Open Stack

FYI we have submitted the heat template to the osops repo and is now pending review at gerrit.
Would appreciate the core reviewer of osops to have a look. Thanks!
https://review.openstack.org/#/c/351799/


From: Tong Li [mailto:litong01 at us.ibm.com]
Sent: Thursday, August 4, 2016 10:15 AM
To: Sun, Yih Leong <yih.leong.sun at intel.com<mailto:yih.leong.sun at intel.com>>
Cc: akapadia at mirantis.com<mailto:akapadia at mirantis.com>; Randal, Allison <allison.randal at hpe.com<mailto:allison.randal at hpe.com>>; Anni.Lai at huawei.com<mailto:Anni.Lai at huawei.com>; Brad Topol <btopol at us.ibm.com<mailto:btopol at us.ibm.com>>; brenski at mirantis.com<mailto:brenski at mirantis.com>; Barrett, Carol L <carol.l.barrett at intel.com<mailto:carol.l.barrett at intel.com>>; Catherine Cuong Diep <cdiep at us.ibm.com<mailto:cdiep at us.ibm.com>>; Brown, David L <david.l.brown at intel.com<mailto:david.l.brown at intel.com>>; defcore-committee <defcore-committee at lists.openstack.org<mailto:defcore-committee at lists.openstack.org>>; dn283x at att.com<mailto:dn283x at att.com>; ee550x at att.com<mailto:ee550x at att.com>; egle.sigler at rackspace.com<mailto:egle.sigler at rackspace.com>; Evans, Eileen <eileen.evans at hpe.com<mailto:eileen.evans at hpe.com>>; Elizabeth Kueper <ekueper at us.ibm.com<mailto:ekueper at us.ibm.com>>; Stewart, Gretchen <gretchen.stewart at intel.com<mailto:gretchen.stewart at intel.com>>; Janssen, Hank H. <hank.janssen at hpe.com<mailto:hank.janssen at hpe.com>>; huangzhipeng at huawei.com<mailto:huangzhipeng at huawei.com>; Jason Kennedy <jkomg at us.ibm.com<mailto:jkomg at us.ibm.com>>; Meyer, Jim <jim.meyer at hpe.com<mailto:jim.meyer at hpe.com>>; Johanna Koester <koester at us.ibm.com<mailto:koester at us.ibm.com>>; Woodburn, John L <john.l.woodburn at intel.com<mailto:john.l.woodburn at intel.com>>; McRoberts, Julie <julie.mcroberts at intel.com<mailto:julie.mcroberts at intel.com>>; kaneshige.kenji at jp.fujitsu.com<mailto:kaneshige.kenji at jp.fujitsu.com>; letucker at cisco.com<mailto:letucker at cisco.com>; liyongle at huawei.com<mailto:liyongle at huawei.com>; Cazares, Luz <luz.cazares at intel.com<mailto:luz.cazares at intel.com>>; manju.ramanathpura at hds.com<mailto:manju.ramanathpura at hds.com>; Bonell Manjarrez, Marcela <marcela.bonell.manjarrez at intel.com<mailto:marcela.bonell.manjarrez at intel.com>>; markmc at redhat.com<mailto:markmc at redhat.com>; mark.baker at canonical.com<mailto:mark.baker at canonical.com>; Apostol, Michael J <michael.j.apostol at intel.com<mailto:michael.j.apostol at intel.com>>; mvoelker at vmware.com<mailto:mvoelker at vmware.com>; nijaba at redhat.com<mailto:nijaba at redhat.com>; Strottman, Nissa <nissa.strottman at hpe.com<mailto:nissa.strottman at hpe.com>>; pchadwick at suse.com<mailto:pchadwick at suse.com>; Yeluri, Raghuram <raghuram.yeluri at intel.com<mailto:raghuram.yeluri at intel.com>>; rbryant at redhat.com<mailto:rbryant at redhat.com>; roagarwa at cisco.com<mailto:roagarwa at cisco.com>; Rob.Esker at netapp.com<mailto:Rob.Esker at netapp.com>; Rochelle Grober <rochelle.grober at huawei.com<mailto:rochelle.grober at huawei.com>>; Sodoma, Scott <scott.sodoma at intel.com<mailto:scott.sodoma at intel.com>>; Shamail Tahir <stahir at us.ibm.com<mailto:stahir at us.ibm.com>>; soniarvind at vmware.com<mailto:soniarvind at vmware.com>; TF4242 at att.com<mailto:TF4242 at att.com>; Travis Mcpeak <tmcpeak at us.ibm.com<mailto:tmcpeak at us.ibm.com>>; Vince Brunssen <brunssen at us.ibm.com<mailto:brunssen at us.ibm.com>>
Subject: RE: [interop-challenge] osops repo for heat Template


