[oslo] HTTP base direct RPC oslo.messaging driver contribution
Hi oslo team,
We'd like to contribute HTTP base direct RPC driver to the oslo.messaging community. We have developed the HTTP base driver internally. We have been using the driver in the production with over 10K hypervisors now.
I checked the IRC meeting log of the oslo team[1], but there is no regluar meeting in 2023. Is it okay to submit oslo-spec[2] to propose the driver directly, or is there another good place to discuss the feature before submitting a spec?
1. https://meetings.opendev.org/#Oslo_Team_Meeting 2. https://opendev.org/openstack/oslo-specs
best regards, Masahito
Hello Masahito,
Submission to oslo-spec is a good starting point.
Best regards
Le lun. 5 juin 2023 à 10:04, 室井雅仁 masahito.muroi@linecorp.com a écrit :
Hi oslo team,
We'd like to contribute HTTP base direct RPC driver to the oslo.messaging community. We have developed the HTTP base driver internally. We have been using the driver in the production with over 10K hypervisors now.
I checked the IRC meeting log of the oslo team[1], but there is no regluar meeting in 2023. Is it okay to submit oslo-spec[2] to propose the driver directly, or is there another good place to discuss the feature before submitting a spec?
best regards, Masahito
Hello,
That seems very interesting for Large-scale topics as well!
Do you already have the code available somewhere?
On 05.06.23 - 10:21, Herve Beraud wrote:
Hello Masahito,
Submission to oslo-spec is a good starting point.
Best regards
Le lun. 5 juin 2023 à 10:04, 室井雅仁 masahito.muroi@linecorp.com a écrit :
Hi oslo team,
We'd like to contribute HTTP base direct RPC driver to the oslo.messaging community. We have developed the HTTP base driver internally. We have been using the driver in the production with over 10K hypervisors now.
I checked the IRC meeting log of the oslo team[1], but there is no regluar meeting in 2023. Is it okay to submit oslo-spec[2] to propose the driver directly, or is there another good place to discuss the feature before submitting a spec?
best regards, Masahito
-- Hervé Beraud Senior Software Engineer at Red Hat irc: hberaud https://github.com/4383/
Hello Herve,
Thank you for the quick replying. Let us prepare the spec and submit it.
btw, does olso team have PTG in the up-comming summit? We'd like to get a quick feedback of the spec if time is allowed in the PTG. But it looks like oslo team won't have PTG there.
best regards, Masahito
-----Original Message----- From: "Herve Beraud"hberaud@redhat.com To: "室井雅仁"masahito.muroi@linecorp.com; Cc: openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org; Sent: 2023/06/05(月) 17:21 (GMT+09:00) Subject: Re: [oslo] HTTP base direct RPC oslo.messaging driver contribution
Hello Masahito,
Submission to oslo-spec is a good starting point.
Best regards
Le lun. 5 juin 2023 à 10:04, 室井雅仁 masahito.muroi@linecorp.com a écrit :
Hi oslo team,
We'd like to contribute HTTP base direct RPC driver to the oslo.messaging community. We have developed the HTTP base driver internally. We have been using the driver in the production with over 10K hypervisors now.
I checked the IRC meeting log of the oslo team[1], but there is no regluar meeting in 2023. Is it okay to submit oslo-spec[2] to propose the driver directly, or is there another good place to discuss the feature before submitting a spec?
1. https://meetings.opendev.org/#Oslo_Team_Meeting 2. https://opendev.org/openstack/oslo-specs
best regards, Masahito
-- Hervé Beraud Senior Software Engineer at Red Hat irc: hberaud https://github.com/4383/
Hello,
Indeed, Oslo doesn't have PTG sessions.
Best regards
Le lun. 5 juin 2023 à 10:42, Masahito Muroi masahito.muroi@linecorp.com a écrit :
Hello Herve,
Thank you for the quick replying. Let us prepare the spec and submit it.
btw, does olso team have PTG in the up-comming summit? We'd like to get a quick feedback of the spec if time is allowed in the PTG. But it looks like oslo team won't have PTG there.
best regards, Masahito
-----Original Message----- *From:* "Herve Beraud"hberaud@redhat.com *To:* "室井雅仁"masahito.muroi@linecorp.com; *Cc:* openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org; *Sent:* 2023/06/05(月) 17:21 (GMT+09:00) *Subject:* Re: [oslo] HTTP base direct RPC oslo.messaging driver contribution
Hello Masahito,
Submission to oslo-spec is a good starting point.
Best regards
Le lun. 5 juin 2023 à 10:04, 室井雅仁 masahito.muroi@linecorp.com a écrit :
Hi oslo team,
We'd like to contribute HTTP base direct RPC driver to the oslo.messaging community. We have developed the HTTP base driver internally. We have been using the driver in the production with over 10K hypervisors now.
I checked the IRC meeting log of the oslo team[1], but there is no regluar meeting in 2023. Is it okay to submit oslo-spec[2] to propose the driver directly, or is there another good place to discuss the feature before submitting a spec?
best regards, Masahito
-- Hervé Beraud Senior Software Engineer at Red Hat irc: hberaud https://github.com/4383/
Hello,
This is very interesting and I agree having the spec would be the good way to move this forward.
We have not requested oslo sessions in the upcoming PTG but Stephen and I are attending it so will be available for the discussion.
