[openstack-dev] Fwd: FW: [Neutron] Group Based Policy and the way forward

Sumit Naiksatam sumitnaiksatam at gmail.com
Wed Aug 6 20:13:41 UTC 2014

On Wed, Aug 6, 2014 at 12:46 PM, Kevin Benton <blak111 at gmail.com> wrote:
>>I believe the referential security group rules solve this problem (unless
>> I'm not understanding):
> I think the disconnect is that you are comparing the way to current mapping
> driver implements things for the reference implementation with the existing
> APIs. Under this light, it's not going to look like there is a point to this
> code being in Neutron since, as you said, the abstraction could happen at a
> client. However, this changes once new mapping drivers can be added that
> implement things differently.
> Let's take the security groups example. Using the security groups API
> directly is imperative ("put a firewall rule on this port that blocks this
> IP") compared to a higher level declarative abstraction ("make sure these
> two endpoints cannot communicate"). With the former, the ports must support
> security groups and there is nowhere except for the firewall rules on that
> port to implement it without violating the user's expectation. With the
> latter, a mapping driver could determine that communication between these
> two hosts can be prevented by using an ACL on a router or a switch, which
> doesn't violate the user's intent and buys a performance improvement and
> works with ports that don't support security groups.
> Group based policy is trying to move the requests into the declarative
> abstraction so optimizations like the one above can be made.

Kevin, you have captured the GBP value prop and difference very
succinctly. The major difference is in the declarative (GBP) versus
imperative (current) style of programming.

This has been stated very clearly and explicitly in the blueprint
spec. If one does not appreciate the difference or advantage of one
over the other, then this discussion is pointless.

> _______________________________________________
> OpenStack-dev mailing list
> OpenStack-dev at lists.openstack.org
> http://lists.openstack.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/openstack-dev

More information about the OpenStack-dev mailing list