Yih Leong,
I would say yes. I am thinking if we can simply write some bash script (thinking curl) to drive the test and eventually upload the results. terraform should allow local-exec to run bash script but I have not tested that. I am totally open for better methods.

Thanks.

Tong Li
IBM Open Technology
Building 501/B205
litong01 at us.ibm.com<mailto:litong01 at us.ibm.com>

[Inactive hide details for "Sun, Yih Leong" ---08/04/2016 12:37:15 PM---That’s should works for now. I will get my team to uplo]"Sun, Yih Leong" ---08/04/2016 12:37:15 PM---That’s should works for now. I will get my team to upload the heat template to https://github.com/op

From: "Sun, Yih Leong" <yih.leong.sun at intel.com<mailto:yih.leong.sun at intel.com>>
To: Tong Li/Raleigh/IBM at IBMUS
Cc: "akapadia at mirantis.com<mailto:akapadia at mirantis.com>" <akapadia at mirantis.com<mailto:akapadia at mirantis.com>>, "Randal, Allison" <allison.randal at hpe.com<mailto:allison.randal at hpe.com>>, "Anni.Lai at huawei.com<mailto:Anni.Lai at huawei.com>" <Anni.Lai at huawei.com<mailto:Anni.Lai at huawei.com>>, Brad Topol/Raleigh/IBM at IBMUS, "brenski at mirantis.com<mailto:brenski at mirantis.com>" <brenski at mirantis.com<mailto:brenski at mirantis.com>>, "Barrett, Carol L" <carol.l.barrett at intel.com<mailto:carol.l.barrett at intel.com>>, Catherine Cuong Diep/San Jose/IBM at IBMUS, "Brown, David L" <david.l.brown at intel.com<mailto:david.l.brown at intel.com>>, defcore-committee <defcore-committee at lists.openstack.org<mailto:defcore-committee at lists.openstack.org>>, "dn283x at att.com<mailto:dn283x at att.com>" <dn283x at att.com<mailto:dn283x at att.com>>, "ee550x at att.com<mailto:ee550x at att.com>" <ee550x at att.com<mailto:ee550x at att.com>>, "egle.sigler at rackspace.com<mailto:egle.sigler at rackspace.com>" <egle.sigler at rackspace.com<mailto:egle.sigler at rackspace.com>>, "Evans, Eileen" <eileen.evans at hpe.com<mailto:eileen.evans at hpe.com>>, Elizabeth Kueper/Rochester/IBM at IBMUS, "Stewart, Gretchen" <gretchen.stewart at intel.com<mailto:gretchen.stewart at intel.com>>, "Janssen, Hank H." <hank.janssen at hpe.com<mailto:hank.janssen at hpe.com>>, "huangzhipeng at huawei.com<mailto:huangzhipeng at huawei.com>" <huangzhipeng at huawei.com<mailto:huangzhipeng at huawei.com>>, Jason Kennedy/Seattle/IBM at IBMUS, "Meyer, Jim" <jim.meyer at hpe.com<mailto:jim.meyer at hpe.com>>, Johanna Koester/Raleigh/IBM at IBMUS, "Woodburn, John L" <john.l.woodburn at intel.com<mailto:john.l.woodburn at intel.com>>, "McRoberts, Julie" <julie.mcroberts at intel.com<mailto:julie.mcroberts at intel.com>>, "kaneshige.kenji at jp.fujitsu.com<mailto:kaneshige.kenji at jp.fujitsu.com>" <kaneshige.kenji at