Because some other cores such as Herve won't be there, we'd need to continue further discussions after PTG in spec review, but if that early in-person discussion sounds helpful for you then I'll reserve a table.
Thank you, Takashi
On Tue, Jun 6, 2023 at 4:48 PM Herve Beraud hberaud@redhat.com wrote:
Hello,
Indeed, Oslo doesn't have PTG sessions.
Best regards
Le lun. 5 juin 2023 à 10:42, Masahito Muroi masahito.muroi@linecorp.com a écrit :
Hello Herve,
Thank you for the quick replying. Let us prepare the spec and submit it.
btw, does olso team have PTG in the up-comming summit? We'd like to get a quick feedback of the spec if time is allowed in the PTG. But it looks like oslo team won't have PTG there.
best regards, Masahito
-----Original Message----- *From:* "Herve Beraud"hberaud@redhat.com *To:* "室井雅仁"masahito.muroi@linecorp.com; *Cc:* openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org; *Sent:* 2023/06/05(月) 17:21 (GMT+09:00) *Subject:* Re: [oslo] HTTP base direct RPC oslo.messaging driver contribution
Hello Masahito,
Submission to oslo-spec is a good starting point.
Best regards
Le lun. 5 juin 2023 à 10:04, 室井雅仁 masahito.muroi@linecorp.com a écrit :
Hi oslo team,
We'd like to contribute HTTP base direct RPC driver to the oslo.messaging community. We have developed the HTTP base driver internally. We have been using the driver in the production with over 10K hypervisors now.
I checked the IRC meeting log of the oslo team[1], but there is no regluar meeting in 2023. Is it okay to submit oslo-spec[2] to propose the driver directly, or is there another good place to discuss the feature before submitting a spec?
best regards, Masahito
-- Hervé Beraud Senior Software Engineer at Red Hat irc: hberaud https://github.com/4383/
-- Hervé Beraud Senior Software Engineer at Red Hat irc: hberaud https://github.com/4383/
Hi,
Thank you everyone for the kindly reply.
I got the PTG situation. Submitting the spec seems to be a nice first step.
We don't have public repository of the driver because of internal repository structure reason. The repository is really stick to the current internal repository structure now. Cleaning up repository would take time so that we didn't do the extra tasks.
best regards. Masahito
-----Original Message----- From: "Takashi Kajinami"tkajinam@redhat.com To: "Masahito Muroi"masahito.muroi@linecorp.com; Cc: openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org; "Herve Beraud"hberaud@redhat.com; Sent: 2023/06/06(火) 18:50 (GMT+09:00) Subject: Re: [oslo] HTTP base direct RPC oslo.messaging driver contribution
Hello,
This is very interesting and I agree having the spec would be the good way to move this forward.
We have not requested oslo sessions in the upcoming PTG but Stephen and I are attending it so will be available for the discussion.
Because some other cores such as Herve won't be there, we'd need to continue further discussions after PTG in spec review, but if that early in-person discussion sounds helpful for you then I'll reserve a table.
Thank you, Takashi
On Tue, Jun 6, 2023 at 4:48 PM Herve Beraud hberaud@redhat.com wrote:
Hello,
Indeed, Oslo doesn't have PTG sessions.
Best regards
Le lun. 5 juin 2023 à 10:42, Masahito Muroi masahito.muroi@linecorp.com a écrit :
Hello Herve,
Thank you for the quick replying. Let us prepare the spec and submit it.
btw, does olso team have PTG in the up-comming summit? We'd like to get a quick feedback of the spec if time is allowed in the PTG. But it looks like oslo team won't have PTG there.
best regards, Masahito
-----Original Message----- From: "Herve Beraud"hberaud@redhat.com To: "室井雅仁"masahito.muroi@linecorp.com; Cc: openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org; Sent: 2023/06/05(月) 17:21 (GMT+09:00) Subject: Re: [oslo] HTTP base direct RPC oslo.messaging driver contribution
Hello Masahito,
Submission to oslo-spec is a good starting point.
Best regards
Le lun. 5 juin 2023 à 10:04, 室井雅仁 masahito.muroi@linecorp.com a écrit :
Hi oslo team,
We'd like to contribute HTTP base direct RPC driver to the oslo.messaging community. We have developed the HTTP base driver internally. We have been using the driver in the production with over 10K hypervisors now.
I checked the IRC meeting log of the oslo team[1], but there is no regluar meeting in 2023. Is it okay to submit oslo-spec[2] to propose the driver directly, or is there another good place to discuss the feature before submitting a spec?
1. https://meetings.opendev.org/#Oslo_Team_Meeting 2. https://opendev.org/openstack/oslo-specs
best regards, Masahito
-- Hervé Beraud Senior Software Engineer at Red Hat irc: hberaud https://github.com/4383/
-- Hervé Beraud Senior Software Engineer at Red Hat irc: hberaud https://github.com/4383/
Jumping in because the thread has been rather reminiscent of the json-rpc messaging feature ironic carries so our users don't have to run with rabbit. I suspect Ironic might be happy to propose it to oslo.messaging if this http driver is acceptable.
Please feel free to add me as a reviewer on the spec.
-Julia
On Tue, Jun 6, 2023 at 2:10 PM Masahito Muroi masahito.muroi@linecorp.com wrote:
Hi,
Thank you everyone for the kindly reply.
