ - 2024-10-15: OpenInfra Days NA, Indianapolis: https://ittraining.iu.edu/explore-topics/titles/oid-iu/ - 2024-10-21: OpenInfra Project Teams Gathering https://openinfra.dev/ptg/ === How to Contact the TC === You can reach the TC in several ways: 1. Email: send an email with the tag [tc] on this mailing list. 2. Ping us using the 'tc-members' keyword on the #openstack-tc IRC channel. 3. Join us at our weekly meeting: The Technical Committee meets every week on Tuesdays at 1800 UTC [7]. Thank you very much for reading! On behalf of the OpenStack TC, Goutham Pacha Ravi (gouthamr) OpenStack TC Chair [1] 2024.2 "Dalmatian" Release Schedule: https://releases.openstack.org/dalmatian/schedule.html [2] Introducing OpenStack Dalmatian 2024.2: https://openinfra.dev/live/ [3] Goal: migrate CI/CD jobs to Ubuntu Noble: https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/governance/+/929703 [4] Retire all single charm repositories: https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/governance/+/903490 [5] 2025.1 "Epoxy" Release Schedule: https://releases.openstack.org/epoxy/schedule.html [6] TC Meeting IRC Log, 2024-09-24: https://meetings.opendev.org/meetings/tc/2024/tc.2024-09-24-17.59.log.html [7] TC Meeting Agenda, 2024-10-01: https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/TechnicalCommittee

1 0

Nova placement
by engineer2024 30 Sep '24

30 Sep '24

Is there a way to get back the correct used resources allocation data, in case of loosing the db ? Does placement update the allocation details after restarting the compute nodes to get the latest resources usage for that node ? Thanks elinux

2 2

[neutron] Proposing Ihar Hrachyshka as neutron stable core reviewer
by Brian Haley 30 Sep '24

30 Sep '24

Hello Neutrinos, I would like to nominate Ihar Hrachyshka for Neutron stable core reviewer (again). Ihar previously led the neutron stable core reviewer team a number of years ago, and I think he'd be a great re-addition to the team. Please vote with a +1/-1. Thanks, -Brian, Neutron PTL

6 6

[kolla] Proposing Matt Crees for Kayobe core
by William Szumski 30 Sep '24

30 Sep '24

Greetings Kayobians, I would like to propose Matt Crees as a core reviewer for Kayobe. With Mark Goddard stepping back from Kayobe maintenance duties, we have a slot to fill in the core team. In my opinion, Matt Crees is the strongest candidate for the position, having provided numerous reviews and contributions over the past few cycles. Please register any objections to this decision before the kolla meeting on 25th of September, otherwise I will proceed with making formal arrangements to get him added. Thanks Will Szumski will(a)stackhpc.com

6 6

[neutron] Bug Deputy report Sep 23 - 29th
by Oleg Bondarev 30 Sep '24

30 Sep '24

Hello Team, Nothing critical this week, 3 High bugs need assignees, 1 RFE to review by Drivers team. Full report for the week of Sep 23 is below: High: - https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/2081868 - LoggingDBApiTestCase.test_get_logs_bound_sg fails - Confirmed - unassigned - https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/2081870 - TestProcessMonitor.test_respawn_handler failed - Confirmed - unassigned - https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/2081871 - TestHAL3Agent.test_ha_router failed - Confirmed - unassigned - https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/2081945 - [postgresql] AttributeError: 'NoneType' object has no attribute 'id' - In progress: https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/neutron/+/930408 - assigned to Rodolfo Alonso Medium: - https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/2082066 - Logging not supported in unmaintained branches - In progress: https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/neutron-tempest-plugin/+/930546 - assigned to Rodolfo Alonso - https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/2082070 - [unmaintained] Errors in the "neutron-tempest-plugin-scenario-ovn" job - In progress: https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/neutron-tempest-plugin/+/930548 - assigned to Rodolfo Alonso - https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/2082344 - [unmaintained] ``NetworkWritableMtuTest`` test don't work in ML2/OVN - In progress: https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/neutron-tempest-plugin/+/930594 - assigned to Rodolfo Alonso - https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/2082880 - [ovn-octavia-provider] config registration hit DuplicateOptError - In progress: https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/ovn-octavia-provider/+/930670 - assigned to Rico Lin Low: - https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/2082883 - neutron-tempest-plugin: KeyError caused by missing 'previous' ref Edit - Confirmed - unassigned RFEs: - https://bugs.launchpad.net/ironic/+bug/2081847 - [RFE] Implement a new DHCP backend for Ironic and Neutron Edit - New - unassigned Thanks, Oleg

1 0

[kolla] [kolla-ansible]
by dariusz.bursztynowski＠pw.edu.pl 29 Sep '24

29 Sep '24

Hello, Are there plans for kolla-ansible to support Ubuntu 24.04 / ARM64 (to have LTS support for Raspberry Pi 5)? Best regards, Dariusz Bursztynowski

