It's time for the OpenStack User Survey <https://www.openstack.org/user-survey> [1]! In an effort to create less work for our community, in 2018 we moved to an annual, rather than a bi-annual report. If you run an OpenStack deployment, now is the time to share details about how you run the software and your thoughts on ways that the community can improve the software. Your feedback matters and it's shared directly with the PTLs and community leaders that work to build OpenStack! We had some good community feedback on the last survey and ended up with only minor updates from 2018. Below you can see a list of changes that we've incorporated: * "Which new/emerging technologies are you interested in using or seeing integrated with OpenStack?" o Added options for "AI/ML" and "5G" * Deleted the question "Are you interested in helping our interoperability efforts by using RefStack to test your cloud capabilities?" * "Which tools are you using to deploy / manage this cluster?" o Added the word "manage" to the question as tools can be used for both o Add "TripleO" and "Container-based orchestration" as options o Created a new "Please specify" if "Other tools" is chosen * "Which container orchestration or Platform-as-a-Service (PaaS) tools are you using to manage applications on this OpenStack deployment?" o Added "container orchestration or " to question * "Which OpenStack Network (Neutron) drivers are you using?" o Add Calico as an answer * "Which compatibility APIs does this deployment support?" o Added the option "This deployment doesn't use compatibility APIs" * Please note: This year, we will not be including the hardware and software vendor questions in the report or analytics dashboard due to the potential for the data to be misinterpreted. * *In addition to the question modifications above, we reached out to PTLs to ask for their feedback and guidance on the project specific questions of the survey. We've modified or added those questions as noted below: *Keystone* This will be a question where respondents can rank their choices and will follow their existing question: * Which of the following initiatives would be most beneficial for your deployment? You can rank items by priority with items at the top being most important and items at the bottom being least important. o Improved performance o Better support for synchronizing multiple keystone regions o Read-only RBAC roles o More flexible federated mappings o Improved fine-grained access control o Better support for domain administrators o Improved usability of keystone outside of an OpenStack environment Glance Changed existing question to: * "Multi back-ends feature will stay Experimental in Stein release. How badly this affect your deployment plans? Any details how you’re planning to use it would be helpful.” *Ironic* Changed existing question to: * "What would you find most useful if it was part of Ironic?" *Swift* Changed existing question to: * What features of Swift are you currently using (or have plans to use in the next 12 months)? (select all that apply o S3 compatibility o Dynamic Large Objects o Static Large Objects o Temporary URLs o Data-at-rest encryption o Multiple storage policies o Multi-region clusters o Explicit data placement (composite rings) o Container sync o Static websites or CORS o Symlinks o Quotas o Object versioning If you have further questions, concerns, please let us know. Cheers, Jimmy and Allison [1] https://www.openstack.org/user-survey
Jimmy, I am curious, how did you reach out the PTLs for project specific questions? The Octavia team didn't receive any e-mail from you or Allison on the topic. Michael
Hi Michael, We reached out to all of the PTLs who had questions in the 2018 version of the survey to review and update their questions. If there is a project that was missed, we can add it and share anonymized results with the PTLs directly as well as the openstack-discsuss mailing list. If there is a question from the Octavia team, please let us know and we can add it for the 2019 survey. Cheers, Allison
On Apr 27, 2019, at 4:01 PM, Michael Johnson <johnsomor@gmail.com> wrote:
Jimmy,
I am curious, how did you reach out the PTLs for project specific questions? The Octavia team didn't receive any e-mail from you or Allison on the topic.
Michael
Jimmy & Allison, As you probably remember from previous year's surveys, the Octavia team has been trying to get a question included in the survey for a while. I have included the response we got the last time we inquired about the survey below. We never received a follow up invitation. I think it would be in the best interest for the community if we follow our "Four Opens" ethos in the user survey process, specifically the "Open Community" statement, by soliciting survey questions from the project teams in an open forum such as the openstack-discuss mailing list. Michael ----- Last response e-mail ------ Jimmy McArthur <jimmy@openstack.org> Fri, Sep 7, 2018, 5:51 PM to Allison, me Hey Michael, The project-specific questions were added in 2017, so likely didn't include some new projects. While we asked all projects to participate initially, less than a dozen did. We will be sending an invitation for new/underrepresented projects in the coming weeks. Please stand by and know that we value your feedback and that of the community. Cheers! On Sat, Apr 27, 2019 at 5:11 PM Allison Price <allison@openstack.org> wrote:
Hi Michael,
We reached out to all of the PTLs who had questions in the 2018 version of the survey to review and update their questions. If there is a project that was missed, we can add it and share anonymized results with the PTLs directly as well as the openstack-discsuss mailing list.