I got the PTG situation. Submitting the spec seems to be a nice first step.
We don't have public repository of the driver because of internal repository structure reason. The repository is really stick to the current internal repository structure now. Cleaning up repository would take time so that we didn't do the extra tasks.
best regards. Masahito
-----Original Message----- *From:* "Takashi Kajinami"tkajinam@redhat.com *To:* "Masahito Muroi"masahito.muroi@linecorp.com; *Cc:* openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org; "Herve Beraud"< hberaud@redhat.com>; *Sent:* 2023/06/06(火) 18:50 (GMT+09:00) *Subject:* Re: [oslo] HTTP base direct RPC oslo.messaging driver contribution
Hello,
This is very interesting and I agree having the spec would be the good way to move this forward.
We have not requested oslo sessions in the upcoming PTG but Stephen and I are attending it so will be available for the discussion.
Because some other cores such as Herve won't be there, we'd need to continue further discussions after PTG in spec review, but if that early in-person discussion sounds helpful for you then I'll reserve a table.
Thank you, Takashi
On Tue, Jun 6, 2023 at 4:48 PM Herve Beraud hberaud@redhat.com wrote:
Hello,
Indeed, Oslo doesn't have PTG sessions.
Best regards
Le lun. 5 juin 2023 à 10:42, Masahito Muroi masahito.muroi@linecorp.com a écrit :
Hello Herve,
Thank you for the quick replying. Let us prepare the spec and submit it.
btw, does olso team have PTG in the up-comming summit? We'd like to get a quick feedback of the spec if time is allowed in the PTG. But it looks like oslo team won't have PTG there.
best regards, Masahito
-----Original Message----- *From:* "Herve Beraud"hberaud@redhat.com *To:* "室井雅仁"masahito.muroi@linecorp.com; *Cc:* openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org; *Sent:* 2023/06/05(月) 17:21 (GMT+09:00) *Subject:* Re: [oslo] HTTP base direct RPC oslo.messaging driver contribution
Hello Masahito,
Submission to oslo-spec is a good starting point.
Best regards
Le lun. 5 juin 2023 à 10:04, 室井雅仁 masahito.muroi@linecorp.com a écrit :
Hi oslo team,
We'd like to contribute HTTP base direct RPC driver to the oslo.messaging community. We have developed the HTTP base driver internally. We have been using the driver in the production with over 10K hypervisors now.
I checked the IRC meeting log of the oslo team[1], but there is no regluar meeting in 2023. Is it okay to submit oslo-spec[2] to propose the driver directly, or is there another good place to discuss the feature before submitting a spec?
best regards, Masahito
-- Hervé Beraud Senior Software Engineer at Red Hat irc: hberaud https://github.com/4383/
-- Hervé Beraud Senior Software Engineer at Red Hat irc: hberaud https://github.com/4383/
I'm interested in this as well, please add me to the spec if you need additional brains :). I'll also be at the summit if you'd like to discuss any of it in person.
-- Jay Faulkner Ironic PTL
On Tue, Jun 6, 2023 at 3:14 PM Julia Kreger juliaashleykreger@gmail.com wrote:
Jumping in because the thread has been rather reminiscent of the json-rpc messaging feature ironic carries so our users don't have to run with rabbit. I suspect Ironic might be happy to propose it to oslo.messaging if this http driver is acceptable.
Please feel free to add me as a reviewer on the spec.
-Julia
On Tue, Jun 6, 2023 at 2:10 PM Masahito Muroi masahito.muroi@linecorp.com wrote:
Hi,
Thank you everyone for the kindly reply.
I got the PTG situation. Submitting the spec seems to be a nice first step.
We don't have public repository of the driver because of internal repository structure reason. The repository is really stick to the current internal repository structure now. Cleaning up repository would take time so that we didn't do the extra tasks.
best regards. Masahito
-----Original Message----- *From:* "Takashi Kajinami"tkajinam@redhat.com *To:* "Masahito Muroi"masahito.muroi@linecorp.com; *Cc:* openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org; "Herve Beraud"< hberaud@redhat.com>; *Sent:* 2023/06/06(火) 18:50 (GMT+09:00) *Subject:* Re: [oslo] HTTP base direct RPC oslo.messaging driver contribution
Hello,
This is very interesting and I agree having the spec would be the good way to move this forward.
We have not requested oslo sessions in the upcoming PTG but Stephen and I are attending it so will be available for the discussion.
Because some other cores such as Herve won't be there, we'd need to continue further discussions after PTG in spec review, but if that early in-person discussion sounds helpful for you then I'll reserve a table.
Thank you, Takashi
On Tue, Jun 6, 2023 at 4:48 PM Herve Beraud hberaud@redhat.com wrote:
Hello,
Indeed, Oslo doesn't have PTG sessions.
Best regards
Le lun. 5 juin 2023 à 10:42, Masahito Muroi masahito.muroi@linecorp.com a écrit :
Hello Herve,
Thank you for the quick replying. Let us prepare the spec and submit it.
btw, does olso team have PTG in the up-comming summit? We'd like to get a quick feedback of the spec if time is allowed in the PTG. But it looks like oslo team won't have PTG there.
best regards, Masahito
-----Original Message----- *From:* "Herve Beraud"hberaud@redhat.com *To:* "室井雅仁"masahito.muroi@linecorp.com; *Cc:* openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org; *Sent:* 2023/06/05(月) 17:21 (GMT+09:00) *Subject:* Re: [oslo] HTTP base direct RPC oslo.messaging driver contribution
Hello Masahito,
Submission to oslo-spec is a good starting point.