jp.fujitsu.com<mailto:kaneshige.kenji at jp.fujitsu.com>>, "letucker at cisco.com<mailto:letucker at cisco.com>" <letucker at cisco.com<mailto:letucker at cisco.com>>, "liyongle at huawei.com<mailto:liyongle at huawei.com>" <liyongle at huawei.com<mailto:liyongle at huawei.com>>, "Cazares, Luz" <luz.cazares at intel.com<mailto:luz.cazares at intel.com>>, "manju.ramanathpura at hds.com<mailto:manju.ramanathpura at hds.com>" <manju.ramanathpura at hds.com<mailto:manju.ramanathpura at hds.com>>, "Bonell Manjarrez, Marcela" <marcela.bonell.manjarrez at intel.com<mailto:marcela.bonell.manjarrez at intel.com>>, "markmc at redhat.com<mailto:markmc at redhat.com>" <markmc at redhat.com<mailto:markmc at redhat.com>>, "mark.baker at canonical.com<mailto:mark.baker at canonical.com>" <mark.baker at canonical.com<mailto:mark.baker at canonical.com>>, "Apostol, Michael J" <michael.j.apostol at intel.com<mailto:michael.j.apostol at intel.com>>, "mvoelker at vmware.com<mailto:mvoelker at vmware.com>" <mvoelker at vmware.com<mailto:mvoelker at vmware.com>>, "nijaba at redhat.com<mailto:nijaba at redhat.com>" <nijaba at redhat.com<mailto:nijaba at redhat.com>>, "Strottman, Nissa" <nissa.strottman at hpe.com<mailto:nissa.strottman at hpe.com>>, "pchadwick at suse.com<mailto:pchadwick at suse.com>" <pchadwick at suse.com<mailto:pchadwick at suse.com>>, "Yeluri, Raghuram" <raghuram.yeluri at intel.com<mailto:raghuram.yeluri at intel.com>>, "rbryant at redhat.com<mailto:rbryant at redhat.com>" <rbryant at redhat.com<mailto:rbryant at redhat.com>>, "roagarwa at cisco.com<mailto:roagarwa at cisco.com>" <roagarwa at cisco.com<mailto:roagarwa at cisco.com>>, "Rob.Esker at netapp.com<mailto:Rob.Esker at netapp.com>" <Rob.Esker at netapp.com<mailto:Rob.Esker at netapp.com>>, Rochelle Grober <rochelle.grober at huawei.com<mailto:rochelle.grober at huawei.com>>, "Sodoma, Scott" <scott.sodoma at intel.com<mailto:scott.sodoma at intel.com>>, Shamail Tahir/Boston/IBM at IBMUS, "soniarvind at vmware.com<mailto:soniarvind at vmware.com>" <soniarvind at vmware.com<mailto:soniarvind at vmware.com>>, "TF4242 at att.com<mailto:TF4242 at att.com>" <TF4242 at att.com<mailto:TF4242 at att.com>>, Travis Mcpeak/Silicon Valley/IBM at IBMUS, Vince Brunssen/Austin/IBM at IBMUS
Date: 08/04/2016 12:37 PM
Subject: RE: [interop-challenge] osops repo for heat Template

________________________________



That’s should works for now.
I will get my team to upload the heat template to https://github.com/openstack/osops-tools-contrib/<heat><https://github.com/openstack/osops-tools-contrib/%3cheat%3e>

On the 2nd point, Heat itself doesn’t upload test results.
Are we also responsible for creating the “Test Result Upload Script”?


