Vote results - translation importing policy
Hi, I got 13 answers for this vote. ( I'm very happy to see so many active people in this mailing list. That's great. ) Here is the result: 1. importing policy Vote results: 5a | 3b | 9c | 1d 2. Whether to keep the old translations in Horizon Vote results: 4a | 6b | 2c (language coordinator decided) So the final answer to these 2 questions are: 1. language coordinator decided 2. No @ Coordinators of completed translation teams: If you are NOT comfortable to import the translations of your language in Havanna RC1, please let us know. @ Coordinators of other translation teams: If you want to import your translations in RC1, please let us know. I see the translations of Spanish and Russian are very active. If you are not comfortable to import your translations in RC1, you still have chance to import them in RC2 and the final release. Please let us know your decision as soon as possible, so that Akihiro Motoki can start the importing. Thank you for your hard work! ---vote answers--- 1. importing policy c - language coordinator decided d - All b - 90% translated. a/c - 100% translated, or language coordinator decided (maybe not 100%) b - only if 90% translated is possible, otherwise A a/c - 100% translated, or language coordinator decided (maybe not 100%) c - language coordinator decided c - language co-ordinator decided a/b/c - but if around 95-100%, coordinator decided. c - Language coordinator decided a/c - 100% translated or coordinator decided (or active translator if no coordinator) a - I think 100 %translated should be our goal c - language coordinator decided 2. Whether to keep the old translations in Horizon b – No a - Older versions of translations if in the past had become part of any release should be kept. a - But 100% translated. If Long term support version, All keep. :) c - If no language coodinator b> No, else language coordinator decided a - c - If no language coordinator b> No, else language coordinator decided a - if no coordinator, else language coordinator decided b - b - b - "Yes" in general, but **NO** for Havana. b - b - No if there is such a technical reason as Akihiro mentioned. ------------ Regards Ying Chun Guo (Daisy)
Ying Chun Guo/China/IBM 2013/09/25 17:03
To
openstack-i18n@lists.openstack.org,
cc
Subject
Call for vote: translation importing policy
Hi, team
We are just before the translation importing, and we haven't gotten a consensus to the importing policy. Let's do a vote then. The vote will be opened for 24 hours. I only open this vote to i18n mail list yet. But I will publish the vote results to public mail list and ask for comments. The result of this vote will be used for Havanna RC1. If we got strong opposition from the public mail list, we still have chance to change it in Havanna RC2 and Havanna offical release.
Please let us know your opinion.
------------------------------------------------- 1. Which importing policy do you choose? (the policy to be used to import translations from Transifex to Horizon )
a> 100% translated b> 50% translated, ( or you can specify another percentage number ) c> language coordinator decided d> All languages in Transifex e> others ____________
2. Whether to keep the old translations in Horizon? (There are some old translation po/mo files in Horizon. They are old version. Most of them are not completed. )
a> Yes b> No
Regards Ying Chun Guo (Daisy)
Hi Daisy, As for Spanish, there is the 94% translated. We are almost there :) When exactly is the freeze? Just to know up until when we have time! Marian On 26 September 2013 09:45, Ying Chun Guo <guoyingc@cn.ibm.com> wrote:
Hi,
I got 13 answers for this vote. ( I'm very happy to see so many active people in this mailing list. That's great. )
Here is the result: 1. importing policy Vote results: 5a | 3b | *9c* | 1d 2. Whether to keep the old translations in Horizon Vote results: 4a | *6b* | 2c (language coordinator decided)
So the final answer to these 2 questions are: 1. language coordinator decided 2. No
@ Coordinators of completed translation teams: If you are *NOT* comfortable to import the translations of your language in Havanna RC1, please let us know.
@ Coordinators of other translation teams: If you want to import your translations in RC1, please let us know.
I see the translations of Spanish and Russian are very active. If you are not comfortable to import your translations in RC1, you still have chance to import them in RC2 and the final release.
Please let us know your decision as soon as possible, so that Akihiro Motoki can start the importing. Thank you for your hard work!
---vote answers--- 1. importing policy
c - language coordinator decided d - All b - 90% translated. a/c - 100% translated, or language coordinator decided (maybe not 100%) b - only if 90% translated is possible, otherwise A a/c - 100% translated, or language coordinator decided (maybe not 100%) c - language coordinator decided c - language co-ordinator decided a/b/c - but if around 95-100%, coordinator decided. c - Language coordinator decided a/c - 100% translated or coordinator decided (or active translator if no coordinator) a - I think 100 %translated should be our goal c - language coordinator decided
2. Whether to keep the old translations in Horizon
b – No a - Older versions of translations if in the past had become part of any release should be kept. a - But 100% translated. If Long term support version, All keep. :) c - If no language coodinator b> No, else language coordinator decided a - c - If no language coordinator b> No, else language coordinator decided a - if no coordinator, else language coordinator decided b - b - b - "Yes" in general, but **NO** for Havana. b - b - No if there is such a technical reason as Akihiro mentioned.
