Open Stack

 ---- On Mon, 08 Jul 2019 17:46:37 +0900 Lajos Katona <katonalala at gmail.com> wrote ----
 > Hi,
 > For networking-l2gw (and networking-l2gw-tempest-plugin) I can say that it is maintained (with not that great activity, but anyway far from rerirement).Is there anything I have to do to make this "activeness" visible from governance perspective?

Lajos,
networking-l2gw* had been retired around ~3 years back[1]. If networking-l2gw situation is active and fulfils the neutron stadium criteria, you can propose it back after discussing with neutron team. 

[1] https://review.opendev.org/#/c/392010/

-gmann 

 > Lajos
 > Bernard Cafarelli <bcafarel at redhat.com> ezt írta (időpont: 2019. júl. 6., Szo, 22:05):
 >  
 > 
 > On Sat, 6 Jul 2019 at 19:44, Mohammed Naser <mnaser at vexxhost.com> wrote:
 > Hi everyone,
 >  
 >  One of the issue that we recently ran into was the fact that there was
 >  some inconsistency about merging retirement of repositories inside
 >  governance without the code being fully removed.
 >  
 >  In order to avoid this, I've made a change to our governance
 >  repository which will enforce that no code exists in those retired
 >  repositories, however, this has surfaced that some repositories were
 >  retired with some stale files, some are smaller littler files, some
 >  are entire projects still.
 >  
 >  I have compiled a list for every team, with the repos that are not
 >  properly retired that have extra files (using this change which should
 >  eventually +1 once we fix it all: https://review.opendev.org/669549)
 >  
 >  [Documentation] openstack/api-site has extra files, please remove:
 >  .gitignore, .zuul.yaml, LICENSE, api-quick-start, api-ref, bindep.txt,
 >  common, doc-tools-check-languages.conf, firstapp,
 >  test-requirements.txt, tools, tox.ini, www
 >  [Documentation] openstack/faafo has extra files, please remove:
 >  .gitignore, CONTRIBUTING.rst, LICENSE, Vagrantfile, bin, contrib, doc,
 >  etc, faafo, requirements.txt, setup.cfg, setup.py,
 >  test-requirements.txt, tox.ini
 >  
 >  [fuel] openstack/fuel-agent has extra files, please remove:
 >  .gitignore, LICENSE, MAINTAINERS, cloud-init-templates, contrib,
 >  debian, etc, fuel_agent, requirements.txt, run_tests.sh, setup.cfg,
 >  setup.py, specs, test-requirements.txt, tools, tox.ini
 >  [fuel] openstack/fuel-astute has extra files, please remove:
 >  .gitignore, .rspec, .ruby-version, Gemfile, LICENSE, MAINTAINERS,
 >  Rakefile, astute.gemspec, astute.service, astute.sysconfig, bin,
 >  bindep.txt, debian, examples, lib, mcagents, run_tests.sh, spec,
 >  specs, tests
 >  [fuel] openstack/fuel-library has extra files, please remove:
 >  .gitignore, CHANGELOG, Gemfile, LICENSE, MAINTAINERS, Rakefile,
 >  debian, deployment, files, graphs, logs, specs, tests, utils
 >  [fuel] openstack/fuel-main has extra files, please remove: .gitignore,
 >  00-debmirror.patch, LICENSE, MAINTAINERS, Makefile, config.mk,
 >  fuel-release, iso, mirror, packages, prepare-build-env.sh,
 >  report-changelog.sh, repos.mk, requirements-fuel-rpm.txt,
 >  requirements-rpm.txt, rules.mk, sandbox.mk, specs
 >  [fuel] openstack/fuel-menu has extra files, please remove: .gitignore,
