Hi,

During the Yoga PTG we discussed the possibility of deprecating python-neutronclient (see [0]). The CLI part of python-neutronclient is already deprecated (see [1]), but we have python bindings for Neutron both in python-neutronclient and in openstacksdk.

As python-neutronclient's binding code is widely used as "client" code (i.e.: Heat, Horizon, Nova), but python-openstackclient uses openstacksdk's binding code for "client" this means duplicated work and maintenance for all the bindings.

If we have a new API feature the binding code must go both to python-neutronclient to make it available in Heat, and to openstacksdk to have openstackclient support for it.

The best would be to have the binding code in openstacksdk and deprecate python-neutronclient, but before we plan anything we would like to have a list of projects that depend on python-neutronclient. We identified a few but for sure with python-neutronclient's long history there are a lot more: * Heat * Horizon * Nova * various Networking projects * ......

Please share Your thoughts about this topic and the projects which use python-neutronclient, it would be really helpful to see how we can move forward.

[0]: https://etherpad.opendev.org/p/neutron-yoga-ptg#L372 [1]: https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/python-neutronclient/+/795475

Regards Lajos Katona (lajoskatona)