If there is a question from the Octavia team, please let us know and we can add it for the 2019 survey.
Cheers, Allison
On Apr 27, 2019, at 4:01 PM, Michael Johnson <johnsomor@gmail.com> wrote:
Jimmy,
I am curious, how did you reach out the PTLs for project specific questions? The Octavia team didn't receive any e-mail from you or Allison on the topic.
Michael
Hi Michael, I apologize that the Octavia project team has been unable to submit a question to date. Jimmy posted the User Survey update to the public mailing list to ensure we updated the entire community and that we caught any projects that had not submitted their questions. The User Survey is open all year, and the primary goal is passing operator feedback to the upstream community. If the Octavia team - or any OpenStack project team - has a question they would like added (limit of 2 per project), please let Jimmy or myself know. Thanks for reaching out, Michael. Cheers, Allison
On May 7, 2019, at 3:39 PM, Michael Johnson <johnsomor@gmail.com> wrote:
Jimmy & Allison,
As you probably remember from previous year's surveys, the Octavia team has been trying to get a question included in the survey for a while. I have included the response we got the last time we inquired about the survey below. We never received a follow up invitation.
I think it would be in the best interest for the community if we follow our "Four Opens" ethos in the user survey process, specifically the "Open Community" statement, by soliciting survey questions from the project teams in an open forum such as the openstack-discuss mailing list.
Michael
----- Last response e-mail ------ Jimmy McArthur <jimmy@openstack.org>
Fri, Sep 7, 2018, 5:51 PM to Allison, me Hey Michael,
The project-specific questions were added in 2017, so likely didn't include some new projects. While we asked all projects to participate initially, less than a dozen did. We will be sending an invitation for new/underrepresented projects in the coming weeks. Please stand by and know that we value your feedback and that of the community.
Cheers!
On Sat, Apr 27, 2019 at 5:11 PM Allison Price <allison@openstack.org> wrote:
Hi Michael,
We reached out to all of the PTLs who had questions in the 2018 version of the survey to review and update their questions. If there is a project that was missed, we can add it and share anonymized results with the PTLs directly as well as the openstack-discsuss mailing list.
If there is a question from the Octavia team, please let us know and we can add it for the 2019 survey.
Cheers, Allison
On Apr 27, 2019, at 4:01 PM, Michael Johnson <johnsomor@gmail.com> wrote:
Jimmy,
I am curious, how did you reach out the PTLs for project specific questions? The Octavia team didn't receive any e-mail from you or Allison on the topic.
Michael
Hi Allison and Jimmy, In today's Octavia IRC meeting [1], the team agreed on the following two questions we would like to see included in the survey: 1. Which OpenStack load balancing (Octavia) provider drivers would you like to see supported? 2. Which new features would you like to see supported in OpenStack load balancing (Octavia)? Please let us know if you have any questions. Thanks, Carlos [1] http://eavesdrop.openstack.org/meetings/octavia/2019/octavia.2019-05-08-16.0... On Tue, May 7, 2019 at 10:51 PM Allison Price <allison@openstack.org> wrote:
Hi Michael,
I apologize that the Octavia project team has been unable to submit a question to date. Jimmy posted the User Survey update to the public mailing list to ensure we updated the entire community and that we caught any projects that had not submitted their questions. The User Survey is open all year, and the primary goal is passing operator feedback to the upstream community.
If the Octavia team - or any OpenStack project team - has a question they would like added (limit of 2 per project), please let Jimmy or myself know.
Thanks for reaching out, Michael.
Cheers, Allison
On May 7, 2019, at 3:39 PM, Michael Johnson <johnsomor@gmail.com> wrote:
Jimmy & Allison,
As you probably remember from previous year's surveys, the Octavia team has been trying to get a question included in the survey for a while. I have included the response we got the last time we inquired about the survey below. We never received a follow up invitation.
I think it would be in the best interest for the community if we follow our "Four Opens" ethos in the user survey process, specifically the "Open Community" statement, by soliciting survey questions from the project teams in an open forum such as the openstack-discuss mailing list.
Michael
----- Last response e-mail ------ Jimmy McArthur <jimmy@openstack.org>
Fri, Sep 7, 2018, 5:51 PM to Allison, me Hey Michael,
The project-specific questions were added in 2017, so likely didn't include some new projects. While we asked all projects to participate initially, less than a dozen did. We will be sending an invitation for new/underrepresented projects in the coming weeks. Please stand by and know that we value your feedback and that of the community.
