[tc][heat][tacker] Discusssion about heat-translater and tosca-parser maintenance
Hi,
I'm a tacker team member. I'd like to discuss how to maintain heat-translator[1] and tosca-parser[2] repositories.
These 2 repositories have not been updated so actively, but tacker often requires code updates for these repositories. Recently, patch merge progress of tacker and these repo do not sometimes match, which affects the development of tacker. For example, our some functional tests on zuul fail because these master codes are not updated.
Therefore, tacker members would like to take part more in these 2 developments. Tacker members have already started code reviews, patch posts, etc. If possible, we want some Tacker members to join the core team in the near future.
How about this?
[1] https://opendev.org/openstack/heat-translator [2] https://opendev.org/openstack/tosca-parser
Regards, Toshiaki
@spzala and I have been maintaining, as best we can, tosca-parser and heat-translator for the past several years, though our day jobs have moved on to other things. This hasn't been a problem because of the extremely low activity in both projects, mostly updating for releases and handling a bug fix every once in a while. While there has been a flurry of new activity in the past week, we are unaware of any issues in these repos causing Tacker build failures or blocking any progress.
I know I would be more than happy to add to the core team with the goal of eventually handing off maintenance responsibilities, and I'm pretty sure Sahdev will agree.
I'll be back in the office next week, for about a week or so, then off the rest of the year. I'm glad to start discussions now and plan to start making changes in January, if that works.
Thanks,
Bob
On 11/27/2020 7:15 AM, TAKAHASHI TOSHIAKI(高橋 敏明) wrote:
Hi,
I'm a tacker team member. I'd like to discuss how to maintain heat-translator[1] and tosca-parser[2] repositories.
These 2 repositories have not been updated so actively, but tacker often requires code updates for these repositories. Recently, patch merge progress of tacker and these repo do not sometimes match, which affects the development of tacker. For example, our some functional tests on zuul fail because these master codes are not updated.
Therefore, tacker members would like to take part more in these 2 developments. Tacker members have already started code reviews, patch posts, etc. If possible, we want some Tacker members to join the core team in the near future.
How about this?
[1] https://opendev.org/openstack/heat-translator [2] https://opendev.org/openstack/tosca-parser
Regards, Toshiaki
---- On Fri, 27 Nov 2020 09:09:41 -0600 HADDLETON, Robert W (Bob) bob.haddleton@nokia.com wrote ----
@spzala and I have been maintaining, as best we can, tosca-parser and heat-translator for the past several years, though our day jobs have moved on to other things. This hasn't been a problem because of the extremely low activity in both projects, mostly updating for releases and handling a bug fix every once in a while. While there has been a flurry of new activity in the past week, we are unaware of any issues in these repos causing Tacker build failures or blocking any progress.
I know I would be more than happy to add to the core team with the goal of eventually handing off maintenance responsibilities, and I'm pretty sure Sahdev will agree.
I'll be back in the office next week, for about a week or so, then off the rest of the year. I'm glad to start discussions now and plan to start making changes in January, if that works.
+1. That is a good idea to have more maintainer from the different team which is done in much other repo too like horizon UI, devstack plugins repo. Both of these repos are under the Heat project and Rico (heat PTL) also can help with this.
-gmann
Thanks,
Bob
On 11/27/2020 7:15 AM, TAKAHASHI TOSHIAKI(高橋 敏明) wrote:
Hi,
I'm a tacker team member. I'd like to discuss how to maintain heat-translator[1] and tosca-parser[2] repositories.
These 2 repositories have not been updated so actively, but tacker often requires code updates for these repositories. Recently, patch merge progress of tacker and these repo do not sometimes match, which affects the development of tacker. For example, our some functional tests on zuul fail because these master codes are not updated.
Therefore, tacker members would like to take part more in these 2 developments. Tacker members have already started code reviews, patch posts, etc. If possible, we want some Tacker members to join the core team in the near future.
How about this?
[1] https://opendev.org/openstack/heat-translator [2] https://opendev.org/openstack/tosca-parser
Regards, Toshiaki
Hi Bob, gmann, and Tacker team,
Thank you for the reply. OK, first of all, our Tacker team will continue activities such as reviews so that we can work as a core of heat-translater and tosca-parser. For our team, there is no problem with our development if we can maintain the master code of those repo.
How can we proceed with this? Should we give member names who will become core? Need to discuss with Heat, tc, etc.?