Best regards
Le lun. 5 juin 2023 à 10:04, 室井雅仁 masahito.muroi@linecorp.com a écrit :
Hi oslo team,
We'd like to contribute HTTP base direct RPC driver to the oslo.messaging community. We have developed the HTTP base driver internally. We have been using the driver in the production with over 10K hypervisors now.
I checked the IRC meeting log of the oslo team[1], but there is no regluar meeting in 2023. Is it okay to submit oslo-spec[2] to propose the driver directly, or is there another good place to discuss the feature before submitting a spec?
best regards, Masahito
-- Hervé Beraud Senior Software Engineer at Red Hat irc: hberaud https://github.com/4383/
-- Hervé Beraud Senior Software Engineer at Red Hat irc: hberaud https://github.com/4383/
Le mer. 7 juin 2023 à 00:31, Jay Faulkner jay@gr-oss.io a écrit :
I'm interested in this as well, please add me to the spec if you need additional brains :). I'll also be at the summit if you'd like to discuss any of it in person.
-- Jay Faulkner Ironic PTL
On Tue, Jun 6, 2023 at 3:14 PM Julia Kreger juliaashleykreger@gmail.com wrote:
Jumping in because the thread has been rather reminiscent of the json-rpc messaging feature ironic carries so our users don't have to run with rabbit. I suspect Ironic might be happy to propose it to oslo.messaging if this http driver is acceptable.
Indeed, it could be interesting, thanks Julia.
Please feel free to add me as a reviewer on the spec.
-Julia
On Tue, Jun 6, 2023 at 2:10 PM Masahito Muroi < masahito.muroi@linecorp.com> wrote:
Hi,
Thank you everyone for the kindly reply.
I got the PTG situation. Submitting the spec seems to be a nice first step.
We don't have public repository of the driver because of internal repository structure reason. The repository is really stick to the current internal repository structure now. Cleaning up repository would take time so that we didn't do the extra tasks.
best regards. Masahito
-----Original Message----- *From:* "Takashi Kajinami"tkajinam@redhat.com *To:* "Masahito Muroi"masahito.muroi@linecorp.com; *Cc:* openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org; "Herve Beraud"< hberaud@redhat.com>; *Sent:* 2023/06/06(火) 18:50 (GMT+09:00) *Subject:* Re: [oslo] HTTP base direct RPC oslo.messaging driver contribution
Hello,
This is very interesting and I agree having the spec would be the good way to move this forward.
We have not requested oslo sessions in the upcoming PTG but Stephen and I are attending it so will be available for the discussion.
Because some other cores such as Herve won't be there, we'd need to continue further discussions after PTG in spec review, but if that early in-person discussion sounds helpful for you then I'll reserve a table.
Thank you, Takashi
On Tue, Jun 6, 2023 at 4:48 PM Herve Beraud hberaud@redhat.com wrote:
Hello,
Indeed, Oslo doesn't have PTG sessions.
Best regards
Le lun. 5 juin 2023 à 10:42, Masahito Muroi masahito.muroi@linecorp.com a écrit :
Hello Herve,
Thank you for the quick replying. Let us prepare the spec and submit it.
btw, does olso team have PTG in the up-comming summit? We'd like to get a quick feedback of the spec if time is allowed in the PTG. But it looks like oslo team won't have PTG there.
best regards, Masahito
-----Original Message----- *From:* "Herve Beraud"hberaud@redhat.com *To:* "室井雅仁"masahito.muroi@linecorp.com; *Cc:* openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org; *Sent:* 2023/06/05(月) 17:21 (GMT+09:00) *Subject:* Re: [oslo] HTTP base direct RPC oslo.messaging driver contribution
Hello Masahito,
Submission to oslo-spec is a good starting point.
Best regards
Le lun. 5 juin 2023 à 10:04, 室井雅仁 masahito.muroi@linecorp.com a écrit :
Hi oslo team,
We'd like to contribute HTTP base direct RPC driver to the oslo.messaging community. We have developed the HTTP base driver internally. We have been using the driver in the production with over 10K hypervisors now.
I checked the IRC meeting log of the oslo team[1], but there is no regluar meeting in 2023. Is it okay to submit oslo-spec[2] to propose the driver directly, or is there another good place to discuss the feature before submitting a spec?
best regards, Masahito
-- Hervé Beraud Senior Software Engineer at Red Hat irc: hberaud https://github.com/4383/
-- Hervé Beraud Senior Software Engineer at Red Hat irc: hberaud https://github.com/4383/
Hello,
Interesting! Looking forward to reading the spec and potential code for this.
Best regards Tobias
On 7 Jun 2023, at 10:41, Herve Beraud hberaud@redhat.com wrote:
Le mer. 7 juin 2023 à 00:31, Jay Faulkner <jay@gr-oss.iomailto:jay@gr-oss.io> a écrit : I'm interested in this as well, please add me to the spec if you need additional brains :). I'll also be at the summit if you'd like to discuss any of it in person.
