[ironic] Proposed: Reviewer & Approver team updates
Ironic approvers had a discussion about the current state of the core team, and we propose the following changes. As some context for those not familiar, Ironic has two review groups: - Ironic-Approvers -- this group has the ability to +2 changes and Workflow +1 changes - Ironic-Reviewers -- this group has the ability to +2 changes, but cannot Workflow +1 changes I am proposing the promotion of our two inaugural members of ironic-reviewers into approvers. Both of these contributors have used their +2 judiciously and have earned the trust of the community to use that same judgement about which changes to approve: * Afonne-CID (cid) from GR-OSS (move from ironic-reviewer to ironic-approver) * Doug Goldstein (cardoe) from Rackspace (move from ironic-reviewer to ironic-approver ) Additionally, we'd like to add an existing community member to ironic-reviewers. Jakub Jelinek has become the community expert on RAID support in IPA and has deepened his knowledge across the codebase. We'd like to recognize that by asking him to join the ironic-reviewers team. * Jakub Jelinek (kubajj) from CERN (add to ironic-reviewer) Finally, we would like to move an existing ironic-approver and longtime contributor to emeritus status. Mark Goddard is no longer active in the OpenStack community, and I propose he be moved to emeritus status. This just means that while he may be removed from the team, if at some future point he returns to the Ironic community we may expedite his return to the approvers group. * Mark Goddard (remove from ironic-approvers) Thanks everyone for your contributions to Ironic, current and future. It's nice to see the growth of the team, and hope this opens the door for CID, cardoe, and kubajj to grow themselves and the team further. Thanks, Jay Faulkner G-Research OSS
Ooops, sorry for the late response! I'm +2 to all 4 proposed changes. Thank you for your hard work, folks, and good luck to Mark! Dmitry On 11/5/25 8:00 PM, Jay Faulkner wrote:
Ironic approvers had a discussion about the current state of the core team, and we propose the following changes.
As some context for those not familiar, Ironic has two review groups: - Ironic-Approvers -- this group has the ability to +2 changes and Workflow +1 changes - Ironic-Reviewers -- this group has the ability to +2 changes, but cannot Workflow +1 changes
I am proposing the promotion of our two inaugural members of ironic- reviewers into approvers. Both of these contributors have used their +2 judiciously and have earned the trust of the community to use that same judgement about which changes to approve:
* Afonne-CID (cid) from GR-OSS (move from ironic-reviewer to ironic- approver) * Doug Goldstein (cardoe) from Rackspace (move from ironic-reviewer to ironic-approver )
Additionally, we'd like to add an existing community member to ironic- reviewers. Jakub Jelinek has become the community expert on RAID support in IPA and has deepened his knowledge across the codebase. We'd like to recognize that by asking him to join the ironic-reviewers team.
* Jakub Jelinek (kubajj) from CERN (add to ironic-reviewer)
Finally, we would like to move an existing ironic-approver and longtime contributor to emeritus status. Mark Goddard is no longer active in the OpenStack community, and I propose he be moved to emeritus status. This just means that while he may be removed from the team, if at some future point he returns to the Ironic community we may expedite his return to the approvers group.
* Mark Goddard (remove from ironic-approvers)
Thanks everyone for your contributions to Ironic, current and future. It's nice to see the growth of the team, and hope this opens the door for CID, cardoe, and kubajj to grow themselves and the team further.
Thanks,
Jay Faulkner G-Research OSS
Likewise, I'm good with all noted changes. Thanks Jay! On Fri, Nov 7, 2025 at 9:24 AM Dmitry Tantsur <dtantsur@protonmail.com> wrote:
Ooops, sorry for the late response!
I'm +2 to all 4 proposed changes. Thank you for your hard work, folks, and good luck to Mark!
Dmitry
On 11/5/25 8:00 PM, Jay Faulkner wrote:
Ironic approvers had a discussion about the current state of the core team, and we propose the following changes.
As some context for those not familiar, Ironic has two review groups: - Ironic-Approvers -- this group has the ability to +2 changes and Workflow +1 changes - Ironic-Reviewers -- this group has the ability to +2 changes, but cannot Workflow +1 changes
I am proposing the promotion of our two inaugural members of ironic- reviewers into approvers. Both of these contributors have used their +2 judiciously and have earned the trust of the community to use that same judgement about which changes to approve:
* Afonne-CID (cid) from GR-OSS (move from ironic-reviewer to ironic- approver) * Doug Goldstein (cardoe) from Rackspace (move from ironic-reviewer to ironic-approver )
Additionally, we'd like to add an existing community member to ironic- reviewers. Jakub Jelinek has become the community expert on RAID support in IPA and has deepened his knowledge across the codebase. We'd like to recognize that by asking him to join the ironic-reviewers team.
* Jakub Jelinek (kubajj) from CERN (add to ironic-reviewer)
Finally, we would like to move an existing ironic-approver and longtime contributor to emeritus status. Mark Goddard is no longer active in the OpenStack community, and I propose he be moved to emeritus status. This just means that while he may be removed from the team, if at some future point he returns to the Ironic community we may expedite his return to the approvers group.