4 3

[Openstack] [Keystone] [Shibboleth] Assistance with Configuring Multiple IdPs in DevStack with Shibboleth Integration
by Abubakur Sait 28 Sep '24

28 Sep '24

Hi all, I have installed DevStack (release 2023.2) on Ubuntu 22.04 and integrated Shibboleth (the federation solution) with it. Everything works fine for a single IdP. However, I am looking to expand the setup to support multiple IdPs. I have read the Keystone documentation, but it doesn’t seem to cover this specific case. In my current setup, I have DevStack and Shibboleth integrated for a single IdP. I have read the shib-sp documentation as well. It mentions the need for a Discovery Service (DS) if we intend to use multiple IdPs which will be handled by the shib-SP software. This is the issue I am facing right now. Please see the following comments to get my point. Here’s the scenario I have so far: 1. A user accesses Horizon (Service Provider -- SP) at: http://192.168.4.103/dashboard/auth/login/?next=/dashboard/. 2. A drop-down list allows the user to choose the authentication method. The user selects the SAML IdP method. 3. The user is redirected to the IdP’s page where they authenticate. 4. The user is redirected back to the SP and successfully accesses the system. 5. The issue I’m facing is how to configure multiple IdPs so that users can choose from them at step (2). I understand that we can add a list of IdPs in the ~/horizon/openstack_dashboard/local/local_settings.py file to display in Horizon, but this doesn’t fully resolve the issue since the Shibboleth SP application itself doesn’t seem to handle multiple IdPs. Shibboleth SP typically expects a DS for multiple IdPs, but given that we already have a dropdown list in Horizon, do we still need the DS in this case? If not, how can we proceed with adding multiple IdPs in the system? Any guidance or advice would be greatly appreciated. Thank you for your help! Best regards, Bakur Sait

1 0

[octavia] Lose of some jobs by worker
by Payne Max 28 Sep '24

28 Sep '24

Hi, OpenStack community, I’ve faced a problem when some of our jobs can get lost by a worker, for example from the screenshot, SIGTERM was called in several seconds after receiving a job by a worker. [cid:image001.png@01DB1013.D648A630] Then there were no new log messages related to this job. Then our client complained that LB stucked in PENDING_UPDATE for several days and we started investigation. Our MySQL (persistent storage) is clean, but in our Redis, I can see several jobs without TTL and I think they are related to the «lost» jobs. [cid:image002.png@01DB1014.1DFF1BD0] Is it an ok situation? Can it be related to the https://github.com/openstack/octavia/blob/master/octavia/common/base_taskfl… Let’s discuss it!

4 6

kolla-ansible support for Ubuntu 2024.04/ARM64 ?
by dariusz.bursztynowski＠pw.edu.pl 28 Sep '24

28 Sep '24

Hello, Are there plans for kolla-ansible to support Ubuntu 24.04 / ARM64 (e.g., to have LTS support for Raspberry Pi 5)? Best regards, Dariusz Bursztynowski

1 0

[openstack]Problem with launching instances from VMDK
by Nguyễn Hữu Khôi 27 Sep '24

27 Sep '24

Hello I am trying create instance from vmdk but I have this error: The image format was claimed to be 'vmdk' but the image data appears to be in a different format. My cloud is Openstack 2023.1. This happened when We applied patches for CVE-2024-40767. Nguyen Huu Khoi

3 4

[release] Release countdown for week R+0
by Thierry Carrez 27 Sep '24

27 Sep '24

Development Focus ----------------- We will be releasing the coordinated OpenStack 2024.2 Dalmatian release next week, on October 2nd, 2024. Thanks to everyone involved in the Dalmatian cycle! We are now in pre-release freeze, so no new deliverable will be created until final release, unless a release-critical regression is spotted. Otherwise, teams attending the virtual PTG in a few weeks should start to plan what they will be discussing there, by creating and filling team etherpads. You can access the list of PTG etherpads at: https://ptg.opendev.org/etherpads.html General Information ------------------- On release day, the release team will produce final versions of deliverables following the cycle-with-rc release model, by re-tagging the commit used for the last RC. A patch doing just that will be proposed. PTLs and release liaisons should watch for that final release patch from the release team. While not required, we would appreciate having an ack from each team before we approve it on the 2nd, so that their approval is included in the metadata that goes onto the signed tag. Upcoming Deadlines & Dates -------------------------- Final 2024.2 Dalmatian release: October 2nd, 2024 Project Teams Gathering: October 21-25, 2024 -- Thierry Carrez (ttx)

1 0

help
by Gyan Dev Mishra 27 Sep '24

27 Sep '24

hi sir, was facing an issue with launching an instance in OpenStack. When I try to launch an instance using a Ubuntu Server 22.04 ISO image, I am getting the error. Even if I try with the default Cirros image, the instance launches, but when I attempt to access it from the console, I encounter a network error. I was trying to run it using an IP in the 10.x.x range, but it is fetching an IP in the 192.168.x range. I have attached the screenshot for the your reference. How can I resolve this issue? DISCLAIMER: This communication may contain confidential or copyright information. If you are not an intended recipient, you must not keep, forward, copy, use, save or rely on this communication. Any such action is unauthorized and prohibited. If you have received this communication in error please delete it. Reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure no viruses are present in this email, the company cannot accept responsibility for any loss or damage arising from the use of this email or attachments.