-- Jay Faulkner Ironic PTL
On Tue, Jun 6, 2023 at 3:14 PM Julia Kreger <juliaashleykreger@gmail.commailto:juliaashleykreger@gmail.com> wrote: Jumping in because the thread has been rather reminiscent of the json-rpc messaging feature ironic carries so our users don't have to run with rabbit. I suspect Ironic might be happy to propose it to oslo.messaging if this http driver is acceptable.
Indeed, it could be interesting, thanks Julia.
Please feel free to add me as a reviewer on the spec.
-Julia
On Tue, Jun 6, 2023 at 2:10 PM Masahito Muroi <masahito.muroi@linecorp.commailto:masahito.muroi@linecorp.com> wrote: Hi,
Thank you everyone for the kindly reply.
I got the PTG situation. Submitting the spec seems to be a nice first step.
We don't have public repository of the driver because of internal repository structure reason. The repository is really stick to the current internal repository structure now. Cleaning up repository would take time so that we didn't do the extra tasks.
best regards. Masahito
-----Original Message----- From: "Takashi Kajinami"<tkajinam@redhat.commailto:tkajinam@redhat.com> To: "Masahito Muroi"<masahito.muroi@linecorp.commailto:masahito.muroi@linecorp.com>; Cc: <openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.orgmailto:openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org>; "Herve Beraud"<hberaud@redhat.commailto:hberaud@redhat.com>; Sent: 2023/06/06(火) 18:50 (GMT+09:00) Subject: Re: [oslo] HTTP base direct RPC oslo.messaging driver contribution
Hello,
This is very interesting and I agree having the spec would be the good way to move this forward.
We have not requested oslo sessions in the upcoming PTG but Stephen and I are attending it so will be available for the discussion.
Because some other cores such as Herve won't be there, we'd need to continue further discussions after PTG in spec review, but if that early in-person discussion sounds helpful for you then I'll reserve a table.
Thank you, Takashi
On Tue, Jun 6, 2023 at 4:48 PM Herve Beraud <hberaud@redhat.commailto:hberaud@redhat.com> wrote: Hello,
Indeed, Oslo doesn't have PTG sessions.
Best regards
Le lun. 5 juin 2023 à 10:42, Masahito Muroi <masahito.muroi@linecorp.commailto:masahito.muroi@linecorp.com> a écrit : Hello Herve,
Thank you for the quick replying. Let us prepare the spec and submit it.
btw, does olso team have PTG in the up-comming summit? We'd like to get a quick feedback of the spec if time is allowed in the PTG. But it looks like oslo team won't have PTG there.
best regards, Masahito
-----Original Message----- From: "Herve Beraud"<hberaud@redhat.commailto:hberaud@redhat.com> To: "室井雅仁"<masahito.muroi@linecorp.commailto:masahito.muroi@linecorp.com>; Cc: <openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.orgmailto:openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org>; Sent: 2023/06/05(月) 17:21 (GMT+09:00) Subject: Re: [oslo] HTTP base direct RPC oslo.messaging driver contribution
Hello Masahito,
Submission to oslo-spec is a good starting point.
Best regards
Le lun. 5 juin 2023 à 10:04, 室井雅仁 <masahito.muroi@linecorp.commailto:masahito.muroi@linecorp.com> a écrit : Hi oslo team,
We'd like to contribute HTTP base direct RPC driver to the oslo.messaging community. We have developed the HTTP base driver internally. We have been using the driver in the production with over 10K hypervisors now.
I checked the IRC meeting log of the oslo team[1], but there is no regluar meeting in 2023. Is it okay to submit oslo-spec[2] to propose the driver directly, or is there another good place to discuss the feature before submitting a spec?
1. https://meetings.opendev.org/#Oslo_Team_Meeting 2. https://opendev.org/openstack/oslo-specs
best regards, Masahito
-- Hervé Beraud Senior Software Engineer at Red Hat irc: hberaud https://github.com/4383/
-- Hervé Beraud Senior Software Engineer at Red Hat irc: hberaud https://github.com/4383/
[https://ack.mail.navercorp.com/readReceipt/notify/?img=srYmFoKqaAblMrMYaqumK...]
-- Hervé Beraud Senior Software Engineer at Red Hat irc: hberaud https://github.com/4383/
Hi all,
We have pushed the spec. Please feel free to review it. https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/oslo-specs/+/885809
best regards, Masahito
-----Original Message----- From: "Jay Faulkner"jay@gr-oss.io To: "Julia Kreger"juliaashleykreger@gmail.com; Cc: "Masahito Muroi"masahito.muroi@linecorp.com; "Takashi Kajinami"tkajinam@redhat.com; openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org; "Herve Beraud"hberaud@redhat.com; "Arnaud Morin"arnaud.morin@gmail.com; Sent: 2023/06/07(水) 07:31 (GMT+09:00) Subject: Re: [oslo][largescale-sig] HTTP base direct RPC oslo.messaging driver contribution
I'm interested in this as well, please add me to the spec if you need additional brains :). I'll also be at the summit if you'd like to discuss any of it in person.
-- Jay Faulkner Ironic PTL
On Tue, Jun 6, 2023 at 3:14 PM Julia Kreger juliaashleykreger@gmail.com wrote:
Jumping in because the thread has been rather reminiscent of the json-rpc messaging feature ironic carries so our users don't have to run with rabbit. I suspect Ironic might be happy to propose it to oslo.messaging if this http driver is acceptable.