Cheers!
On Sat, Apr 27, 2019 at 5:11 PM Allison Price <allison@openstack.org> wrote:
Hi Michael,
We reached out to all of the PTLs who had questions in the 2018 version of the survey to review and update their questions. If there is a project that was missed, we can add it and share anonymized results with the PTLs directly as well as the openstack-discsuss mailing list.
If there is a question from the Octavia team, please let us know and we can add it for the 2019 survey.
Cheers, Allison
On Apr 27, 2019, at 4:01 PM, Michael Johnson <johnsomor@gmail.com> wrote:
Jimmy,
I am curious, how did you reach out the PTLs for project specific questions? The Octavia team didn't receive any e-mail from you or Allison on the topic.
Michael
Hi Carlos, Thank you for providing these two questions. We can get them both added, but I did have a question. Are both of these questions intended to be open ended with a text box for respondents to fill in their answers? Or do you want to provide answer choices? (thinking for the first question in particular) With any multiple choice question, an Other option can be included that will trigger a text box to be completed. Thanks! Allison
On May 8, 2019, at 12:04 PM, Carlos Goncalves <cgoncalves@redhat.com> wrote:
Hi Allison and Jimmy,
In today's Octavia IRC meeting [1], the team agreed on the following two questions we would like to see included in the survey:
1. Which OpenStack load balancing (Octavia) provider drivers would you like to see supported? 2. Which new features would you like to see supported in OpenStack load balancing (Octavia)?
Please let us know if you have any questions.
Thanks, Carlos
[1] http://eavesdrop.openstack.org/meetings/octavia/2019/octavia.2019-05-08-16.0...
On Tue, May 7, 2019 at 10:51 PM Allison Price <allison@openstack.org> wrote:
Hi Michael,
I apologize that the Octavia project team has been unable to submit a question to date. Jimmy posted the User Survey update to the public mailing list to ensure we updated the entire community and that we caught any projects that had not submitted their questions. The User Survey is open all year, and the primary goal is passing operator feedback to the upstream community.
If the Octavia team - or any OpenStack project team - has a question they would like added (limit of 2 per project), please let Jimmy or myself know.
Thanks for reaching out, Michael.
Cheers, Allison
On May 7, 2019, at 3:39 PM, Michael Johnson <johnsomor@gmail.com> wrote:
Jimmy & Allison,
As you probably remember from previous year's surveys, the Octavia team has been trying to get a question included in the survey for a while. I have included the response we got the last time we inquired about the survey below. We never received a follow up invitation.
I think it would be in the best interest for the community if we follow our "Four Opens" ethos in the user survey process, specifically the "Open Community" statement, by soliciting survey questions from the project teams in an open forum such as the openstack-discuss mailing list.
Michael
----- Last response e-mail ------ Jimmy McArthur <jimmy@openstack.org>
Fri, Sep 7, 2018, 5:51 PM to Allison, me Hey Michael,
The project-specific questions were added in 2017, so likely didn't include some new projects. While we asked all projects to participate initially, less than a dozen did. We will be sending an invitation for new/underrepresented projects in the coming weeks. Please stand by and know that we value your feedback and that of the community.
Cheers!
On Sat, Apr 27, 2019 at 5:11 PM Allison Price <allison@openstack.org> wrote:
Hi Michael,
We reached out to all of the PTLs who had questions in the 2018 version of the survey to review and update their questions. If there is a project that was missed, we can add it and share anonymized results with the PTLs directly as well as the openstack-discsuss mailing list.
If there is a question from the Octavia team, please let us know and we can add it for the 2019 survey.
Cheers, Allison
On Apr 27, 2019, at 4:01 PM, Michael Johnson <johnsomor@gmail.com> wrote:
Jimmy,
I am curious, how did you reach out the PTLs for project specific questions? The Octavia team didn't receive any e-mail from you or Allison on the topic.
Michael
Carlos, Right now these questions are up as free text area. Feel free to send along adjustments if you'd like. Cheers Jimmy
Allison Price <mailto:allison@openstack.org> May 8, 2019 at 4:30 PM Hi Carlos,
Thank you for providing these two questions. We can get them both added, but I did have a question. Are both of these questions intended to be open ended with a text box for respondents to fill in their answers? Or do you want to provide answer choices? (thinking for the first question in particular) With any multiple choice question, an Other option can be included that will trigger a text box to be completed.
