[kolla] Support Octavia for ubuntu binary on stable/rocky?
Hi,
I'm trying to install Octavia in Rocky release with Ubuntu binary distro. And found that there're no docker images for Ubuntu binary. Then I checked the Kolla dockerfile and found that it will not build the image since it's not support yet. But I found that the Ubuntu Cloud Archive Team has already putted Octavia packages into cloud repository [1]. Since some images built using from this PPA, I think it can support ubuntu binary in Rocky release.
I tried put package code into Docker files and build, but it gave me an error message like below: ERROR:kolla.common.utils:octavia-api Failed with status: matched ERROR:kolla.common.utils:octavia-health-manager Failed with status: matched ERROR:kolla.common.utils:octavia-housekeeping Failed with status: matched ERROR:kolla.common.utils:octavia-worker Failed with status: matched
So I think there's limit somewhere. How can I release it?
Thanks, Eddie.
[1] https://launchpad.net/~ubuntu-cloud-archive/+archive/ubuntu/rocky-staging
On Tue, 17 Sep 2019 at 06:36, Eddie Yen missile0407@gmail.com wrote:
Hi,
I'm trying to install Octavia in Rocky release with Ubuntu binary distro. And found that there're no docker images for Ubuntu binary. Then I checked the Kolla dockerfile and found that it will not build the image since it's not support yet. But I found that the Ubuntu Cloud Archive Team has already putted Octavia packages into cloud repository [1]. Since some images built using from this PPA, I think it can support ubuntu binary in Rocky release.
I tried put package code into Docker files and build, but it gave me an error message like below: ERROR:kolla.common.utils:octavia-api Failed with status: matched ERROR:kolla.common.utils:octavia-health-manager Failed with status: matched ERROR:kolla.common.utils:octavia-housekeeping Failed with status: matched ERROR:kolla.common.utils:octavia-worker Failed with status: matched
So I think there's limit somewhere. How can I release it?
Thanks, Eddie.
[1] https://launchpad.net/~ubuntu-cloud-archive/+archive/ubuntu/rocky-staging
Hi Eddie,
We explicitly fail when building octavia images on ubuntu/binary, see docker/octavia/octavia-base/Dockerfile.j2:
RUN echo '{{ install_type }} not yet available for {{ base_distro }}' \ && /bin/false
If you think we can support octavia now, please propose a patch to master branch. I'm afraid we can't accept new features to stable branches though, so you'll have to carry this change locally.
Mark
Hi Mark,
Roger that. And I'm afraid I can't patch to master branch since I didn't find any Octavia package release for stein and further. Also it seems like the newer Octavia package will release on newer Ubuntu distro, may not release on Bionic for now.
So I'll test and use locally if success.
And I think it would be better that adding check mechanism into pre-check. Throw an error message if user want to deploy Octavia on ubuntu/binary. I may take times to do this patch.
Many thanks, Eddie.
Mark Goddard mark@stackhpc.com 於 2019年9月17日 週二 下午5:14寫道：
On Tue, 17 Sep 2019 at 06:36, Eddie Yen missile0407@gmail.com wrote:
Hi,
I'm trying to install Octavia in Rocky release with Ubuntu binary
distro. And found that there're no docker images for Ubuntu binary.
Then I checked the Kolla dockerfile and found that it will not build the
image since it's not support yet.
But I found that the Ubuntu Cloud Archive Team has already putted
Octavia packages into cloud repository [1]. Since some images built using from this PPA, I think it can support ubuntu binary in Rocky release.
I tried put package code into Docker files and build, but it gave me an
error message like below:
ERROR:kolla.common.utils:octavia-api Failed with status: matched ERROR:kolla.common.utils:octavia-health-manager Failed with status:
matched
ERROR:kolla.common.utils:octavia-housekeeping Failed with status: matched ERROR:kolla.common.utils:octavia-worker Failed with status: matched
So I think there's limit somewhere. How can I release it?
Thanks, Eddie.
[1]
https://launchpad.net/~ubuntu-cloud-archive/+archive/ubuntu/rocky-staging
Hi Eddie,
We explicitly fail when building octavia images on ubuntu/binary, see docker/octavia/octavia-base/Dockerfile.j2:
RUN echo '{{ install_type }} not yet available for {{ base_distro }}' \ && /bin/false
If you think we can support octavia now, please propose a patch to master branch. I'm afraid we can't accept new features to stable branches though, so you'll have to carry this change locally.
Mark
On Tue, 17 Sep 2019 at 12:17, Eddie Yen missile0407@gmail.com wrote:
Hi Mark,
Roger that. And I'm afraid I can't patch to master branch since I didn't find any Octavia package release for stein and further. Also it seems like the newer Octavia package will release on newer Ubuntu distro, may not release on Bionic for now.