Please feel free to add me as a reviewer on the spec.
-Julia
On Tue, Jun 6, 2023 at 2:10 PM Masahito Muroi masahito.muroi@linecorp.com wrote:
Hi,
Thank you everyone for the kindly reply.
I got the PTG situation. Submitting the spec seems to be a nice first step.
We don't have public repository of the driver because of internal repository structure reason. The repository is really stick to the current internal repository structure now. Cleaning up repository would take time so that we didn't do the extra tasks.
best regards. Masahito
-----Original Message----- From: "Takashi Kajinami"tkajinam@redhat.com To: "Masahito Muroi"masahito.muroi@linecorp.com; Cc: openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org; "Herve Beraud"hberaud@redhat.com; Sent: 2023/06/06(火) 18:50 (GMT+09:00) Subject: Re: [oslo] HTTP base direct RPC oslo.messaging driver contribution
Hello,
This is very interesting and I agree having the spec would be the good way to move this forward.
We have not requested oslo sessions in the upcoming PTG but Stephen and I are attending it so will be available for the discussion.
Because some other cores such as Herve won't be there, we'd need to continue further discussions after PTG in spec review, but if that early in-person discussion sounds helpful for you then I'll reserve a table.
Thank you, Takashi
On Tue, Jun 6, 2023 at 4:48 PM Herve Beraud hberaud@redhat.com wrote:
Hello,
Indeed, Oslo doesn't have PTG sessions.
Best regards
Le lun. 5 juin 2023 à 10:42, Masahito Muroi masahito.muroi@linecorp.com a écrit :
Hello Herve,
Thank you for the quick replying. Let us prepare the spec and submit it.
btw, does olso team have PTG in the up-comming summit? We'd like to get a quick feedback of the spec if time is allowed in the PTG. But it looks like oslo team won't have PTG there.
best regards, Masahito
-----Original Message----- From: "Herve Beraud"hberaud@redhat.com To: "室井雅仁"masahito.muroi@linecorp.com; Cc: openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org; Sent: 2023/06/05(月) 17:21 (GMT+09:00) Subject: Re: [oslo] HTTP base direct RPC oslo.messaging driver contribution
Hello Masahito,
Submission to oslo-spec is a good starting point.
Best regards
Le lun. 5 juin 2023 à 10:04, 室井雅仁 masahito.muroi@linecorp.com a écrit :
Hi oslo team,
We'd like to contribute HTTP base direct RPC driver to the oslo.messaging community. We have developed the HTTP base driver internally. We have been using the driver in the production with over 10K hypervisors now.
I checked the IRC meeting log of the oslo team[1], but there is no regluar meeting in 2023. Is it okay to submit oslo-spec[2] to propose the driver directly, or is there another good place to discuss the feature before submitting a spec?
1. https://meetings.opendev.org/#Oslo_Team_Meeting 2. https://opendev.org/openstack/oslo-specs
best regards, Masahito
-- Hervé Beraud Senior Software Engineer at Red Hat irc: hberaud https://github.com/4383/
-- Hervé Beraud Senior Software Engineer at Red Hat irc: hberaud https://github.com/4383/
Stephen and I from oslo core met the LINE team at Vancouver and discussed this topic, and in short we(at least Stephen and I) agreed with the proposal. Let me dump some topics we discussed there. # Sorry I thought I posted this somewhere early...
Some concerns were raised about adding consul as a new core component, but we agreed with using it as the initial implementation. There were some suggestions to rely on existing service records stored in DB but we need some amount of work, to address the following points. - Not all OpenStack services store service records in DB. (eg ceilometer) - Even though some services store service records in DB, the available information there is not enough - We have to maintain mapping between host and reachable endpoint - Some services spawns worker and need endpoint *per worker*, and we need endpoint list for all workers
Random port assignment from range is another topic we discussed there, but we eventually agreed that this is the required approach, mainly because it's hard to allocate port numbers for all services running in a single node(required number of ports can be different based on services/workers/etc). So we agreed that the proposed way to dynamically allocate available ports from the given range is a good solution.
Also, LINE already deployed this feature in their production and it has been proven to work well in scale. As we don't see any technical blockers at this moment, we agreed with moving forward with the proposed architecture. There can be some improvement like adding the driver mechanism for cluster backend but, we would avoid expanding our current scope, until someone is really interested in working on such topics.
Finally we suggested updating the test plan and adding a devstack(at least single node) job in the gate so that we can properly maintain the feature.
Other people might have additional thoughts, but hope the above outcomes make the current proposal more clear to all.
Thank you, Takashi
On Sat, Jun 10, 2023 at 6:14 PM Masahito Muroi masahito.muroi@linecorp.com wrote:
Hi all,
We have pushed the spec. Please feel free to review it. https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/oslo-specs/+/885809
best regards, Masahito
-----Original Message----- *From:* "Jay Faulkner"jay@gr-oss.io *To:* "Julia Kreger"juliaashleykreger@gmail.com; *Cc:* "Masahito Muroi"masahito.muroi@linecorp.com; "Takashi Kajinami"< tkajinam@redhat.com>; openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org; "Herve Beraud"hberaud@redhat.com; "Arnaud Morin"arnaud.morin@gmail.com; *Sent:* 2023/06/07(水) 07:31 (GMT+09:00) *Subject:* Re: [oslo][largescale-sig] HTTP base direct RPC oslo.messaging driver contribution
I'm interested in this as well, please add me to the spec if you need additional brains :). I'll also be at the summit if you'd like to discuss any of it in person.
