[openstack-qa] Tempest core cleanup motions - motion 2 - remove mordred
Attila Fazekas
afazekas at redhat.com
Tue May 21 20:44:53 UTC 2013
+1
----- Original Message -----
> From: "Sean Dague" <sean at dague.net>
> To: openstack-qa at lists.openstack.org
> Sent: Tuesday, May 21, 2013 5:53:44 PM
> Subject: Re: [openstack-qa] Tempest core cleanup motions - motion 2 - remove mordred
>
> Remembering that openstack-qa-core isn't an honor society, but is a
> working group of people that are actively engaged in the tempest code
> base, providing feedback to new contributors, and helping shepherd
> important features into Tempest. Removal doesn't mean judgement on the
> person, it just means that right now these are not active in driving
> this project through actively reviewing code.
>
> Remove the following folks from openstack-qa-core (the voting group for
> tempest): mordred
>
> Until this morning... (after I ran the stats) mordred hadn't done any
> reviews in the last 90 days. Monty's a busy guy, and his focus is
> clearly elsewhere. Him not being core doesn't mean we don't listen or
> engage with him, but Tempest and reviewing code in Tempest isn't his
> primary focus right now.
>
> There was previously an objection from Attila in the last round, but
> Monty himself responded and said he should be dropped -
> http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-qa/2013-May/000348.html
>
> On 05/21/2013 11:37 AM, Sean Dague wrote:
> > Ok, so the last thread died out a bit, but I still feel we need to move
> > forward. I'm going to break these into 3 separate motions (all will be
> > responses to this email, so the thread should be easy to follow).
> >
> > Voting rules: if you are currently tempest core, please vote +1, 0
> > (abstain), -1 for any of these. If you aren't tempest core, please refrain.
> >
> > We're going to call quorum 3 +1s (which is 1/2 of the currently active
> > tempest core folks) and 0 -1s. Any current tempest core out of the 12
> > (not just the active) that -1s a motion blocks it. Also, I realize that
> > from IBM we're 3 of the active cores, and as extra protection against
> > anyone feeling that one org is too dominant, I'm not going to count it
> > if the only +1s are from IBM, even though that would meet quorum.
> >
> > I also reran the 90 day review numbers this morning for reviews in
> > tempest this morning, they change a little because some chunk of the
> > prior reviews were apparently about 85 days old previously.
> >
> > ** -- tempest-core team member
> > +----------------------+-----------------------------------+
> > | Reviewer | Reviews (-2|-1|+1|+2) (+/- ratio) |
> > +----------------------+-----------------------------------+
> > | sdague ** | 173 (9|48|1|115) (67.1%) |
> > | cyeoh-0 ** | 150 (0|48|7|95) (68.0%) |
> > | afazekas ** | 146 (1|21|26|98) (84.9%) |
> > | david-kranz ** | 90 (0|13|3|74) (85.6%) |
> > | treinish ** | 64 (1|24|0|39) (60.9%) |
> > | ivan-zhu | 37 (0|8|29|0) (78.4%) |
> > | gfidente | 35 (0|4|31|0) (88.6%) |
> > | jaypipes ** | 34 (0|5|2|27) (85.3%) |
> > | donald-ngo | 18 (0|5|13|0) (72.2%) |
> > | jogo | 17 (0|3|14|0) (82.4%) |
> > | ravikumar-venkatesan | 17 (0|1|16|0) (94.1%) |
> > | andrea-frittoli | 16 (0|1|15|0) (93.8%) |
> > | psedlak | 13 (0|3|10|0) (76.9%) |
> > | adalbas | 13 (0|1|12|0) (92.3%) |
> > | lauria | 11 (0|0|11|0) (100.0%) |
> > | prekarat | 10 (0|4|6|0) (60.0%) |
> > | dwalleck ** | 7 (0|1|4|2) (85.7%) |
> > | igawa | 7 (0|0|7|0) (100.0%) |
> > | fungi | 5 (0|0|5|0) (100.0%) |
> > | jerome-gallard | 4 (0|0|4|0) (100.0%) |
> > | dachary | 3 (0|2|1|0) (33.3%) |
> > | rohitkarajgi | 3 (0|1|2|0) (66.7%) |
> > | maru | 3 (0|1|2|0) (66.7%) |
> > | mkollaro | 3 (0|0|3|0) (100.0%) |
> > | maurosr | 3 (0|0|3|0) (100.0%) |
> > | ayoung | 2 (0|1|1|0) (50.0%) |
> > | unknown | 2 (0|0|2|0) (100.0%) |
> > | johngarbutt | 1 (0|1|0|0) (0.0%) |
> > | cboylan | 1 (0|1|0|0) (0.0%) |
> > | armando-migliaccio | 1 (0|1|0|0) (0.0%) |
> > | akuno | 1 (0|1|0|0) (0.0%) |
> > | ymzk37 | 1 (0|0|1|0) (100.0%) |
> > | mpavlase | 1 (0|0|1|0) (100.0%) |
> > | dperaza | 1 (0|0|1|0) (100.0%) |
> > | bob-ball | 1 (0|0|1|0) (100.0%) |
> > | aloga | 1 (0|0|1|0) (100.0%) |
> > +----------------------+-----------------------------------+
> >
> > Previous posting here -
> > http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-qa/2013-May/000340.html
> >
> > -Sean
> >
> >
>
>
> --
> Sean Dague
> http://dague.net
>
> _______________________________________________
> openstack-qa mailing list
> openstack-qa at lists.openstack.org
> http://lists.openstack.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/openstack-qa
>
More information about the openstack-qa
mailing list