Hi Gibi,

Thanks for raising this issue here! Some notes:

- oslo.concurrency is in *independent* release model, thus it does not have stable branches since stable/victoria (when the model change happened) - for openstack projects (that are not in independent release model) upper constraint changes are generated automatically - for projects in independent release model these should be proposed manually for stable branches, if needed - lower constraints can only be bumped at development phase according to the policy [1] (i guess because this could lead to issues during upgrades of an existing environment), however, probably after weighing the circumstances, an exception can be granted

See my comments to your questions inline. (Anyone from Release Management or Requirements team: correct me if i am wrong with them)

[1] https://docs.openstack.org/project-team-guide/dependency-management.html#sta...

Cheers,

Előd

On 2022. 09. 28. 12:34, Balazs Gibizer wrote:

Hi,

So we have a bug[1] that was fixed in oslo.concurrency on master[2] and released as 5.0.1 and Zed is released with 5.0.1.

The issue is present in stable/yoga as well. There we have oslo.concurrency upper constraint pinned to 4.5.0 [3].

1. How can I backport [2] to the 4.5.x series of oslo.concurrency to

release 4.5.2 with the fix? I don't see a branch that I could use for this.

Either we use 5.0.1 for stable/yoga as well, or a bugfix/4.5.0 branch can be cut (e.g. from 4.5.1 release) and 4.5.2 released from that (maybe need to be released by hand as our tools don't support this if i'm not mistaken)

2. If #1) is solved and 4.5.2 is released can I propose an upper

constraint bump on stable/yoga from 4.5.0 to 4.5.2?

As I wrote above, i think it's possible, but needs to be done manually

3. If #1) and #2) is done. Can I propose a minimum requirement bump in

nova's requirements.txt from >= 4.5.0 to >= 4.5.2 on stable/yoga?

If i understand correctly, simply bumping the upper constraint would resolve our issue, so this is probably not needed. But as I said above, it can be considered to raise it anyway.

Cheers, gibi

[1] https://bugs.launchpad.net/nova/+bug/1988311 [2] https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/oslo.concurrency/+/855714 [3] https://github.com/openstack/requirements/blob/e64217c9f9316675f57e14ff559bb...