-- Jay Faulkner Ironic PTL
On Tue, Jun 6, 2023 at 3:14 PM Julia Kreger juliaashleykreger@gmail.com wrote:
Jumping in because the thread has been rather reminiscent of the json-rpc messaging feature ironic carries so our users don't have to run with rabbit. I suspect Ironic might be happy to propose it to oslo.messaging if this http driver is acceptable.
Please feel free to add me as a reviewer on the spec.
-Julia
On Tue, Jun 6, 2023 at 2:10 PM Masahito Muroi masahito.muroi@linecorp.com wrote:
Hi,
Thank you everyone for the kindly reply.
I got the PTG situation. Submitting the spec seems to be a nice first step.
We don't have public repository of the driver because of internal repository structure reason. The repository is really stick to the current internal repository structure now. Cleaning up repository would take time so that we didn't do the extra tasks.
best regards. Masahito
-----Original Message----- *From:* "Takashi Kajinami"tkajinam@redhat.com *To:* "Masahito Muroi"masahito.muroi@linecorp.com; *Cc:* openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org; "Herve Beraud"< hberaud@redhat.com>; *Sent:* 2023/06/06(火) 18:50 (GMT+09:00) *Subject:* Re: [oslo] HTTP base direct RPC oslo.messaging driver contribution
Hello,
This is very interesting and I agree having the spec would be the good way to move this forward.
We have not requested oslo sessions in the upcoming PTG but Stephen and I are attending it so will be available for the discussion.
Because some other cores such as Herve won't be there, we'd need to continue further discussions after PTG in spec review, but if that early in-person discussion sounds helpful for you then I'll reserve a table.
Thank you, Takashi
On Tue, Jun 6, 2023 at 4:48 PM Herve Beraud hberaud@redhat.com wrote:
Hello,
Indeed, Oslo doesn't have PTG sessions.
Best regards
Le lun. 5 juin 2023 à 10:42, Masahito Muroi masahito.muroi@linecorp.com a écrit :
Hello Herve,
Thank you for the quick replying. Let us prepare the spec and submit it.
btw, does olso team have PTG in the up-comming summit? We'd like to get a quick feedback of the spec if time is allowed in the PTG. But it looks like oslo team won't have PTG there.
best regards, Masahito
-----Original Message----- *From:* "Herve Beraud"hberaud@redhat.com *To:* "室井雅仁"masahito.muroi@linecorp.com; *Cc:* openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org; *Sent:* 2023/06/05(月) 17:21 (GMT+09:00) *Subject:* Re: [oslo] HTTP base direct RPC oslo.messaging driver contribution
Hello Masahito,
Submission to oslo-spec is a good starting point.
Best regards
Le lun. 5 juin 2023 à 10:04, 室井雅仁 masahito.muroi@linecorp.com a écrit :
Hi oslo team,
We'd like to contribute HTTP base direct RPC driver to the oslo.messaging community. We have developed the HTTP base driver internally. We have been using the driver in the production with over 10K hypervisors now.
I checked the IRC meeting log of the oslo team[1], but there is no regluar meeting in 2023. Is it okay to submit oslo-spec[2] to propose the driver directly, or is there another good place to discuss the feature before submitting a spec?
best regards, Masahito
-- Hervé Beraud Senior Software Engineer at Red Hat irc: hberaud https://github.com/4383/
-- Hervé Beraud Senior Software Engineer at Red Hat irc: hberaud https://github.com/4383/
Hi, Takashi, Herve and Stephan,
Thank you for the summit wrap-up, Takashi.
We have addressed all the unclear points in the spec and updated following the summit offsite talk. I hope the latest spec enhances your thoughts about the new driver details. Please review the spec file again. https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/oslo-specs/+/885809
Thanks, Masahito
-----Original Message----- From: "Takashi Kajinami"tkajinam@redhat.com To: "Masahito Muroi"masahito.muroi@linecorp.com; Cc: "Jay Faulkner"jay@gr-oss.io; "Julia Kreger"juliaashleykreger@gmail.com; openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org; "Herve Beraud"hberaud@redhat.com; "Arnaud Morin"arnaud.morin@gmail.com; Sent: 2023/06/29(木) 13:46 (GMT+09:00) Subject: Re: [oslo][largescale-sig] HTTP base direct RPC oslo.messaging driver contribution
Stephen and I from oslo core met the LINE team at Vancouver and discussed this topic, and in short we(at least Stephen and I) agreed with the proposal. Let me dump some topics we discussed there. # Sorry I thought I posted this somewhere early...
Some concerns were raised about adding consul as a new core component, but we agreed with using it as the initial implementation. There were some suggestions to rely on existing service records stored in DB but we need some amount of work, to address the following points. - Not all OpenStack services store service records in DB. (eg ceilometer) - Even though some services store service records in DB, the available information there is not enough - We have to maintain mapping between host and reachable endpoint - Some services spawns worker and need endpoint *per worker*, and we need endpoint list for all workers
Random port assignment from range is another topic we discussed there, but we eventually agreed that this is the required approach, mainly because it's hard to allocate port numbers for all services running in a single node(required number of ports can be different based on services/workers/etc). So we agreed that the proposed way to dynamically allocate available ports from the given range is a good solution.