So I'll test and use locally if success.
And I think it would be better that adding check mechanism into pre-check. Throw an error message if user want to deploy Octavia on ubuntu/binary. I may take times to do this patch.
Interesting suggestion. We haven't done that kind of thing before, but I suppose it could be helpful in some circumstances. OTOH, we are working on a support matrix [1] in our documentation which would make this information easier to find, so maybe it's not necessary?
[1] https://review.opendev.org/677500
Many thanks, Eddie.
Mark Goddard mark@stackhpc.com 於 2019年9月17日 週二 下午5:14寫道：
On Tue, 17 Sep 2019 at 06:36, Eddie Yen missile0407@gmail.com wrote:
Hi,
I'm trying to install Octavia in Rocky release with Ubuntu binary distro. And found that there're no docker images for Ubuntu binary. Then I checked the Kolla dockerfile and found that it will not build the image since it's not support yet. But I found that the Ubuntu Cloud Archive Team has already putted Octavia packages into cloud repository [1]. Since some images built using from this PPA, I think it can support ubuntu binary in Rocky release.
I tried put package code into Docker files and build, but it gave me an error message like below: ERROR:kolla.common.utils:octavia-api Failed with status: matched ERROR:kolla.common.utils:octavia-health-manager Failed with status: matched ERROR:kolla.common.utils:octavia-housekeeping Failed with status: matched ERROR:kolla.common.utils:octavia-worker Failed with status: matched
So I think there's limit somewhere. How can I release it?
Thanks, Eddie.
[1] https://launchpad.net/~ubuntu-cloud-archive/+archive/ubuntu/rocky-staging
Hi Eddie,
We explicitly fail when building octavia images on ubuntu/binary, see docker/octavia/octavia-base/Dockerfile.j2:
RUN echo '{{ install_type }} not yet available for {{ base_distro }}' \ && /bin/false
If you think we can support octavia now, please propose a patch to master branch. I'm afraid we can't accept new features to stable branches though, so you'll have to carry this change locally.
Mark
Hmm, I didn't notice that review before. And yeah, having the support form for each component inside the document is better solution. Thanks for letting me know about this information.
Mark Goddard mark@stackhpc.com 於 2019年9月17日 週二 下午7:21寫道：
On Tue, 17 Sep 2019 at 12:17, Eddie Yen missile0407@gmail.com wrote:
Hi Mark,
Roger that. And I'm afraid I can't patch to master branch since I didn't find any
Octavia package release for stein and further.
Also it seems like the newer Octavia package will release on newer
Ubuntu distro, may not release on Bionic for now.
So I'll test and use locally if success.
And I think it would be better that adding check mechanism into
pre-check. Throw an error message if user want to deploy Octavia on ubuntu/binary.
I may take times to do this patch.
Interesting suggestion. We haven't done that kind of thing before, but I suppose it could be helpful in some circumstances. OTOH, we are working on a support matrix [1] in our documentation which would make this information easier to find, so maybe it's not necessary?
[1] https://review.opendev.org/677500
Many thanks, Eddie.
Mark Goddard mark@stackhpc.com 於 2019年9月17日 週二 下午5:14寫道：
On Tue, 17 Sep 2019 at 06:36, Eddie Yen missile0407@gmail.com wrote:
Hi,
I'm trying to install Octavia in Rocky release with Ubuntu binary
distro. And found that there're no docker images for Ubuntu binary.
Then I checked the Kolla dockerfile and found that it will not build
the image since it's not support yet.
But I found that the Ubuntu Cloud Archive Team has already putted
Octavia packages into cloud repository [1]. Since some images built using from this PPA, I think it can support ubuntu binary in Rocky release.
I tried put package code into Docker files and build, but it gave me
an error message like below:
ERROR:kolla.common.utils:octavia-api Failed with status: matched ERROR:kolla.common.utils:octavia-health-manager Failed with status:
matched
ERROR:kolla.common.utils:octavia-housekeeping Failed with status:
matched
ERROR:kolla.common.utils:octavia-worker Failed with status: matched
So I think there's limit somewhere. How can I release it?
Thanks, Eddie.
[1]
https://launchpad.net/~ubuntu-cloud-archive/+archive/ubuntu/rocky-staging
Hi Eddie,
We explicitly fail when building octavia images on ubuntu/binary, see docker/octavia/octavia-base/Dockerfile.j2:
RUN echo '{{ install_type }} not yet available for {{ base_distro }}' \ && /bin/false
If you think we can support octavia now, please propose a patch to master branch. I'm afraid we can't accept new features to stable branches though, so you'll have to carry this change locally.
Mark
participants (2)
-
Eddie Yen
-
Mark Goddard