 >  MAINTAINERS, MANIFEST.in, fuelmenu, run_tests.sh, setup.py, specs,
 >  test-requirements.txt, tox.ini
 >  [fuel] openstack/fuel-mirror has extra files, please remove:
 >  .gitignore, .mailmap, MAINTAINERS, perestroika, tox.ini
 >  [fuel] openstack/fuel-nailgun-agent has extra files, please remove:
 >  .gitignore, Gemfile, LICENSE, MAINTAINERS, Rakefile, agent, debian,
 >  nailgun-agent.cron, nailgun-agent.gemspec, run_tests.sh, specs
 >  [fuel] openstack/fuel-ostf has extra files, please remove: .gitignore,
 >  LICENSE, MAINTAINERS, MANIFEST.in, etc, fuel_health, fuel_plugin,
 >  ostf.service, pylintrc, requirements.txt, run_tests.sh, setup.cfg,
 >  setup.py, specs, test-requirements.txt, tools, tox.ini
 >  [fuel] openstack/fuel-qa has extra files, please remove: .coveragerc,
 >  .gitignore, .pylintrc, .pylintrc_gerrit, MAINTAINERS, core, doc,
 >  fuel_tests, fuelweb_test, gates_tests, packages_tests, pytest.ini,
 >  run_system_test.py, run_tests.sh, system_test, tox.ini, utils
 >  [fuel] openstack/fuel-ui has extra files, please remove:
 >  .eslintignore, .eslintrc.yaml, .gitignore, LICENSE, MAINTAINERS,
 >  fixtures, gulp, gulpfile.js, karma.config.js, npm-shrinkwrap.json,
 >  package.json, run_real_plugin_tests.sh,
 >  run_real_plugin_tests_on_real_nailgun.sh, run_ui_func_tests.sh, specs,
 >  static, webpack.config.js
 >  [fuel] openstack/fuel-virtualbox has extra files, please remove:
 >  .gitignore, MAINTAINERS, actions, clean.sh, config.sh, contrib,
 >  drivers, dumpkeys.cache, functions, iso, launch.sh, launch_16GB.sh,
 >  launch_8GB.sh
 >  [fuel] openstack/fuel-web has extra files, please remove: .gitignore,
 >  LICENSE, MAINTAINERS, bin, build_docs.sh, debian, docs, nailgun,
 >  run_tests.sh, specs, systemd, tools, tox.ini
 >  [fuel] openstack/shotgun has extra files, please remove: .coveragerc,
 >  .gitignore, .testr.conf, CONTRIBUTING.rst, HACKING.rst, LICENSE,
 >  MAINTAINERS, MANIFEST.in, bin, etc, requirements.txt, setup.cfg,
 >  setup.py, shotgun, specs, test-requirements.txt, tox.ini
 >  [fuel] openstack/fuel-dev-tools has extra files, please remove:
 >  .coveragerc, .gitignore, .mailmap, .testr.conf, CONTRIBUTING.rst,
 >  HACKING.rst, LICENSE, MAINTAINERS, babel.cfg, contrib, doc,
 >  fuel_dev_tools, openstack-common.conf, requirements.txt, setup.cfg,
 >  setup.py, test-requirements.txt, tox.ini, vagrant
 >  [fuel] openstack/fuel-devops has extra files, please remove:
 >  .coveragerc, .gitignore, .pylintrc, .pylintrc_gerrit, LICENSE,
 >  MAINTAINERS, bin, devops, doc, run_tests.sh, samples, setup.cfg,
 >  setup.py, test-requirements.txt, tox.ini
 >  [fuel] openstack/fuel-docs has extra files, please remove: .gitignore,
 >  Makefile, _images, _templates, common_conf.py, conf.py, devdocs,
 >  examples, glossary, index.rst, make.bat, plugindocs, requirements.txt,
 >  setup.cfg, setup.py, tox.ini, userdocs
 >  [fuel] openstack/fuel-nailgun-extension-cluster-upgrade has extra
 >  files, please remove: .coveragerc, .gitignore, AUTHORS, LICENSE,
 >  MANIFEST.in, bindep.txt, cluster_upgrade, conftest.py,
 >  nailgun-test-settings.yaml, requirements.txt, setup.cfg, setup.py,
 >  specs, test-requirements.txt, tools, tox.ini