1 0

(외부메일) [heat][heat-cinder] How can I use the Cinder volume extend in Heat?
by 박광우 26 Sep '24

26 Sep '24

3 3

[ptl][release] OpenStack Dalmatian OpenInfra Live
by Allison Price 26 Sep '24

26 Sep '24

Hi everyone, I wanted to gather interest from PTLs to participate in an OpenStack Dalmatian OpenInfra Live on Thursday, October 3 after Wednesday’s release. Like past episodes (you can see Caracal here [1]), we will give interested PTLs the opportunity to present the progress their team made in 2024.2 Dalmatian as well as present upcoming priorities for 2025.1 Epoxy. The episode will air on Thursday at 1400 UTC, so interested participants would need to be available 1330-1500 UTC on Thursday, October 3. If you are interested, please let me know. Thanks! Allison [1 ] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3BgAXbFaVqw

5 6

Potential Mentorship Opportunities (Jan - May 2025)
by Kendall Nelson 26 Sep '24

26 Sep '24

Hello Party People! It's very early, but I wanted to float the information ahead of time :) Coming up for the next semester (Spring semester in Northern Hemisphere; Jan to May) we have the opportunity to propose projects to students at North Dakota State University to work on. Students will be in the last couple semesters before graduation with a Bachelor's degree in CS. Good projects would be scoped to a small group of students 3-5 working together for around 4.5 months (maybe 4 with onboarding, midterms etc). Mentors on these projects do not have to work alone - often I have two or three community members working together to mentor the students (ask Manila, they are a good example). I will want to start collecting project proposals (and mentor volunteers) in December before everyone leaves for the holidays but that still gives a fair amount of time for questions if anyone has them. I already have one team interested (Hi, Swift!) but would love a couple others to get involved. Let me know what questions you have or if you are interested in mentoring! -Kendall Nelson (diablo_rojo)

1 0

[ironic] [security] Ironic officially vulnerability-managed
by Jay Faulkner 26 Sep '24

26 Sep '24

Hi all, Although for a long time now, in practice, we've been using the Vulnerability Management team (VMT) process to triage, embargo, and resolve Ironic security bugs, we've now done the legwork needed to be officially managed by the VMT. The following Ironic projects are now VMT-managed[0]: - ironic - ironic-inspector - ironic-python-agent - ironic-lib - networking-baremetal - networking-generic-switch - python-ironicclient - python-ironic-inspector-client - sushy As per VMT policy[1]. the launchpad bug trackers for these projects have been updated to only allow access by the VMT to initial private-security bug reports. If there are any questions, please just ask! Thanks, Jay Faulkner 0: https://opendev.org/openstack/ossa/commit/b68aaa0652ec83b1349dddcdc334b7572… 1: https://security.openstack.org/repos-overseen.html#requirements (number 4)

1 0

[ceilometer] What's the general status / recommendation for Telemetry in OpenStack
by Waines, Greg 26 Sep '24

26 Sep '24

Hey ... I am working in OpenStack StarlingX which supports a Kubernetes cluster and a containerized OpenStack cluster (via openstack-helm). Our OpenStack offering is fairly simple ... only running Nova, Cinder, Neutron, Keystone, Glance, Horizon and Heat ... @ Antelope. In a predecessor of StarlingX, maybe in the Queens(?) timeframe ... we had a Telemetry solution that consisted of: - Ceilometer (for basic data polling, notifications and collection) - Panko (for event DB) - Gnocchi (for time-series DB) - Aodh (for alarming based on metric thresholds, etc.) HOWEVER ... today (Caracal) ... - I think Gnocchi is still alive and well ... https://github.com/gnocchixyz/gnocchi * but maintained outside of OpenStack - I think OpenStack Panko was deprecated in ~ Wallaby ? * and don't think(?) it is maintained outside of OpenStack ? - The OpenStack Landscape at https://www.openstack.org/software/ * shows only Ceilometer and Aodh MY QUESTIONs : ----------------------- - so what are the current recommendations for OpenStack Telemetry ? - is it just Ceilometer and Aodh ? * Does Ceilometer provide DBs ? (like it used to a long time ago) - is Gnocchi (although maintained outside of OpenStack) still supported in the OpenStack environment as a DB option ? - what is used for event DB ? ... now that panko is gone ... Gnocchi ? Ceilometer ? - are there actually multiple options/solutions for OpenStack Telemetry ? e.g. * Ceilometer / Gnocchi / Aodh * Ceilometer / External Elastic Solution / Aodh * Others ? Greg.

5 5