Open Stack

+1

I wanted to make sure that this group has had a chance to review before sending it to the TC to ask for help.  I'd like to expand the review by end of day.

Rob

From: Troy Toman [mailto:troy at tomanator.com]
Sent: Monday, May 05, 2014 2:24 PM
To: Hirschfeld, Rob
Cc: Defcore-committee at lists.openstack.org
Subject: Re: [OpenStack-DefCore] Moment Of Truth: based on current scores & non-admin requirement the list of capabilities is...
Importance: High

I believe we should make an effort to clarify the .5 votes - particularly for items "on the bubble"  Take security groups and floating IPs for instance. If floating IPs were to get a '0' for TC Future Direction, it would drop in the yellow territory. If security groups were to get a 1 for TC Future Direction it probably moves into the green. This is crucial give our desire to put things in core that will stay for a considerable length of time. So, if these make it in, then we are saying the Compute API will have to continue to support them. If Neutron is the preferred future interface for these features, it may be better to leave them out in the first pass and bring them in when Neutron is ready.

Perhaps Michael and Anne could take the lead on that particular column and how we get the proper TC clarification?

Troy

On May 5, 2014, at 11:50 AM, <Rob_Hirschfeld at Dell.com<mailto:Rob_Hirschfeld at Dell.com>> <Rob_Hirschfeld at Dell.com<mailto:Rob_Hirschfeld at Dell.com>> wrote:


DefCore,


THIS IS NOT FINAL.  Let me repeat THIS IS JUST THE FIRST PASS!!!!

We've still got a handful of capabilities to score BUT we've got a lot of them scored.  There's a pretty obvious break at 75 based on the flat weighting.

NOTE: Eliminating the Admin tests really cut down the number of core capability candidates.  I think that is the right course of action AND that we wanted a small core to start; however, we need to be prepared for the attention this will attract.

Over the next few days, we need
1)      Please reply +1 or w/ issues to this thread.
2)      Get the missing items at the bottom reviewed - this email is the start of that process
3)      Post some of the material about this list (linked below) and the list
a.       https://docs.google.com/document/d/1rxDkjcgPlYKuEmcV_Nigp1bSoMRrV7iyJMQ8fzwTr9M/edit
b.      https://docs.google.com/document/d/1sbP3YVFdj-zF4Q19OJoXWF9QdRSdJfCbW0dgblfOnBo/edit#<https://docs.google.com/document/d/1sbP3YVFdj-zF4Q19OJoXWF9QdRSdJfCbW0dgblfOnBo/edit>
4)      Tweak the capabilities list (Troy is leading this) if needed


I am hopeful that we can present this list as a preliminary list on Sunday to the board.  At this point, I'm thinking we should _not_ vote to approach but hold that until the meeting during OSCON.

Without further ado:

Candidate Capabilities

Score

compute-quotas

100

compute-servers

100

compute-volume

100

compute-flavors

96

compute-auth

92

images-v1

92

images-v2

92

objectstore-container

87

objectstore-object

87

compute-keypairs

83

compute-servers-metadata

83

compute-floating-ips

79

compute-images

79

compute-instance-actions

79

compute-security-groups

71

compute-image-metadata

67

compute-virtual-interfaces

67

<identity-non-admin-roles>

58

compute-limits

58

compute-usage

58

networks-extensions

58

compute-ext-disk-config

50

networks-l2

50

networks-l3

50

compute-live-migration

42

compute-servers-personality

42

networks-floating-ips

37

networks-security-groups

33

networks-lbaas

25

compute-multiple-create

21

orch-stacks

21

compute-attach-interface

17

networks-quotas

17

networks-vpn

17

compute-auth-v3

8



THIS IS NOT FINAL.  Let me repeat THIS IS JUST THE FIRST PASS!!!!


Unscored Capabilities:

objectstore-acct-services

objectstore-container-acl

objectstore-container-quota

objectstore-container-staticweb

objectstore-quotas

volume

volume-extra-specs

volume-multi-backend

volume-snapshots



THIS IS NOT FINAL.  Let me repeat THIS IS JUST THE FIRST PASS!!!!

Rob
______________________________
Rob Hirschfeld
Sr. Distinguished Cloud Solution Architect
Dell | Cloud Edge, Data Center Solutions
cell +1 512 909-7219 blog robhirschfeld.com<http://robhirschfeld.com/>, twitter @zehicle
Please note, I am based in the CENTRAL (-6) time zone

_______________________________________________
Defcore-committee mailing list
Defcore-committee at lists.openstack.org<mailto:Defcore-committee at lists.openstack.org>
http://lists.openstack.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/defcore-committee

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/defcore-committee/attachments/20140505/93aa2679/attachment-0001.html>