* Mark Goddard (remove from ironic-approvers)
Thanks everyone for your contributions to Ironic, current and future. It's nice to see the growth of the team, and hope this opens the door for CID, cardoe, and kubajj to grow themselves and the team further.
Thanks,
Jay Faulkner G-Research OSS
In favor of all changes congrats cid, doug, and kubajj thanks for all your work Mark and good luck! Ciao Riccardo On Mon, Nov 10, 2025 at 4:10 PM Julia Kreger <juliaashleykreger@gmail.com> wrote:
Likewise, I'm good with all noted changes. Thanks Jay!
On Fri, Nov 7, 2025 at 9:24 AM Dmitry Tantsur <dtantsur@protonmail.com> wrote:
Ooops, sorry for the late response!
I'm +2 to all 4 proposed changes. Thank you for your hard work, folks, and good luck to Mark!
Dmitry
On 11/5/25 8:00 PM, Jay Faulkner wrote:
Ironic approvers had a discussion about the current state of the core team, and we propose the following changes.
As some context for those not familiar, Ironic has two review groups: - Ironic-Approvers -- this group has the ability to +2 changes and Workflow +1 changes - Ironic-Reviewers -- this group has the ability to +2 changes, but cannot Workflow +1 changes
I am proposing the promotion of our two inaugural members of ironic- reviewers into approvers. Both of these contributors have used their +2 judiciously and have earned the trust of the community to use that same judgement about which changes to approve:
* Afonne-CID (cid) from GR-OSS (move from ironic-reviewer to ironic- approver) * Doug Goldstein (cardoe) from Rackspace (move from ironic-reviewer to ironic-approver )
Additionally, we'd like to add an existing community member to ironic- reviewers. Jakub Jelinek has become the community expert on RAID
support
in IPA and has deepened his knowledge across the codebase. We'd like to recognize that by asking him to join the ironic-reviewers team.
* Jakub Jelinek (kubajj) from CERN (add to ironic-reviewer)
Finally, we would like to move an existing ironic-approver and longtime contributor to emeritus status. Mark Goddard is no longer active in the OpenStack community, and I propose he be moved to emeritus status. This just means that while he may be removed from the team, if at some future point he returns to the Ironic community we may expedite his return to the approvers group.
* Mark Goddard (remove from ironic-approvers)
Thanks everyone for your contributions to Ironic, current and future. It's nice to see the growth of the team, and hope this opens the door for CID, cardoe, and kubajj to grow themselves and the team further.
Thanks,
Jay Faulkner G-Research OSS
These changes have been executed. Congratulations CID, Doug, and Jakub! - Jay Faulkner G-Research OSS On 11/10/25 7:10 AM, Julia Kreger wrote:
Likewise, I'm good with all noted changes. Thanks Jay!
On Fri, Nov 7, 2025 at 9:24 AM Dmitry Tantsur <dtantsur@protonmail.com> wrote:
Ooops, sorry for the late response!
I'm +2 to all 4 proposed changes. Thank you for your hard work, folks, and good luck to Mark!
Dmitry
On 11/5/25 8:00 PM, Jay Faulkner wrote:
Ironic approvers had a discussion about the current state of the core team, and we propose the following changes.
As some context for those not familiar, Ironic has two review groups: - Ironic-Approvers -- this group has the ability to +2 changes and Workflow +1 changes - Ironic-Reviewers -- this group has the ability to +2 changes, but cannot Workflow +1 changes
I am proposing the promotion of our two inaugural members of ironic- reviewers into approvers. Both of these contributors have used their +2 judiciously and have earned the trust of the community to use that same judgement about which changes to approve:
* Afonne-CID (cid) from GR-OSS (move from ironic-reviewer to ironic- approver) * Doug Goldstein (cardoe) from Rackspace (move from ironic-reviewer to ironic-approver )
Additionally, we'd like to add an existing community member to ironic- reviewers. Jakub Jelinek has become the community expert on RAID support in IPA and has deepened his knowledge across the codebase. We'd like to recognize that by asking him to join the ironic-reviewers team.
* Jakub Jelinek (kubajj) from CERN (add to ironic-reviewer)
Finally, we would like to move an existing ironic-approver and longtime contributor to emeritus status. Mark Goddard is no longer active in the OpenStack community, and I propose he be moved to emeritus status. This just means that while he may be removed from the team, if at some future point he returns to the Ironic community we may expedite his return to the approvers group.
* Mark Goddard (remove from ironic-approvers)
Thanks everyone for your contributions to Ironic, current and future. It's nice to see the growth of the team, and hope this opens the door for CID, cardoe, and kubajj to grow themselves and the team further.
Thanks,
Jay Faulkner G-Research OSS
participants (4)
-
Dmitry Tantsur
-
Jay Faulkner
-
Julia Kreger
-
Riccardo Pittau