From: Tong Li [mailto:litong01 at us.ibm.com]
Sent: Thursday, August 4, 2016 5:10 AM
To: Sun, Yih Leong <yih.leong.sun at intel.com<mailto:yih.leong.sun at intel.com>>
Cc: akapadia at mirantis.com<mailto:akapadia at mirantis.com>; Randal, Allison <allison.randal at hpe.com<mailto:allison.randal at hpe.com>>; Anni.Lai at huawei.com<mailto:Anni.Lai at huawei.com>; Brad Topol <btopol at us.ibm.com<mailto:btopol at us.ibm.com>>; brenski at mirantis.com<mailto:brenski at mirantis.com>; Barrett, Carol L <carol.l.barrett at intel.com<mailto:carol.l.barrett at intel.com>>; Catherine Cuong Diep <cdiep at us.ibm.com<mailto:cdiep at us.ibm.com>>; Brown, David L <david.l.brown at intel.com<mailto:david.l.brown at intel.com>>; defcore-committee <defcore-committee at lists.openstack.org<mailto:defcore-committee at lists.openstack.org>>; dn283x at att.com<mailto:dn283x at att.com>; ee550x at att.com<mailto:ee550x at att.com>; egle.sigler at rackspace.com<mailto:egle.sigler at rackspace.com>; Evans, Eileen <eileen.evans at hpe.com<mailto:eileen.evans at hpe.com>>; Elizabeth Kueper <ekueper at us.ibm.com<mailto:ekueper at us.ibm.com>>; Stewart, Gretchen <gretchen.stewart at intel.com<mailto:gretchen.stewart at intel.com>>; Janssen, Hank H. <hank.janssen at hpe.com<mailto:hank.janssen at hpe.com>>; huangzhipeng at huawei.com<mailto:huangzhipeng at huawei.com>; Jason Kennedy <jkomg at us.ibm.com<mailto:jkomg at us.ibm.com>>; Meyer, Jim <jim.meyer at hpe.com<mailto:jim.meyer at hpe.com>>; Johanna Koester <koester at us.ibm.com<mailto:koester at us.ibm.com>>; Woodburn, John L <john.l.woodburn at intel.com<mailto:john.l.woodburn at intel.com>>; McRoberts, Julie <julie.mcroberts at intel.com<mailto:julie.mcroberts at intel.com>>; kaneshige.kenji at jp.fujitsu.com<mailto:kaneshige.kenji at jp.fujitsu.com>; letucker at cisco.com<mailto:letucker at cisco.com>; liyongle at huawei.com<mailto:liyongle at huawei.com>; Cazares, Luz <luz.cazares at intel.com<mailto:luz.cazares at intel.com>>; manju.ramanathpura at hds.com<mailto:manju.ramanathpura at hds.com>; Bonell Manjarrez, Marcela <marcela.bonell.manjarrez at intel.com<mailto:marcela.bonell.manjarrez at intel.com>>; markmc at redhat.com<mailto:markmc at redhat.com>; mark.baker at canonical.com<mailto:mark.baker at canonical.com>; Apostol, Michael J <michael.j.apostol at intel.com<mailto:michael.j.apostol at intel.com>>; mvoelker at vmware.com<mailto:mvoelker at vmware.com>; nijaba at redhat.com<mailto:nijaba at redhat.com>; Strottman, Nissa <nissa.strottman at hpe.com<mailto:nissa.strottman at hpe.com>>; pchadwick at suse.com<mailto:pchadwick at suse.com>; Yeluri, Raghuram <raghuram.yeluri at intel.com<mailto:raghuram.yeluri at intel.com>>; rbryant at redhat.com<mailto:rbryant at redhat.com>; roagarwa at cisco.com<mailto:roagarwa at cisco.com>; Rob.Esker at netapp.com<mailto:Rob.Esker at netapp.com>; Rochelle Grober <rochelle.grober at huawei.com<mailto:rochelle.grober at huawei.com>>; Sodoma, Scott <scott.sodoma at intel.com<mailto:scott.sodoma at intel.com>>; Shamail Tahir <stahir at us.ibm.com<mailto:stahir at us.ibm.com>>; soniarvind at vmware.com<mailto:soniarvind at vmware.com>; TF4242 at att.com<mailto:TF4242 at att.com>; Travis Mcpeak <tmcpeak at us.ibm.com<mailto:tmcpeak at us.ibm.com>>; Vince Brunssen <brunssen at us.ibm.com<mailto:brunssen at us.ibm.com>>
Subject: Re: [interop-challenge] osops repo for heat Template

Leong,
I have the same question. Since some of the projects are already in contrib repo, I suggest we continue using that unless someone create a brand new bearing openstack path of course. Here is what I suggest:

1. Still use this repo https://github.com/openstack/osops-tools-contrib for work load scripts, create heat sub directory at the location where terraform currently is. create other sub directories when other tools are adopted.
2. Find a restful api capable storage to save test results so that these work load scripts will automatically upload the test results to the location after each run (runner can indicate if the results should be uploaded or not with a flag)

Thanks.