 >  [fuel] openstack/fuel-nailgun-extension-iac has extra files, please
 >  remove: .gitignore, LICENSE, MANIFEST.in, doc, fuel_external_git,
 >  requirements.txt, setup.cfg, setup.py, specs, test-requirements.txt,
 >  tools, tox.ini
 >  [fuel] openstack/fuel-nailgun-extension-converted-serializers has
 >  extra files, please remove: .coveragerc, .gitignore, LICENSE,
 >  MANIFEST.in, bindep.txt, conftest.py, converted_serializers,
 >  nailgun-test-settings.yaml, requirements.txt, setup.cfg, setup.py,
 >  specs, test-requirements.txt, tools, tox.ini
 >  [fuel] openstack/fuel-octane has extra files, please remove:
 >  .coveragerc, .gitignore, .mailmap, Gemfile, Gemfile.lock, HACKING.rst,
 >  LICENSE, MAINTAINERS, MANIFEST.in, Rakefile, bindep.txt, deploy,
 >  deployment, docs, misc, octane, requirements.txt, setup.cfg, setup.py,
 >  specs, test-requirements.txt, tox.ini
 >  [fuel] openstack/fuel-upgrade has extra files, please remove: .gitignore
 >  [fuel] openstack/tuning-box has extra files, please remove:
 >  .coveragerc, .gitignore, .mailmap, .testr.conf, CONTRIBUTING.rst,
 >  HACKING.rst, LICENSE, MAINTAINERS, MANIFEST.in, TODO, alembic.ini,
 >  babel.cfg, bindep.txt, doc, examples, openstack-common.conf,
 >  requirements.txt, setup.cfg, setup.py, specs, test-requirements.txt,
 >  tools, tox.ini, tuning_box
 >  [fuel] openstack/fuel-plugins has extra files, please remove:
 >  .gitignore, CHANGELOG.md, CONTRIBUTING.rst, HACKING.rst, LICENSE,
 >  MAINTAINERS, examples, fuel_plugin_builder, requirements.txt,
 >  run_tests.sh, setup.cfg, setup.py, test-requirements.txt, tox.ini
 >  [fuel] openstack/fuel-plugin-murano has extra files, please remove:
 >  .gitignore, LICENSE, components.yaml, deployment_scripts,
 >  deployment_tasks.yaml, docs, environment_config.yaml, functions.sh,
 >  metadata.yaml, node_roles.yaml, pre_build_hook, releasenotes,
 >  repositories, test-requirements.txt, tox.ini, volumes.yaml
 >  [fuel] openstack/fuel-plugin-murano-tests has extra files, please
 >  remove: .gitignore, murano_plugin_tests, openrc.default,
 >  requirements.txt, tox.ini, utils
 >  [fuel] openstack/fuel-specs has extra files, please remove:
 >  .gitignore, .testr.conf, LICENSE, doc, images, policy,
 >  requirements.txt, setup.cfg, setup.py, specs, tests, tools, tox.ini
 >  [fuel] openstack/fuel-stats has extra files, please remove:
 >  .gitignore, LICENSE, MAINTAINERS, MANIFEST.in, analytics, collector,
 >  migration, requirements.txt, setup.py, test-requirements.txt, tools,
 >  tox.ini
 >  [fuel] openstack/python-fuelclient has extra files, please remove:
 >  .gitignore, .testr.conf, MAINTAINERS, MANIFEST.in, fuelclient,
 >  requirements.txt, setup.cfg, setup.py, specs, test-requirements.txt,
 >  tools, tox.ini
 >  
 >  [Infrastructure] opendev/puppet-releasestatus has extra files, please
 >  remove: .gitignore
 >  
 >  [ironic] openstack/python-dracclient has extra files, please remove:
 >  .gitignore, CONTRIBUTING.rst, HACKING.rst, LICENSE, doc, dracclient,
 >  requirements.txt, setup.cfg, setup.py, test-requirements.txt, tox.ini
 >  
 >  [neutron] openstack/networking-calico has extra files, please remove:
 >  .coveragerc, .gitignore, .mailmap, .testr.conf, .zuul.yaml,
