Open Stack

On 4/12/2021 11:18 AM, Brian Rosmaita wrote:
> On 4/12/21 12:52 AM, 野村和正 / NOMURA，KAZUMASA wrote:
>> Hi everyone,
>>
>> Hitachi has developed the out-of-tree driver as Cinder driver. But 
>> wewant to deprecate the out-of-tree driver and support only the 
>> in-treedriver.
>>
>> We need to submit about ten more patches(*1) for full features which 
>> theout-of-tree driver has such as Consistency Group and Volume 
>> Replication.
>>
>> In that case, we have two options:
>>
>> 1. Submit two or three patches at once. In other words, submit two 
>> orthree patches to Xena, then submit another two or three patches 
>> afterprevious patches were merged, and so on. This may give reviewers 
>> thefeeling of endless.
>>
>> 2. Submit all patches at once to Xena. This will give reviewers 
>> theinformation how many patches remains from the beginning, but many 
>> pathesmay bother them.
>>
>> Does anyone have an opinion as to which option is better?
>
> My opinion is that option #1 is better, because as the initial patches 
> are reviewed, issues will come up in review that you will be able to 
> apply proactively to later patches on your own without reviewers 
> having to bring them up, which will result in a better experience for 
> all concerned.
>
> Also, we can have an idea of how many patches to expect (without your 
> filing them all at once) if you file blueprints in Launchpad for each 
> feature.  Please name them 'hitachi-consistency-group-support', 
> 'hitachi-volume-replication', etc., so it's easy to see what driver 
> they're for.  The blueprint doesn't need much detail; it's primarily 
> for tracking purposes. You can see some examples here:
>   https://blueprints.launchpad.net/cinder/wallaby
>
>
I concur with Brian.  I think doing a few at a time will be less likely 
to overwhelm the review team and it will help to prevent repeated 
comments in subsequent patches if you are able to proactively fix the 
subsequent patches before they are submitted.

Thanks for seeking input on this!

Jay

> cheers,
> brian
>
>>
>> Thanks,
>>
>> Kazumasa Nomura
>>
>> E-mail: 
>> kazumasa.nomura.rx at hitachi.com<mailto:kazumasa.nomura.rx at hitachi.com>
>>
>
>