And I'd like to continue to discuss other points such as cooperation with other members(Heat, or is there any users of those?). We will continue to talk about it in the Tacker team, and suggest again if there is some necessary discussion.
Regards, Toshiaki
-----Original Message----- From: Ghanshyam Mann gmann@ghanshyammann.com Sent: Saturday, November 28, 2020 12:21 AM To: HADDLETON, Robert W (Bob) bob.haddleton@nokia.com Cc: openstack-discuss openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org Subject: Re: [tc][heat][tacker][tosca-parser][heat-translator] Discusssion about heat-translater and tosca-parser maintenance
---- On Fri, 27 Nov 2020 09:09:41 -0600 HADDLETON, Robert W (Bob) bob.haddleton@nokia.com wrote ---- > @spzala and I have been maintaining, as best we can, tosca-parser and > heat-translator for the past several years, though our day jobs have > moved on to other things. This hasn't been a problem because of the > extremely low activity in both projects, mostly updating for releases > and handling a bug fix every once in a while. While there has been a > flurry of new activity in the past week, we are unaware of any issues in > these repos causing Tacker build failures or blocking any progress.
I know I would be more than happy to add to the core team with the goal > of
eventually handing off maintenance responsibilities, and I'm pretty > sure Sahdev will agree.
I'll be back in the office next week, for about a week or so, then off > the rest
of the year. I'm glad to start discussions now and plan to > start making changes in January, if that works.
+1. That is a good idea to have more maintainer from the different team +which is done in much other repo too like horizon UI, devstack plugins repo. Both of these repos are under the Heat project and Rico (heat PTL) also can help with this.
-gmann
Thanks,
Bob
On 11/27/2020 7:15 AM, TAKAHASHI TOSHIAKI(高橋 敏明) wrote:
Hi,
I'm a tacker team member. I'd like to discuss how to maintain heat-translator[1] and tosca-parser[2]
repositories.
These 2 repositories have not been updated so actively, but tacker often
requires code updates for these repositories.
Recently, patch merge progress of tacker and these repo do not sometimes
match, which affects the development of tacker.
For example, our some functional tests on zuul fail because these master
codes are not updated.
Therefore, tacker members would like to take part more in these 2
developments.
Tacker members have already started code reviews, patch posts, etc. If possible, we want some Tacker members to join the core team in the near
future.
How about this?
[1] https://opendev.org/openstack/heat-translator [2] https://opendev.org/openstack/tosca-parser
Regards, Toshiaki
On Mon, Nov 30, 2020 at 11:06 AM TAKAHASHI TOSHIAKI(高橋 敏明) < ts-takahashi@nec.com> wrote:
Need to discuss with Heat, tc, etc.?
And I'd like to continue to discuss other points such as cooperation with
other members(Heat, or is there any users of those?).
I don't think you need further discussion with tc as there still are ways for your patch to get reviewed, release package, or for you to join heat-translator-core team As we treat heat translator as a separated team, I'm definitely +1 on any decision from Bob. So not necessary to discuss with heat core team unless you find it difficult to achieve above tasks. I'm more than happy to provide help if needed.
-- May The Force of OpenStack Be With You, Rico Lin irc: ricolin
Hi Rico,
Thanks. OK, we’ll discuss with Bob to proceed with development of the projects.
Regards, Toshiaki
From: Rico Lin rico.lin.guanyu@gmail.com Sent: Monday, November 30, 2020 4:34 PM To: openstack-discuss openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org Subject: Re: [tc][heat][tacker][tosca-parser][heat-translator] Discusssion about heat-translater and tosca-parser maintenance
On Mon, Nov 30, 2020 at 11:06 AM TAKAHASHI TOSHIAKI(高橋 敏明) <ts-takahashi@nec.commailto:ts-takahashi@nec.com> wrote:
Need to discuss with Heat, tc, etc.?
And I'd like to continue to discuss other points such as cooperation with other members(Heat, or is there any users of those?).
I don't think you need further discussion with tc as there still are ways for your patch to get reviewed, release package, or for you to join heat-translator-core team As we treat heat translator as a separated team, I'm definitely +1 on any decision from Bob. So not necessary to discuss with heat core team unless you find it difficult to achieve above tasks. I'm more than happy to provide help if needed.
-- May The Force of OpenStack Be With You, Rico Lin irc: ricolin
Hi Bob and Sahdev
I’m Ueha from tacker team. Thank you for reviewing my patch on the Victria release.