------------
Regards Ying Chun Guo (Daisy)
Ying Chun Guo/China/IBM 2013/09/25 17:03
To
openstack-i18n@lists.openstack.org,
cc
Subject
Call for vote: translation importing policy
Hi, team
We are just before the translation importing, and we haven't gotten a consensus to the importing policy. Let's do a vote then. The vote will be opened for 24 hours. I only open this vote to i18n mail list yet. But I will publish the vote results to public mail list and ask for comments. The result of this vote will be used for Havanna RC1. If we got strong opposition from the public mail list, we still have chance to change it in Havanna RC2 and Havanna offical release.
Please let us know your opinion.
------------------------------------------------- 1. Which importing policy do you choose? (the policy to be used to import translations from Transifex to Horizon )
a> 100% translated b> 50% translated, ( or you can specify another percentage number ) c> language coordinator decided d> All languages in Transifex e> others ____________
2. Whether to keep the old translations in Horizon? (There are some old translation po/mo files in Horizon. They are old version. Most of them are not completed. )
a> Yes b> No
Regards Ying Chun Guo (Daisy)
_______________________________________________ Openstack-i18n mailing list Openstack-i18n@lists.openstack.org http://lists.openstack.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/openstack-i18n
-- Marian
RC1 ( Release candidate 1 ) will be happened in this week. Then, there should be a RC2 (Release Candidate 2) around 2 weeks after (nobody know the exact date yet) The final release date is Oct 17th for Havana version. These 2 RCs and the final release are 3 chances for us to import our translations. So the final deadline should be several days before Oct 17th. I think 5 days before the final release should be a safely time. That is Oct 12th. Because you must leave enough time for developers to check in the translations. Do I make sense? Regards Ying Chun Guo (Daisy) Marian Tort <marian.tort@gmail.com> wrote on 2013/09/27 00:15:36:
Marian Tort <marian.tort@gmail.com> 2013/09/27 00:15
To
Ying Chun Guo/China/IBM@IBMCN,
cc
openstack-i18n@lists.openstack.org
Subject
Re: [Openstack-i18n] Vote results - translation importing policy
Hi Daisy,
As for Spanish, there is the 94% translated. We are almost there :) When exactly is the freeze? Just to know up until when we have time!
Marian
On 26 September 2013 09:45, Ying Chun Guo <guoyingc@cn.ibm.com> wrote: Hi,
I got 13 answers for this vote. ( I'm very happy to see so many active people in this mailing list. That's great. )
Here is the result: 1. importing policy Vote results: 5a | 3b | 9c | 1d 2. Whether to keep the old translations in Horizon Vote results: 4a | 6b | 2c (language coordinator decided)
So the final answer to these 2 questions are: 1. language coordinator decided 2. No
@ Coordinators of completed translation teams: If you are NOT comfortable to import the translations of your language in Havanna RC1, please let us know.
@ Coordinators of other translation teams: If you want to import your translations in RC1, please let us know.
I see the translations of Spanish and Russian are very active. If you are not comfortable to import your translations in RC1, you still have chance to import them in RC2 and the final release.
Please let us know your decision as soon as possible, so that Akihiro Motoki can start the importing. Thank you for your hard work!
---vote answers--- 1. importing policy
c - language coordinator decided d - All b - 90% translated. a/c - 100% translated, or language coordinator decided (maybe not 100%) b - only if 90% translated is possible, otherwise A a/c - 100% translated, or language coordinator decided (maybe not 100%) c - language coordinator decided c - language co-ordinator decided a/b/c - but if around 95-100%, coordinator decided. c - Language coordinator decided a/c - 100% translated or coordinator decided (or active translator if no coordinator) a - I think 100 %translated should be our goal c - language coordinator decided
2. Whether to keep the old translations in Horizon
b – No a - Older versions of translations if in the past had become part of any release should be kept. a - But 100% translated. If Long term support version, All keep. :) c - If no language coodinator b> No, else language coordinator decided a - c - If no language coordinator b> No, else language coordinator decided a - if no coordinator, else language coordinator decided b - b - b - "Yes" in general, but **NO** for Havana. b - b - No if there is such a technical reason as Akihiro mentioned.
------------
Regards Ying Chun Guo (Daisy)
Ying Chun Guo/China/IBM 2013/09/25 17:03
To
openstack-i18n@lists.openstack.org,
cc
Subject
Call for vote: translation importing policy
Hi, team
We are just before the translation importing, and we haven't gotten a consensus to the importing policy. Let's do a vote then. The vote will be opened for 24 hours. I only open this vote to i18n mail list yet. But I will publish the vote results to public mail list and ask for comments. The result of this vote will be used for Havanna RC1. If we got strong opposition from the public mail list, we still have chance to change it in Havanna RC2 and Havanna offical release.
Please let us know your opinion.