Thanks! Allison
_______________________________________________ User-committee mailing list User-committee@lists.openstack.org http://lists.openstack.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/user-committee Carlos Goncalves <mailto:cgoncalves@redhat.com> May 8, 2019 at 12:04 PM Hi Allison and Jimmy,
In today's Octavia IRC meeting [1], the team agreed on the following two questions we would like to see included in the survey:
1. Which OpenStack load balancing (Octavia) provider drivers would you like to see supported? 2. Which new features would you like to see supported in OpenStack load balancing (Octavia)?
Please let us know if you have any questions.
Thanks, Carlos
[1] http://eavesdrop.openstack.org/meetings/octavia/2019/octavia.2019-05-08-16.0...
Allison Price <mailto:allison@openstack.org> May 7, 2019 at 3:50 PM Hi Michael,
I apologize that the Octavia project team has been unable to submit a question to date. Jimmy posted the User Survey update to the public mailing list to ensure we updated the entire community and that we caught any projects that had not submitted their questions. The User Survey is open all year, and the primary goal is passing operator feedback to the upstream community.
If the Octavia team - or any OpenStack project team - has a question they would like added (limit of 2 per project), please let Jimmy or myself know.
Thanks for reaching out, Michael.
Cheers, Allison
Michael Johnson <mailto:johnsomor@gmail.com> May 7, 2019 at 3:39 PM Jimmy & Allison,
As you probably remember from previous year's surveys, the Octavia team has been trying to get a question included in the survey for a while. I have included the response we got the last time we inquired about the survey below. We never received a follow up invitation.
I think it would be in the best interest for the community if we follow our "Four Opens" ethos in the user survey process, specifically the "Open Community" statement, by soliciting survey questions from the project teams in an open forum such as the openstack-discuss mailing list.
Michael
----- Last response e-mail ------ Jimmy McArthur <jimmy@openstack.org>
Fri, Sep 7, 2018, 5:51 PM to Allison, me Hey Michael,
The project-specific questions were added in 2017, so likely didn't include some new projects. While we asked all projects to participate initially, less than a dozen did. We will be sending an invitation for new/underrepresented projects in the coming weeks. Please stand by and know that we value your feedback and that of the community.
Cheers!
Allison Price <mailto:allison@openstack.org> April 27, 2019 at 7:11 PM Hi Michael,
We reached out to all of the PTLs who had questions in the 2018 version of the survey to review and update their questions. If there is a project that was missed, we can add it and share anonymized results with the PTLs directly as well as the openstack-discsuss mailing list.
If there is a question from the Octavia team, please let us know and we can add it for the 2019 survey.
Cheers, Allison
Thank you for the prompt replies and action, Allison and Jimmy! After discussing on #openstack-lbaas with the team and drafting on https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/cItdtzi32r, we would like to suggest presenting some multiple choices along with an "Other" free text area. 1. Which OpenStack load balancing (Octavia) provider drivers would you like to see supported? (sorted alphabetically) A10 Networks AVI Networks Amphora Brocade F5 HAProxy Technologies Kemp Netscaler OVN Radware VMware Other (free text area) 2. Which new features would you like to see supported in OpenStack load balancing (Octavia)? (sorted alphabetically) Active-active Container-based amphora driver Event notifications gRPC protocol HTTP/2 protocol Log offloading MySQL protocol Simultaneous IPv4 and IPv6 VIP Statistics (more metrics) VIP ACL API Other (free text area) Thanks, Carlos On Wed, May 8, 2019 at 11:52 PM Jimmy McArthur <jimmy@openstack.org> wrote:
Carlos,
Right now these questions are up as free text area. Feel free to send along adjustments if you'd like.
Cheers Jimmy
Allison Price May 8, 2019 at 4:30 PM Hi Carlos,
Thank you for providing these two questions. We can get them both added, but I did have a question. Are both of these questions intended to be open ended with a text box for respondents to fill in their answers? Or do you want to provide answer choices? (thinking for the first question in particular) With any multiple choice question, an Other option can be included that will trigger a text box to be completed.
Thanks! Allison
_______________________________________________ User-committee mailing list User-committee@lists.openstack.org http://lists.openstack.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/user-committee Carlos Goncalves May 8, 2019 at 12:04 PM Hi Allison and Jimmy,
In today's Octavia IRC meeting [1], the team agreed on the following two questions we would like to see included in the survey:
1. Which OpenStack load balancing (Octavia) provider drivers would you like to see supported? 2. Which new features would you like to see supported in OpenStack load balancing (Octavia)?
Please let us know if you have any questions.
Thanks, Carlos
[1] http://eavesdrop.openstack.org/meetings/octavia/2019/octavia.2019-05-08-16.0...