Excuse me during the discussion about maintenance. I posted a new bug fix patch for policies validate. Could you review it? Thanks! https://bugs.launchpad.net/tosca-parser/+bug/1903233 https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/tosca-parser/+/763144
Best regards, Ueha
From: TAKAHASHI TOSHIAKI(高橋 敏明) ts-takahashi@nec.com Sent: Monday, November 30, 2020 6:09 PM To: Rico Lin rico.lin.guanyu@gmail.com; openstack-discuss openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org Subject: RE: [tc][heat][tacker][tosca-parser][heat-translator] Discusssion about heat-translater and tosca-parser maintenance
Hi Rico,
Thanks. OK, we’ll discuss with Bob to proceed with development of the projects.
Regards, Toshiaki
From: Rico Lin <rico.lin.guanyu@gmail.commailto:rico.lin.guanyu@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, November 30, 2020 4:34 PM To: openstack-discuss <openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.orgmailto:openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org> Subject: Re: [tc][heat][tacker][tosca-parser][heat-translator] Discusssion about heat-translater and tosca-parser maintenance
On Mon, Nov 30, 2020 at 11:06 AM TAKAHASHI TOSHIAKI(高橋 敏明) <ts-takahashi@nec.commailto:ts-takahashi@nec.com> wrote:
Need to discuss with Heat, tc, etc.?
And I'd like to continue to discuss other points such as cooperation with other members(Heat, or is there any users of those?).
I don't think you need further discussion with tc as there still are ways for your patch to get reviewed, release package, or for you to join heat-translator-core team As we treat heat translator as a separated team, I'm definitely +1 on any decision from Bob. So not necessary to discuss with heat core team unless you find it difficult to achieve above tasks. I'm more than happy to provide help if needed.
-- May The Force of OpenStack Be With You, Rico Lin irc: ricolin
Hi Bob and Sahdev,
Tacker team has started to discuss, and at least 5 members want to participate in the maintenance of heat-translator and tosca-parser.
In my understanding, heat-translator and tosca-parser are different projects and core team is different. We’d like to different members to participate each core team. Is it OK? Should I send the name list to you?
Best regards, Toshiaki
From: ueha.ayumu@fujitsu.com ueha.ayumu@fujitsu.com Sent: Tuesday, December 1, 2020 9:25 AM To: openstack-discuss openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org Subject: RE: [tc][heat][tacker][tosca-parser][heat-translator] Discusssion about heat-translater and tosca-parser maintenance
Hi Bob and Sahdev
I’m Ueha from tacker team. Thank you for reviewing my patch on the Victria release.
Excuse me during the discussion about maintenance. I posted a new bug fix patch for policies validate. Could you review it? Thanks! https://bugs.launchpad.net/tosca-parser/+bug/1903233 https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/tosca-parser/+/763144
Best regards, Ueha
From: TAKAHASHI TOSHIAKI(高橋 敏明) <ts-takahashi@nec.commailto:ts-takahashi@nec.com> Sent: Monday, November 30, 2020 6:09 PM To: Rico Lin <rico.lin.guanyu@gmail.commailto:rico.lin.guanyu@gmail.com>; openstack-discuss <openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.orgmailto:openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org> Subject: RE: [tc][heat][tacker][tosca-parser][heat-translator] Discusssion about heat-translater and tosca-parser maintenance
Hi Rico,
Thanks. OK, we’ll discuss with Bob to proceed with development of the projects.
Regards, Toshiaki
From: Rico Lin <rico.lin.guanyu@gmail.commailto:rico.lin.guanyu@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, November 30, 2020 4:34 PM To: openstack-discuss <openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.orgmailto:openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org> Subject: Re: [tc][heat][tacker][tosca-parser][heat-translator] Discusssion about heat-translater and tosca-parser maintenance
On Mon, Nov 30, 2020 at 11:06 AM TAKAHASHI TOSHIAKI(高橋 敏明) <ts-takahashi@nec.commailto:ts-takahashi@nec.com> wrote:
Need to discuss with Heat, tc, etc.?
And I'd like to continue to discuss other points such as cooperation with other members(Heat, or is there any users of those?).
I don't think you need further discussion with tc as there still are ways for your patch to get reviewed, release package, or for you to join heat-translator-core team As we treat heat translator as a separated team, I'm definitely +1 on any decision from Bob. So not necessary to discuss with heat core team unless you find it difficult to achieve above tasks. I'm more than happy to provide help if needed.
-- May The Force of OpenStack Be With You, Rico Lin irc: ricolin
Hi Bob and Sahdev,
As we discussed last month, Tacker team want to join tosca-parser and heat-translator maintenance. How do we proceed?