------------------------------------------------- 1. Which importing policy do you choose? (the policy to be used to import translations from Transifex to Horizon )
a> 100% translated b> 50% translated, ( or you can specify another percentage number ) c> language coordinator decided d> All languages in Transifex e> others ____________
2. Whether to keep the old translations in Horizon? (There are some old translation po/mo files in Horizon. They are old version. Most of them are not completed. )
a> Yes b> No
Regards Ying Chun Guo (Daisy)
_______________________________________________ Openstack-i18n mailing list Openstack-i18n@lists.openstack.org http://lists.openstack.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/openstack-i18n
-- Marian
Perfect. Will get Dutch (nl_nl) translation for Horizon at 100% before the 12th of October. 2013/9/26 Ying Chun Guo <guoyingc@cn.ibm.com>
RC1 ( Release candidate 1 ) will be happened in this week. Then, there should be a RC2 (Release Candidate 2) around 2 weeks after (nobody know the exact date yet) The final release date is Oct 17th for Havana version. These 2 RCs and the final release are 3 chances for us to import our translations.
So the final deadline should be several days before Oct 17th. I think 5 days before the final release should be a safely time. That is Oct 12th. Because you must leave enough time for developers to check in the translations.
Do I make sense?
Regards Ying Chun Guo (Daisy)
Marian Tort <marian.tort@gmail.com> wrote on 2013/09/27 00:15:36:
Marian Tort <marian.tort@gmail.com> 2013/09/27 00:15
To
Ying Chun Guo/China/IBM@IBMCN,
cc
openstack-i18n@lists.openstack.org
Subject
Re: [Openstack-i18n] Vote results - translation importing policy
Hi Daisy,
As for Spanish, there is the 94% translated. We are almost there :) When exactly is the freeze? Just to know up until when we have time!
Marian
On 26 September 2013 09:45, Ying Chun Guo <guoyingc@cn.ibm.com> wrote: Hi,
I got 13 answers for this vote. ( I'm very happy to see so many active people in this mailing list. That's great. )
Here is the result: 1. importing policy Vote results: 5a | 3b | 9c | 1d 2. Whether to keep the old translations in Horizon Vote results: 4a | 6b | 2c (language coordinator decided)
So the final answer to these 2 questions are: 1. language coordinator decided 2. No
@ Coordinators of completed translation teams: If you are NOT comfortable to import the translations of your language in Havanna RC1, please let us know.
@ Coordinators of other translation teams: If you want to import your translations in RC1, please let us know.
I see the translations of Spanish and Russian are very active. If you are not comfortable to import your translations in RC1, you still have chance to import them in RC2 and the final release.
Please let us know your decision as soon as possible, so that Akihiro Motoki can start the importing. Thank you for your hard work!
---vote answers--- 1. importing policy
c - language coordinator decided d - All b - 90% translated. a/c - 100% translated, or language coordinator decided (maybe not 100%) b - only if 90% translated is possible, otherwise A a/c - 100% translated, or language coordinator decided (maybe not 100%) c - language coordinator decided c - language co-ordinator decided a/b/c - but if around 95-100%, coordinator decided. c - Language coordinator decided a/c - 100% translated or coordinator decided (or active translator if no coordinator) a - I think 100 %translated should be our goal c - language coordinator decided
2. Whether to keep the old translations in Horizon
b – No a - Older versions of translations if in the past had become part of any release should be kept. a - But 100% translated. If Long term support version, All keep. :) c - If no language coodinator b> No, else language coordinator decided a - c - If no language coordinator b> No, else language coordinator decided a - if no coordinator, else language coordinator decided b - b - b - "Yes" in general, but **NO** for Havana. b - b - No if there is such a technical reason as Akihiro mentioned.
------------
Regards Ying Chun Guo (Daisy)
Ying Chun Guo/China/IBM 2013/09/25 17:03
To
openstack-i18n@lists.openstack.org,
cc
Subject
Call for vote: translation importing policy
Hi, team
We are just before the translation importing, and we haven't gotten a consensus to the importing policy. Let's do a vote then. The vote will be opened for 24 hours. I only open this vote to i18n mail list yet. But I will publish the vote results to public mail list and ask for comments. The result of this vote will be used for Havanna RC1. If we got strong opposition from the public mail list, we still have chance to change it in Havanna RC2 and Havanna offical release.
Please let us know your opinion.
------------------------------------------------- 1. Which importing policy do you choose? (the policy to be used to import translations from Transifex to Horizon )
a> 100% translated b> 50% translated, ( or you can specify another percentage number ) c> language coordinator decided d> All languages in Transifex e> others ____________
2. Whether to keep the old translations in Horizon? (There are some old translation po/mo files in Horizon. They are old version. Most of them are not completed. )
a> Yes b> No
Regards Ying Chun Guo (Daisy)
_______________________________________________ Openstack-i18n mailing list Openstack-i18n@lists.openstack.org http://lists.openstack.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/openstack-i18n
-- Marian
_______________________________________________ Openstack-i18n mailing list Openstack-i18n@lists.openstack.org http://lists.openstack.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/openstack-i18n
participants (3)
-
Marian Tort
-
Tom Verdaat
-
Ying Chun Guo