Allison Price May 7, 2019 at 3:50 PM Hi Michael,
I apologize that the Octavia project team has been unable to submit a question to date. Jimmy posted the User Survey update to the public mailing list to ensure we updated the entire community and that we caught any projects that had not submitted their questions. The User Survey is open all year, and the primary goal is passing operator feedback to the upstream community.
If the Octavia team - or any OpenStack project team - has a question they would like added (limit of 2 per project), please let Jimmy or myself know.
Thanks for reaching out, Michael.
Cheers, Allison
Michael Johnson May 7, 2019 at 3:39 PM Jimmy & Allison,
As you probably remember from previous year's surveys, the Octavia team has been trying to get a question included in the survey for a while. I have included the response we got the last time we inquired about the survey below. We never received a follow up invitation.
I think it would be in the best interest for the community if we follow our "Four Opens" ethos in the user survey process, specifically the "Open Community" statement, by soliciting survey questions from the project teams in an open forum such as the openstack-discuss mailing list.
Michael
----- Last response e-mail ------ Jimmy McArthur <jimmy@openstack.org>
Fri, Sep 7, 2018, 5:51 PM to Allison, me Hey Michael,
The project-specific questions were added in 2017, so likely didn't include some new projects. While we asked all projects to participate initially, less than a dozen did. We will be sending an invitation for new/underrepresented projects in the coming weeks. Please stand by and know that we value your feedback and that of the community.
Cheers!
Allison Price April 27, 2019 at 7:11 PM Hi Michael,
We reached out to all of the PTLs who had questions in the 2018 version of the survey to review and update their questions. If there is a project that was missed, we can add it and share anonymized results with the PTLs directly as well as the openstack-discsuss mailing list.
If there is a question from the Octavia team, please let us know and we can add it for the 2019 survey.
Cheers, Allison
Thanks, Jimmy and Allison for the effort to put this together, As Heat PTL I would like to ask for question update for Heat project. Here is our new question: https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/heat-user-survey-brainstrom Please let me know if any confusion On Fri, May 10, 2019 at 5:02 AM Carlos Goncalves <cgoncalves@redhat.com> wrote:
Thank you for the prompt replies and action, Allison and Jimmy!
After discussing on #openstack-lbaas with the team and drafting on https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/cItdtzi32r, we would like to suggest presenting some multiple choices along with an "Other" free text area.
1. Which OpenStack load balancing (Octavia) provider drivers would you like to see supported?
(sorted alphabetically) A10 Networks AVI Networks Amphora Brocade F5 HAProxy Technologies Kemp Netscaler OVN Radware VMware Other (free text area)
2. Which new features would you like to see supported in OpenStack load balancing (Octavia)?
(sorted alphabetically) Active-active Container-based amphora driver Event notifications gRPC protocol HTTP/2 protocol Log offloading MySQL protocol Simultaneous IPv4 and IPv6 VIP Statistics (more metrics) VIP ACL API Other (free text area)
Thanks, Carlos
On Wed, May 8, 2019 at 11:52 PM Jimmy McArthur <jimmy@openstack.org> wrote:
Carlos,
Right now these questions are up as free text area. Feel free to send
along adjustments if you'd like.
Cheers Jimmy
Allison Price May 8, 2019 at 4:30 PM Hi Carlos,
Thank you for providing these two questions. We can get them both added,
but I did have a question. Are both of these questions intended to be open ended with a text box for respondents to fill in their answers? Or do you want to provide answer choices? (thinking for the first question in particular) With any multiple choice question, an Other option can be included that will trigger a text box to be completed.
Thanks! Allison
_______________________________________________ User-committee mailing list User-committee@lists.openstack.org http://lists.openstack.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/user-committee Carlos Goncalves May 8, 2019 at 12:04 PM Hi Allison and Jimmy,
In today's Octavia IRC meeting [1], the team agreed on the following two questions we would like to see included in the survey:
1. Which OpenStack load balancing (Octavia) provider drivers would you like to see supported? 2. Which new features would you like to see supported in OpenStack load balancing (Octavia)?
Please let us know if you have any questions.
Thanks, Carlos
[1]
http://eavesdrop.openstack.org/meetings/octavia/2019/octavia.2019-05-08-16.0...
Allison Price May 7, 2019 at 3:50 PM Hi Michael,
I apologize that the Octavia project team has been unable to submit a
question to date. Jimmy posted the User Survey update to the public mailing list to ensure we updated the entire community and that we caught any projects that had not submitted their questions. The User Survey is open all year, and the primary goal is passing operator feedback to the upstream community.
If the Octavia team - or any OpenStack project team - has a question
they would like added (limit of 2 per project), please let Jimmy or myself know.