Tong Li
IBM Open Technology
Building 501/B205
litong01 at us.ibm.com<mailto:litong01 at us.ibm.com>

[Inactive hide details for "Sun, Yih Leong" ---08/03/2016 02:04:09 PM---Hi all, In today interop-challenge meeting, the team dec]"Sun, Yih Leong" ---08/03/2016 02:04:09 PM---Hi all, In today interop-challenge meeting, the team decided to use the osops-tools-contrib repo [1]

From: "Sun, Yih Leong" <yih.leong.sun at intel.com<mailto:yih.leong.sun at intel.com>>
To: Johanna Koester/Raleigh/IBM at IBMUS, "Meyer, Jim" <jim.meyer at hpe.com<mailto:jim.meyer at hpe.com>>
Cc: "akapadia at mirantis.com<mailto:akapadia at mirantis.com>" <akapadia at mirantis.com<mailto:akapadia at mirantis.com>>, "Randal, Allison" <allison.randal at hpe.com<mailto:allison.randal at hpe.com>>, "Anni.Lai at huawei.com<mailto:Anni.Lai at huawei.com>" <Anni.Lai at huawei.com<mailto:Anni.Lai at huawei.com>>, Brad Topol/Raleigh/IBM at IBMUS, "brenski at mirantis.com<mailto:brenski at mirantis.com>" <brenski at mirantis.com<mailto:brenski at mirantis.com>>, "Barrett, Carol L" <carol.l.barrett at intel.com<mailto:carol.l.barrett at intel.com>>, Catherine Cuong Diep/San Jose/IBM at IBMUS, "Brown, David L" <david.l.brown at intel.com<mailto:david.l.brown at intel.com>>, "dn283x at att.com<mailto:dn283x at att.com>" <dn283x at att.com<mailto:dn283x at att.com>>, "ee550x at att.com<mailto:ee550x at att.com>" <ee550x at att.com<mailto:ee550x at att.com>>, "egle.sigler at rackspace.com<mailto:egle.sigler at rackspace.com>" <egle.sigler at rackspace.com<mailto:egle.sigler at rackspace.com>>, "Evans, Eileen" <eileen.evans at hpe.com<mailto:eileen.evans at hpe.com>>, Elizabeth Kueper/Rochester/IBM at IBMUS, "Stewart, Gretchen" <gretchen.stewart at intel.com<mailto:gretchen.stewart at intel.com>>, "Janssen, Hank H." <hank.janssen at hpe.com<mailto:hank.janssen at hpe.com>>, "huangzhipeng at huawei.com<mailto:huangzhipeng at huawei.com>" <huangzhipeng at huawei.com<mailto:huangzhipeng at huawei.com>>, Jason Kennedy/Seattle/IBM at IBMUS, "Woodburn, John L" <john.l.woodburn at intel.com<mailto:john.l.woodburn at intel.com>>, "McRoberts, Julie" <julie.mcroberts at intel.com<mailto:julie.mcroberts at intel.com>>, "kaneshige.kenji at jp.fujitsu.com<mailto:kaneshige.kenji at jp.fujitsu.com>" <kaneshige.kenji at jp.fujitsu.com<mailto:kaneshige.kenji at jp.fujitsu.com>>, "letucker at cisco.com<mailto:letucker at cisco.com>" <letucker at cisco.com<mailto:letucker at cisco.com>>, "liyongle at huawei.com<mailto:liyongle at huawei.com>" <liyongle at huawei.com<mailto:liyongle at huawei.com>>, "Cazares, Luz" <luz.cazares at intel.com<mailto:luz.cazares at intel.com>>, "manju.ramanathpura at hds.com<mailto:manju.ramanathpura at hds.com>" <manju.ramanathpura at hds.com<mailto:manju.ramanathpura at hds.com>>, "Bonell Manjarrez, Marcela" <marcela.bonell.manjarrez at intel.com<mailto:marcela.bonell.manjarrez at intel.com>>, "markmc at redhat.com<mailto:markmc at redhat.com>" <markmc at redhat.com<mailto:markmc at redhat.com>>, "mark.baker