[all] [tc] [osc] [glance] [train] [ptls] Legacy client CLI to OSC review 639376

Alexandra Settle a.settle at outlook.com
Tue Aug 20 08:32:16 UTC 2019


Hi all,

For the Train cycle Artem Goncharov proposed moving the legacy client
CLIs to OSC. This goal did not move forward due to a broad range of
concerns and was eventually -1'd by Erno Kuvaja (Glance PTL) as he was
unable to support it from a Glance point of view.

Moving forward, I'd like to end the discussion in the review [1] by
abandoning the patch and move this to the mailing list. The following
looks like it needs to happen:

1. This PR should be abandoned. It is not going to be accepted as a
commmunity goal in this format and the debate within the comments is
circular. Let's step out of here, and start having conversation
elsewhere. 

2. To start those conversations, a pop-up team would be a suitable
alternative to begin driving that work. Someone needs to step forward
to lead the pop-up team. The TC recommends two individuals step
forwards as indicated in the pop-up team Governance document [2]. 

3. I recommend the pop-up team include Erno Kuvaja or a representative
from the Glance team and including Matt Reidemann (who has been working
to close the compute API gaps).

4. The leaders must then identify a clear objective, and a clear
disband criteria.

If in case the pop-up team decide that this could be better drafted as
a community goal for U, then that is a suitable alternative that can be
defined using the new goal selection criteria that is being defined
here [3] But this should not be decided before clear objectives are
defined.

Thanks,

Alex
IRC: asettle

[1] https://review.opendev.org/#/c/639376/
[2] https://governance.openstack.org/tc/reference/popup-teams.html
[3] https://review.opendev.org/#/c/667932/


More information about the openstack-discuss mailing list