Thanks for reaching out, Michael.
Cheers, Allison
Michael Johnson May 7, 2019 at 3:39 PM Jimmy & Allison,
As you probably remember from previous year's surveys, the Octavia team has been trying to get a question included in the survey for a while. I have included the response we got the last time we inquired about the survey below. We never received a follow up invitation.
I think it would be in the best interest for the community if we follow our "Four Opens" ethos in the user survey process, specifically the "Open Community" statement, by soliciting survey questions from the project teams in an open forum such as the openstack-discuss mailing list.
Michael
----- Last response e-mail ------ Jimmy McArthur <jimmy@openstack.org>
Fri, Sep 7, 2018, 5:51 PM to Allison, me Hey Michael,
The project-specific questions were added in 2017, so likely didn't include some new projects. While we asked all projects to participate initially, less than a dozen did. We will be sending an invitation for new/underrepresented projects in the coming weeks. Please stand by and know that we value your feedback and that of the community.
Cheers!
Allison Price April 27, 2019 at 7:11 PM Hi Michael,
We reached out to all of the PTLs who had questions in the 2018 version
of the survey to review and update their questions. If there is a project that was missed, we can add it and share anonymized results with the PTLs directly as well as the openstack-discsuss mailing list.
If there is a question from the Octavia team, please let us know and we
can add it for the 2019 survey.
Cheers, Allison
-- May The Force of OpenStack Be With You, *Rico Lin*irc: ricolin
(resend to user committee ML) Thanks, Jimmy and Allison for the effort to put this together, As Heat PTL I would like to ask for question update for Heat project. Here is our new question: https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/heat-user-survey-brainstrom Please let me know if any confusion Rico Lin <rico.lin.guanyu@gmail.com>於 2019年5月10日 週五，下午12:26寫道：
Thanks, Jimmy and Allison for the effort to put this together,
As Heat PTL I would like to ask for question update for Heat project. Here is our new question: https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/heat-user-survey-brainstrom Please let me know if any confusion
On Fri, May 10, 2019 at 5:02 AM Carlos Goncalves <cgoncalves@redhat.com> wrote:
Thank you for the prompt replies and action, Allison and Jimmy!
After discussing on #openstack-lbaas with the team and drafting on https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/cItdtzi32r, we would like to suggest presenting some multiple choices along with an "Other" free text area.
1. Which OpenStack load balancing (Octavia) provider drivers would you like to see supported?
(sorted alphabetically) A10 Networks AVI Networks Amphora Brocade F5 HAProxy Technologies Kemp Netscaler OVN Radware VMware Other (free text area)
2. Which new features would you like to see supported in OpenStack load balancing (Octavia)?
(sorted alphabetically) Active-active Container-based amphora driver Event notifications gRPC protocol HTTP/2 protocol Log offloading MySQL protocol Simultaneous IPv4 and IPv6 VIP Statistics (more metrics) VIP ACL API Other (free text area)
Thanks, Carlos
On Wed, May 8, 2019 at 11:52 PM Jimmy McArthur <jimmy@openstack.org> wrote:
Carlos,
Right now these questions are up as free text area. Feel free to send
along adjustments if you'd like.
Cheers Jimmy
Allison Price May 8, 2019 at 4:30 PM Hi Carlos,
Thank you for providing these two questions. We can get them both
added, but I did have a question. Are both of these questions intended to be open ended with a text box for respondents to fill in their answers? Or do you want to provide answer choices? (thinking for the first question in particular) With any multiple choice question, an Other option can be included that will trigger a text box to be completed.
Thanks! Allison
_______________________________________________ User-committee mailing list User-committee@lists.openstack.org http://lists.openstack.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/user-committee Carlos Goncalves May 8, 2019 at 12:04 PM Hi Allison and Jimmy,
In today's Octavia IRC meeting [1], the team agreed on the following two questions we would like to see included in the survey:
1. Which OpenStack load balancing (Octavia) provider drivers would you like to see supported? 2. Which new features would you like to see supported in OpenStack load balancing (Octavia)?
Please let us know if you have any questions.
Thanks, Carlos
[1]
http://eavesdrop.openstack.org/meetings/octavia/2019/octavia.2019-05-08-16.0...
Allison Price May 7, 2019 at 3:50 PM Hi Michael,
I apologize that the Octavia project team has been unable to submit a
question to date. Jimmy posted the User Survey update to the public mailing list to ensure we updated the entire community and that we caught any projects that had not submitted their questions. The User Survey is open all year, and the primary goal is passing operator feedback to the upstream community.