We already discussed who join which project maintenance mainly. Can the following members participate core team of the projects? (Of course, all Tacker team members join activities, but decided main roles.)
tosca-parser - yasufum (yasufum.o@gmail.commailto:yasufum.o@gmail.com) - manpreet (kaurmanpreet2620@gmail.commailto:kaurmanpreet2620@gmail.com) - takahashi-tsc (ts-takahashi@nec.commailto:ts-takahashi@nec.com)
heat-translator - yoshito-ito (yoshito.itou.dr@hco.ntt.co.jpmailto:yoshito.itou.dr@hco.ntt.co.jp) - LiangLu (lu.liang@jp.fujitsu.commailto:lu.liang@jp.fujitsu.com)
Regards, Toshiaki
From: TAKAHASHI TOSHIAKI(高橋 敏明) ts-takahashi@nec.com Sent: Tuesday, December 8, 2020 10:20 PM To: ueha.ayumu@fujitsu.com; openstack-discuss openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org Subject: RE: [tc][heat][tacker][tosca-parser][heat-translator] Discusssion about heat-translater and tosca-parser maintenance
Hi Bob and Sahdev,
Tacker team has started to discuss, and at least 5 members want to participate in the maintenance of heat-translator and tosca-parser. In my understanding, heat-translator and tosca-parser are different projects and core team is different. We’d like to different members to participate each core team. Is it OK? Should I send the name list to you?
Best regards, Toshiaki
From: ueha.ayumu@fujitsu.commailto:ueha.ayumu@fujitsu.com <ueha.ayumu@fujitsu.commailto:ueha.ayumu@fujitsu.com> Sent: Tuesday, December 1, 2020 9:25 AM To: openstack-discuss <openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.orgmailto:openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org> Subject: RE: [tc][heat][tacker][tosca-parser][heat-translator] Discusssion about heat-translater and tosca-parser maintenance
Hi Bob and Sahdev
I’m Ueha from tacker team. Thank you for reviewing my patch on the Victria release.
Excuse me during the discussion about maintenance. I posted a new bug fix patch for policies validate. Could you review it? Thanks! https://bugs.launchpad.net/tosca-parser/+bug/1903233 https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/tosca-parser/+/763144
Best regards, Ueha
From: TAKAHASHI TOSHIAKI(高橋 敏明) <ts-takahashi@nec.commailto:ts-takahashi@nec.com> Sent: Monday, November 30, 2020 6:09 PM To: Rico Lin <rico.lin.guanyu@gmail.commailto:rico.lin.guanyu@gmail.com>; openstack-discuss <openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.orgmailto:openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org> Subject: RE: [tc][heat][tacker][tosca-parser][heat-translator] Discusssion about heat-translater and tosca-parser maintenance
Hi Rico,
Thanks. OK, we’ll discuss with Bob to proceed with development of the projects.
Regards, Toshiaki
From: Rico Lin <rico.lin.guanyu@gmail.commailto:rico.lin.guanyu@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, November 30, 2020 4:34 PM To: openstack-discuss <openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.orgmailto:openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org> Subject: Re: [tc][heat][tacker][tosca-parser][heat-translator] Discusssion about heat-translater and tosca-parser maintenance
On Mon, Nov 30, 2020 at 11:06 AM TAKAHASHI TOSHIAKI(高橋 敏明) <ts-takahashi@nec.commailto:ts-takahashi@nec.com> wrote:
Need to discuss with Heat, tc, etc.?
And I'd like to continue to discuss other points such as cooperation with other members(Heat, or is there any users of those?).
I don't think you need further discussion with tc as there still are ways for your patch to get reviewed, release package, or for you to join heat-translator-core team As we treat heat translator as a separated team, I'm definitely +1 on any decision from Bob. So not necessary to discuss with heat core team unless you find it difficult to achieve above tasks. I'm more than happy to provide help if needed.
-- May The Force of OpenStack Be With You, Rico Lin irc: ricolin
Hi Bob and Sahdev,
I’ve received a message that Tacker members joined heat-translator/tosca-parser core teams, and started activities as core member. Many thanks!
Best regards, Toshiaki
From: TAKAHASHI TOSHIAKI(高橋 敏明) ts-takahashi@nec.com Sent: Tuesday, January 26, 2021 5:00 PM To: openstack-discuss openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org Subject: RE: [tc][heat][tacker][tosca-parser][heat-translator] Discusssion about heat-translater and tosca-parser maintenance
Hi Bob and Sahdev,
As we discussed last month, Tacker team want to join tosca-parser and heat-translator maintenance. How do we proceed?
