Open Stack

On Tue, Aug 30, 2016 at 03:25:30PM -0400, Emilien Macchi wrote:
> Here's my 2 cents:
> 
> The patch in puppet-ceph has been here for long time now and it still
> doesn't work (recent update of today, puppet-ceph is not idempotent
> when deploying RGW service. It must be fixed in order to get
> successful deployment).
> Puppet CI is still not gating on Ceph RGW (scenario004 still in
> progress and really low progress to make it working recently).

This does sound concerning, Giulio, can you provide any feedback on work
in-progress or planned to improve this?

> My opinion says we should not push to have it in Newton. Work to do it
> was not extremely pushed during the cycle I see zero reason to push
> for it now the cycle is ending.

I agree this is being proposed too late, but given it will be disabled by
default that does mitigate the risk somewhat.

Giulio - can you confirm this will just be a new service template and
puppet profile, and that it's not likely to require rework outside of the
composable services interface?  If so I'm inclined to say OK even if we
know the puppet module needs work.

Wider feedback welcomed, any more thoughts?

Thanks!

Steve