If the Octavia team - or any OpenStack project team - has a question
they would like added (limit of 2 per project), please let Jimmy or myself know.
Thanks for reaching out, Michael.
Cheers, Allison
Michael Johnson May 7, 2019 at 3:39 PM Jimmy & Allison,
As you probably remember from previous year's surveys, the Octavia team has been trying to get a question included in the survey for a while. I have included the response we got the last time we inquired about the survey below. We never received a follow up invitation.
I think it would be in the best interest for the community if we follow our "Four Opens" ethos in the user survey process, specifically the "Open Community" statement, by soliciting survey questions from the project teams in an open forum such as the openstack-discuss mailing list.
Michael
----- Last response e-mail ------ Jimmy McArthur <jimmy@openstack.org>
Fri, Sep 7, 2018, 5:51 PM to Allison, me Hey Michael,
The project-specific questions were added in 2017, so likely didn't include some new projects. While we asked all projects to participate initially, less than a dozen did. We will be sending an invitation for new/underrepresented projects in the coming weeks. Please stand by and know that we value your feedback and that of the community.
Cheers!
Allison Price April 27, 2019 at 7:11 PM Hi Michael,
We reached out to all of the PTLs who had questions in the 2018 version
of the survey to review and update their questions. If there is a project that was missed, we can add it and share anonymized results with the PTLs directly as well as the openstack-discsuss mailing list.
If there is a question from the Octavia team, please let us know and we
can add it for the 2019 survey.
Cheers, Allison
-- May The Force of OpenStack Be With You,
*Rico Lin*irc: ricolin
-- May The Force of OpenStack Be With You,
*Rico Lin*irc: ricolin
Rico, This has been added to the survey. Users that select Heat as part of their deployment will see this question. The old question has been hidden, but retained since some users might have already answered. Cheers, Jimmy
Rico Lin <mailto:rico.lin.guanyu@gmail.com> May 10, 2019 at 5:41 AM (resend to user committee ML)
Thanks, Jimmy and Allison for the effort to put this together,
As Heat PTL I would like to ask for question update for Heat project. Here is our new question: https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/heat-user-survey-brainstrom Please let me know if any confusion
-- May The Force of OpenStack Be With You, */Rico Lin /*irc: ricolin
Rico Lin <mailto:rico.lin.guanyu@gmail.com> May 9, 2019 at 11:26 PM Thanks, Jimmy and Allison for the effort to put this together,
As Heat PTL I would like to ask for question update for Heat project. Here is our new question: https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/heat-user-survey-brainstrom Please let me know if any confusion
-- May The Force of OpenStack Be With You, */Rico Lin /*irc: ricolin
Carlos Goncalves <mailto:cgoncalves@redhat.com> May 9, 2019 at 3:59 PM Thank you for the prompt replies and action, Allison and Jimmy!
After discussing on #openstack-lbaas with the team and drafting on https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/cItdtzi32r, we would like to suggest presenting some multiple choices along with an "Other" free text area.
1. Which OpenStack load balancing (Octavia) provider drivers would you like to see supported?
(sorted alphabetically) A10 Networks AVI Networks Amphora Brocade F5 HAProxy Technologies Kemp Netscaler OVN Radware VMware Other (free text area)
2. Which new features would you like to see supported in OpenStack load balancing (Octavia)?
(sorted alphabetically) Active-active Container-based amphora driver Event notifications gRPC protocol HTTP/2 protocol Log offloading MySQL protocol Simultaneous IPv4 and IPv6 VIP Statistics (more metrics) VIP ACL API Other (free text area)
Thanks, Carlos
Jimmy McArthur <mailto:jimmy@openstack.org> May 8, 2019 at 4:52 PM Carlos,
Right now these questions are up as free text area. Feel free to send along adjustments if you'd like.
Cheers Jimmy
Allison Price <mailto:allison@openstack.org> May 8, 2019 at 4:30 PM Hi Carlos,
Thank you for providing these two questions. We can get them both added, but I did have a question. Are both of these questions intended to be open ended with a text box for respondents to fill in their answers? Or do you want to provide answer choices? (thinking for the first question in particular) With any multiple choice question, an Other option can be included that will trigger a text box to be completed.
Thanks! Allison
Hi Jimmy, The auto-scaling SIG would like to add a question to the user survey. Our question was drafted during our auto-scaling SIG meeting [1]. The question we would like to get added is as follows: If you are using auto-scaling in your OpenStack cloud, which services do you use as part of auto-scaling? [Select all that apply] Monasca Ceilometer Aodh Senlin Heat Other OpenStack service (please specify - e.g. Watcher, Vitrage, Congress) Custom application components Prometheus Other user-provided service (please specify) Thanks, Duc [1] http://eavesdrop.openstack.org/meetings/auto_scaling_sig/2019/auto_scaling_s...