 >  CONTRIBUTING.rst, HACKING.rst, LICENSE, MANIFEST.in, RELEASING.md,
 >  babel.cfg, debian, devstack, doc, networking_calico, playbooks,
 >  requirements.txt, rpm, setup.cfg, setup.py, test-requirements.txt,
 >  tox.ini
 >  [neutron] openstack/networking-l2gw has extra files, please remove:
 >  .coveragerc, .gitignore, .testr.conf, .zuul.yaml, CONTRIBUTING.rst,
 >  HACKING.rst, LICENSE, MANIFEST.in, babel.cfg, bindep.txt, contrib,
 >  debian, devstack, doc, etc, lower-constraints.txt, networking_l2gw,
 >  openstack-common.conf, requirements.txt, setup.cfg, setup.py, specs,
 >  test-requirements.txt, tools, tox.ini
 >  [neutron] openstack/networking-l2gw-tempest-plugin has extra files,
 >  please remove: .gitignore, .zuul.yaml, CONTRIBUTING.rst, HACKING.rst,
 >  LICENSE, babel.cfg, contrib, doc, networking_l2gw_tempest_plugin,
 >  requirements.txt, setup.cfg, setup.py, test-requirements.txt, tox.ini
 >  [neutron] openstack/networking-onos has extra files, please remove:
 >  .coveragerc, .gitignore, .mailmap, .pylintrc, .testr.conf,
 >  CONTRIBUTING.rst, HACKING.rst, LICENSE, PKG-INFO, TESTING.rst,
 >  babel.cfg, devstack, doc, etc, lower-constraints.txt, networking_onos,
 >  package, rally-jobs, releasenotes, requirements.txt, setup.cfg,
 >  setup.py, test-requirements.txt, tools, tox.ini
 >  [neutron] openstack/neutron-vpnaas has extra files, please remove:
 >  .coveragerc, .gitignore, .mailmap, .pylintrc, .stestr.conf,
 >  .zuul.yaml, CONTRIBUTING.rst, HACKING.rst, LICENSE, TESTING.rst,
 >  babel.cfg, devstack, doc, etc, lower-constraints.txt, neutron_vpnaas,
 >  playbooks, rally-jobs, releasenotes, requirements.txt, setup.cfg,
 >  setup.py, test-requirements.txt, tools, tox.ini
 > At least for networking-l2gw* and neutron-vpnaas, I suppose this was caused by:https://opendev.org/openstack/governance/commit/20f95dd947d2f87519b4bb50fb188e6f71deae7c
 > What it meant is that they are not anymore under neutron governance, but they were not retired (at least as far as I know).There were still some recent commits even if minimal activity, and discussion on team status for neutron-vpnaas.
 > Not sure about networking-calico status though  
 >  [OpenStack Charms] openstack/charm-ceph has extra files, please
 >  remove: .gitignore
 >  
 >  [OpenStackAnsible] openstack/openstack-ansible-os_monasca has extra
 >  files, please remove: tests, tox.ini
 >  
 >  [solum] openstack/solum-infra-guestagent has extra files, please
 >  remove: .coveragerc, .gitignore, .mailmap, .testr.conf,
 >  CONTRIBUTING.rst, HACKING.rst, LICENSE, MANIFEST.in, babel.cfg,
 >  config-generator, doc, etc, requirements.txt, setup.cfg, setup.py,
 >  solum_guestagent, test-requirements.txt, tox.ini
 >  
 >  I'd like to kindly ask the affected teams to help out with this, or
 >  any member of our community is more than welcome to push a change to
 >  those repos and work with the appropriate teams to help land it.
 >  
 >  Mohammed
 >  
 >  -- 
 >  Mohammed Naser — vexxhost
 >  -----------------------------------------------------
 >  D. 514-316-8872
 >  D. 800-910-1726 ext. 200
 >  E. mnaser at vexxhost.com
 >  W. http://vexxhost.com
 >  
 >  
 > 
 > -- 
 > Bernard Cafarelli
 >