Also, LINE already deployed this feature in their production and it has been proven to work well in scale. As we don't see any technical blockers at this moment, we agreed with moving forward with the proposed architecture. There can be some improvement like adding the driver mechanism for cluster backend but, we would avoid expanding our current scope, until someone is really interested in working on such topics.
Finally we suggested updating the test plan and adding a devstack(at least single node) job in the gate so that we can properly maintain the feature.
Other people might have additional thoughts, but hope the above outcomes make the current proposal more clear to all.
Thank you, Takashi
On Sat, Jun 10, 2023 at 6:14 PM Masahito Muroi masahito.muroi@linecorp.com wrote:
Hi all,
We have pushed the spec. Please feel free to review it. https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/oslo-specs/+/885809
best regards, Masahito
-----Original Message----- From: "Jay Faulkner"jay@gr-oss.io To: "Julia Kreger"juliaashleykreger@gmail.com; Cc: "Masahito Muroi"masahito.muroi@linecorp.com; "Takashi Kajinami"tkajinam@redhat.com; openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org; "Herve Beraud"hberaud@redhat.com; "Arnaud Morin"arnaud.morin@gmail.com; Sent: 2023/06/07(水) 07:31 (GMT+09:00) Subject: Re: [oslo][largescale-sig] HTTP base direct RPC oslo.messaging driver contribution
I'm interested in this as well, please add me to the spec if you need additional brains :). I'll also be at the summit if you'd like to discuss any of it in person.
-- Jay Faulkner Ironic PTL
On Tue, Jun 6, 2023 at 3:14 PM Julia Kreger juliaashleykreger@gmail.com wrote:
Jumping in because the thread has been rather reminiscent of the json-rpc messaging feature ironic carries so our users don't have to run with rabbit. I suspect Ironic might be happy to propose it to oslo.messaging if this http driver is acceptable.
Please feel free to add me as a reviewer on the spec.
-Julia
On Tue, Jun 6, 2023 at 2:10 PM Masahito Muroi masahito.muroi@linecorp.com wrote:
Hi,
Thank you everyone for the kindly reply.
I got the PTG situation. Submitting the spec seems to be a nice first step.
We don't have public repository of the driver because of internal repository structure reason. The repository is really stick to the current internal repository structure now. Cleaning up repository would take time so that we didn't do the extra tasks.
best regards. Masahito
-----Original Message----- From: "Takashi Kajinami"tkajinam@redhat.com To: "Masahito Muroi"masahito.muroi@linecorp.com; Cc: openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org; "Herve Beraud"hberaud@redhat.com; Sent: 2023/06/06(火) 18:50 (GMT+09:00) Subject: Re: [oslo] HTTP base direct RPC oslo.messaging driver contribution
Hello,
This is very interesting and I agree having the spec would be the good way to move this forward.
We have not requested oslo sessions in the upcoming PTG but Stephen and I are attending it so will be available for the discussion.
Because some other cores such as Herve won't be there, we'd need to continue further discussions after PTG in spec review, but if that early in-person discussion sounds helpful for you then I'll reserve a table.
Thank you, Takashi
On Tue, Jun 6, 2023 at 4:48 PM Herve Beraud hberaud@redhat.com wrote:
Hello,
Indeed, Oslo doesn't have PTG sessions.
Best regards
Le lun. 5 juin 2023 à 10:42, Masahito Muroi masahito.muroi@linecorp.com a écrit :
Hello Herve,
Thank you for the quick replying. Let us prepare the spec and submit it.
btw, does olso team have PTG in the up-comming summit? We'd like to get a quick feedback of the spec if time is allowed in the PTG. But it looks like oslo team won't have PTG there.
best regards, Masahito
-----Original Message----- From: "Herve Beraud"hberaud@redhat.com To: "室井雅仁"masahito.muroi@linecorp.com; Cc: openstack-discuss@lists.openstack.org; Sent: 2023/06/05(月) 17:21 (GMT+09:00) Subject: Re: [oslo] HTTP base direct RPC oslo.messaging driver contribution
Hello Masahito,
Submission to oslo-spec is a good starting point.
Best regards
Le lun. 5 juin 2023 à 10:04, 室井雅仁 masahito.muroi@linecorp.com a écrit :
Hi oslo team,
We'd like to contribute HTTP base direct RPC driver to the oslo.messaging community. We have developed the HTTP base driver internally. We have been using the driver in the production with over 10K hypervisors now.
I checked the IRC meeting log of the oslo team[1], but there is no regluar meeting in 2023. Is it okay to submit oslo-spec[2] to propose the driver directly, or is there another good place to discuss the feature before submitting a spec?
1. https://meetings.opendev.org/#Oslo_Team_Meeting 2. https://opendev.org/openstack/oslo-specs
best regards, Masahito
-- Hervé Beraud Senior Software Engineer at Red Hat irc: hberaud https://github.com/4383/
-- Hervé Beraud Senior Software Engineer at Red Hat irc: hberaud https://github.com/4383/
participants (8)
-
Arnaud Morin
-
Herve Beraud
-
Jay Faulkner
-
Julia Kreger
-
Masahito Muroi
-
Takashi Kajinami
-
Tobias Urdin
-
室井雅仁