Hi Duc, Thanks for sharing this. To date, we have limited adding questions to OpenStack project teams, UC, and TC. If we were going to open it up to Working Groups and SIGs, then we would need to open it up to all of the groups. We have not done this in the past, as we were trying to avoid making the survey too long and complex. We could evaluate this for the next version of the User Survey that will open in August and communicate with all working groups and SIGs, but we don’t have enough time to open that process for the current version. I am happy to join the next auto-scaling SIG meeting to help identify a way to collect this feedback in the meantime if your team would like. Cheers, Allison
On May 15, 2019, at 7:10 PM, Duc Truong <duc.openstack@gmail.com> wrote:
Hi Jimmy,
The auto-scaling SIG would like to add a question to the user survey. Our question was drafted during our auto-scaling SIG meeting [1]. The question we would like to get added is as follows:
If you are using auto-scaling in your OpenStack cloud, which services do you use as part of auto-scaling? [Select all that apply]
Monasca Ceilometer Aodh Senlin Heat Other OpenStack service (please specify - e.g. Watcher, Vitrage, Congress) Custom application components Prometheus Other user-provided service (please specify)
Thanks,
Duc
[1] http://eavesdrop.openstack.org/meetings/auto_scaling_sig/2019/auto_scaling_s...
Carlos, These questions are now updated and on the survey, if the user indicates they are using Octavia on their deployment. Thank you, Jimmy
Carlos Goncalves <mailto:cgoncalves@redhat.com> May 9, 2019 at 3:59 PM Thank you for the prompt replies and action, Allison and Jimmy!
After discussing on #openstack-lbaas with the team and drafting on https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/cItdtzi32r, we would like to suggest presenting some multiple choices along with an "Other" free text area.
1. Which OpenStack load balancing (Octavia) provider drivers would you like to see supported?
(sorted alphabetically) A10 Networks AVI Networks Amphora Brocade F5 HAProxy Technologies Kemp Netscaler OVN Radware VMware Other (free text area)
2. Which new features would you like to see supported in OpenStack load balancing (Octavia)?
(sorted alphabetically) Active-active Container-based amphora driver Event notifications gRPC protocol HTTP/2 protocol Log offloading MySQL protocol Simultaneous IPv4 and IPv6 VIP Statistics (more metrics) VIP ACL API Other (free text area)
Thanks, Carlos
Jimmy McArthur <mailto:jimmy@openstack.org> May 8, 2019 at 4:52 PM Carlos,
Right now these questions are up as free text area. Feel free to send along adjustments if you'd like.
Cheers Jimmy
Allison Price <mailto:allison@openstack.org> May 8, 2019 at 4:30 PM Hi Carlos,
Thank you for providing these two questions. We can get them both added, but I did have a question. Are both of these questions intended to be open ended with a text box for respondents to fill in their answers? Or do you want to provide answer choices? (thinking for the first question in particular) With any multiple choice question, an Other option can be included that will trigger a text box to be completed.
Thanks! Allison
Carlos Goncalves <mailto:cgoncalves@redhat.com> May 8, 2019 at 12:04 PM Hi Allison and Jimmy,
In today's Octavia IRC meeting [1], the team agreed on the following two questions we would like to see included in the survey:
1. Which OpenStack load balancing (Octavia) provider drivers would you like to see supported? 2. Which new features would you like to see supported in OpenStack load balancing (Octavia)?
Please let us know if you have any questions.
Thanks, Carlos
[1] http://eavesdrop.openstack.org/meetings/octavia/2019/octavia.2019-05-08-16.0...
Allison Price <mailto:allison@openstack.org> May 7, 2019 at 3:50 PM Hi Michael,
I apologize that the Octavia project team has been unable to submit a question to date. Jimmy posted the User Survey update to the public mailing list to ensure we updated the entire community and that we caught any projects that had not submitted their questions. The User Survey is open all year, and the primary goal is passing operator feedback to the upstream community.
If the Octavia team - or any OpenStack project team - has a question they would like added (limit of 2 per project), please let Jimmy or myself know.
Thanks for reaching out, Michael.
Cheers, Allison
participants (7)
-
Allison Price
-
Carlos Goncalves
-
Duc Truong
-
Jimmy Mcarthur
-
Jimmy McArthur
-
Michael Johnson
-
Rico Lin