Open Stack

Remembering that openstack-qa-core isn't an honor society, but is a 
working group of people that are actively engaged in the tempest code 
base, providing feedback to new contributors, and helping shepherd 
important features into Tempest. Removal doesn't mean judgement on the 
person, it just means that right now these are not active in driving 
this project through actively reviewing code.

Remove the following folks from openstack-qa-core (the voting group for 
tempest): mordred

Until this morning... (after I ran the stats) mordred hadn't done any 
reviews in the last 90 days. Monty's a busy guy, and his focus is 
clearly elsewhere. Him not being core doesn't mean we don't listen or 
engage with him, but Tempest and reviewing code in Tempest isn't his 
primary focus right now.

There was previously an objection from Attila in the last round, but 
Monty himself responded and said he should be dropped - 
http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-qa/2013-May/000348.html

On 05/21/2013 11:37 AM, Sean Dague wrote:
> Ok, so the last thread died out a bit, but I still feel we need to move
> forward. I'm going to break these into 3 separate motions (all will be
> responses to this email, so the thread should be easy to follow).
>
> Voting rules: if you are currently tempest core, please vote +1, 0
> (abstain), -1 for any of these. If you aren't tempest core, please refrain.
>
> We're going to call quorum 3 +1s (which is 1/2 of the currently active
> tempest core folks) and 0 -1s. Any current tempest core out of the 12
> (not just the active) that -1s a motion blocks it. Also, I realize that
> from IBM we're 3 of the active cores, and as extra protection against
> anyone feeling that one org is too dominant, I'm not going to count it
> if the only +1s are from IBM, even though that would meet quorum.
>
> I also reran the 90 day review numbers this morning for reviews in
> tempest this morning, they change a little because some chunk of the
> prior reviews were apparently about 85 days old previously.
>
> ** -- tempest-core team member
> +----------------------+-----------------------------------+
> |       Reviewer       | Reviews (-2|-1|+1|+2) (+/- ratio) |
> +----------------------+-----------------------------------+
> |      sdague **       |      173 (9|48|1|115) (67.1%)     |
> |      cyeoh-0 **      |      150 (0|48|7|95) (68.0%)      |
> |     afazekas **      |      146 (1|21|26|98) (84.9%)     |
> |    david-kranz **    |       90 (0|13|3|74) (85.6%)      |
> |     treinish **      |       64 (1|24|0|39) (60.9%)      |
> |       ivan-zhu       |       37 (0|8|29|0) (78.4%)       |
> |       gfidente       |       35 (0|4|31|0) (88.6%)       |
> |     jaypipes **      |       34 (0|5|2|27) (85.3%)       |
> |      donald-ngo      |       18 (0|5|13|0) (72.2%)       |
> |         jogo         |       17 (0|3|14|0) (82.4%)       |
> | ravikumar-venkatesan |       17 (0|1|16|0) (94.1%)       |
> |   andrea-frittoli    |       16 (0|1|15|0) (93.8%)       |
> |       psedlak        |       13 (0|3|10|0) (76.9%)       |
> |       adalbas        |       13 (0|1|12|0) (92.3%)       |
> |        lauria        |       11 (0|0|11|0) (100.0%)      |
> |       prekarat       |        10 (0|4|6|0) (60.0%)       |
> |     dwalleck **      |        7 (0|1|4|2) (85.7%)        |
> |        igawa         |        7 (0|0|7|0) (100.0%)       |
> |        fungi         |        5 (0|0|5|0) (100.0%)       |
> |    jerome-gallard    |        4 (0|0|4|0) (100.0%)       |
> |       dachary        |        3 (0|2|1|0) (33.3%)        |
> |     rohitkarajgi     |        3 (0|1|2|0) (66.7%)        |
> |         maru         |        3 (0|1|2|0) (66.7%)        |
> |       mkollaro       |        3 (0|0|3|0) (100.0%)       |
> |       maurosr        |        3 (0|0|3|0) (100.0%)       |
> |        ayoung        |        2 (0|1|1|0) (50.0%)        |
> |       unknown        |        2 (0|0|2|0) (100.0%)       |
> |     johngarbutt      |         1 (0|1|0|0) (0.0%)        |
> |       cboylan        |         1 (0|1|0|0) (0.0%)        |
> |  armando-migliaccio  |         1 (0|1|0|0) (0.0%)        |
> |        akuno         |         1 (0|1|0|0) (0.0%)        |
> |        ymzk37        |        1 (0|0|1|0) (100.0%)       |
> |       mpavlase       |        1 (0|0|1|0) (100.0%)       |
> |       dperaza        |        1 (0|0|1|0) (100.0%)       |
> |       bob-ball       |        1 (0|0|1|0) (100.0%)       |
> |        aloga         |        1 (0|0|1|0) (100.0%)       |
> +----------------------+-----------------------------------+
>
> Previous posting here -
> http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-qa/2013-May/000340.html
>
>      -Sean
>
>


-- 
Sean Dague
http://dague.net