at canonical.com<mailto:mark.baker at canonical.com>" <mark.baker at canonical.com<mailto:mark.baker at canonical.com>>, "Apostol, Michael J" <michael.j.apostol at intel.com<mailto:michael.j.apostol at intel.com>>, "mvoelker at vmware.com<mailto:mvoelker at vmware.com>" <mvoelker at vmware.com<mailto:mvoelker at vmware.com>>, "nijaba at redhat.com<mailto:nijaba at redhat.com>" <nijaba at redhat.com<mailto:nijaba at redhat.com>>, "Strottman, Nissa" <nissa.strottman at hpe.com<mailto:nissa.strottman at hpe.com>>, "pchadwick at suse.com<mailto:pchadwick at suse.com>" <pchadwick at suse.com<mailto:pchadwick at suse.com>>, "Yeluri, Raghuram" <raghuram.yeluri at intel.com<mailto:raghuram.yeluri at intel.com>>, "rbryant at redhat.com<mailto:rbryant at redhat.com>" <rbryant at redhat.com<mailto:rbryant at redhat.com>>, "roagarwa at cisco.com<mailto:roagarwa at cisco.com>" <roagarwa at cisco.com<mailto:roagarwa at cisco.com>>, "Rob.Esker at netapp.com<mailto:Rob.Esker at netapp.com>" <Rob.Esker at netapp.com<mailto:Rob.Esker at netapp.com>>, Rochelle Grober <rochelle.grober at huawei.com<mailto:rochelle.grober at huawei.com>>, "Sodoma, Scott" <scott.sodoma at intel.com<mailto:scott.sodoma at intel.com>>, Shamail Tahir/Boston/IBM at IBMUS, "soniarvind at vmware.com<mailto:soniarvind at vmware.com>" <soniarvind at vmware.com<mailto:soniarvind at vmware.com>>, "TF4242 at att.com<mailto:TF4242 at att.com>" <TF4242 at att.com<mailto:TF4242 at att.com>>, Tong Li/Raleigh/IBM at IBMUS, Travis Mcpeak/Silicon Valley/IBM at IBMUS, Vince Brunssen/Austin/IBM at IBMUS, defcore-committee <defcore-committee at lists.openstack.org<mailto:defcore-committee at lists.openstack.org>>
Date: 08/03/2016 02:04 PM
Subject: [interop-challenge] osops repo for heat Template

________________________________




Hi all,

In today interop-challenge meeting, the team decided to use the osops-tools-contrib repo [1] for the template.
There is a terraform folder, however, there is no “heat” folder at the directory structure. Should we create one for “heat”?

How are we going to organize the directory structure in this repo for:
1. Templates for testing purpose (heat, terraform, etc)
2. Test results

Also, the README indicated that this osops-tools-contrib [1] place is untested and unverified.
Is there a plan for those “tested” template to move into osops-tools-generic [2]?

[1] https://github.com/openstack/osops-tools-contrib
[2] https://github.com/openstack/osops-tools-generic

Thanks!

---
Yih Leong Sun, PhD
Senior Software Cloud Architect | Open Source Technology Center | Intel Corporation
yih.leong.sun at intel.com<mailto:yih.leong.sun at intel.com> | +1 503 264 0610



-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-operators/attachments/20160808/c944554b/attachment.html>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: image001.gif
Type: image/gif
Size: 105 bytes
Desc: image001.gif
URL: <http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-operators/attachments/20160808/c944554b/attachment.gif>