We already discussed who join which project maintenance mainly. Can the following members participate core team of the projects? (Of course, all Tacker team members join activities, but decided main roles.)
tosca-parser - yasufum (yasufum.o@gmail.commailto:yasufum.o@gmail.com) - manpreet (kaurmanpreet2620@gmail.commailto:kaurmanpreet2620@gmail.com) - takahashi-tsc (ts-takahashi@nec.commailto:ts-takahashi@nec.com)
heat-translator - yoshito-ito (yoshito.itou.dr@hco.ntt.co.jpmailto:yoshito.itou.dr@hco.ntt.co.jp) - LiangLu (lu.liang@jp.fujitsu.commailto:lu.liang@jp.fujitsu.com)
Regards, Toshiaki
From: TAKAHASHI TOSHIAKI(高橋 敏明) <ts-takahashi@nec.commailto:ts-takahashi@nec.com> Sent: Tuesday, December 8, 2020 10:20 PM To: ueha.ayumu@fujitsu.commailto:ueha.ayumu@fujitsu.com; openstack-discuss <openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.orgmailto:openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org> Subject: RE: [tc][heat][tacker][tosca-parser][heat-translator] Discusssion about heat-translater and tosca-parser maintenance
Hi Bob and Sahdev,
Tacker team has started to discuss, and at least 5 members want to participate in the maintenance of heat-translator and tosca-parser. In my understanding, heat-translator and tosca-parser are different projects and core team is different. We’d like to different members to participate each core team. Is it OK? Should I send the name list to you?
Best regards, Toshiaki
From: ueha.ayumu@fujitsu.commailto:ueha.ayumu@fujitsu.com <ueha.ayumu@fujitsu.commailto:ueha.ayumu@fujitsu.com> Sent: Tuesday, December 1, 2020 9:25 AM To: openstack-discuss <openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.orgmailto:openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org> Subject: RE: [tc][heat][tacker][tosca-parser][heat-translator] Discusssion about heat-translater and tosca-parser maintenance
Hi Bob and Sahdev
I’m Ueha from tacker team. Thank you for reviewing my patch on the Victria release.
Excuse me during the discussion about maintenance. I posted a new bug fix patch for policies validate. Could you review it? Thanks! https://bugs.launchpad.net/tosca-parser/+bug/1903233 https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/tosca-parser/+/763144
Best regards, Ueha
From: TAKAHASHI TOSHIAKI(高橋 敏明) <ts-takahashi@nec.commailto:ts-takahashi@nec.com> Sent: Monday, November 30, 2020 6:09 PM To: Rico Lin <rico.lin.guanyu@gmail.commailto:rico.lin.guanyu@gmail.com>; openstack-discuss <openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.orgmailto:openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org> Subject: RE: [tc][heat][tacker][tosca-parser][heat-translator] Discusssion about heat-translater and tosca-parser maintenance
Hi Rico,
Thanks. OK, we’ll discuss with Bob to proceed with development of the projects.
Regards, Toshiaki
From: Rico Lin <rico.lin.guanyu@gmail.commailto:rico.lin.guanyu@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, November 30, 2020 4:34 PM To: openstack-discuss <openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.orgmailto:openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org> Subject: Re: [tc][heat][tacker][tosca-parser][heat-translator] Discusssion about heat-translater and tosca-parser maintenance
On Mon, Nov 30, 2020 at 11:06 AM TAKAHASHI TOSHIAKI(高橋 敏明) <ts-takahashi@nec.commailto:ts-takahashi@nec.com> wrote:
Need to discuss with Heat, tc, etc.?
And I'd like to continue to discuss other points such as cooperation with other members(Heat, or is there any users of those?).
I don't think you need further discussion with tc as there still are ways for your patch to get reviewed, release package, or for you to join heat-translator-core team As we treat heat translator as a separated team, I'm definitely +1 on any decision from Bob. So not necessary to discuss with heat core team unless you find it difficult to achieve above tasks. I'm more than happy to provide help if needed.
-- May The Force of OpenStack Be With You, Rico Lin irc: ricolin
participants (5)
-
Ghanshyam Mann
-
HADDLETON, Robert W (Bob)
-
Rico Lin
-
TAKAHASHI TOSHIAKI(高橋 敏明)
-
ueha.ayumu＠fujitsu.com