<div dir="ltr">Hi All,<div><br></div><div>I've processed the list that Tony sent through this morning, removing the branches and tagging their positions as described.</div><div><br></div><div>The only exception being that openstack/zaqar doesn't have stable/liberty or stable/liberty2 branches to EOL.</div><div><br></div><div>Let me know if I've missed anything.</div><div><br></div><div>Cheers,<br>Josh</div></div><div class="gmail_extra"><br><div class="gmail_quote">On Wed, Sep 20, 2017 at 11:03 AM, Tony Breeds <span dir="ltr"><<a href="mailto:tony@bakeyournoodle.com" target="_blank">tony@bakeyournoodle.com</a>></span> wrote:<br><blockquote class="gmail_quote" style="margin:0 0 0 .8ex;border-left:1px #ccc solid;padding-left:1ex"><span class="">On Thu, Aug 24, 2017 at 01:14:56PM +1000, Tony Breeds wrote:<br>
> Hello all,<br>
> We have a number of old stable/* branches hanging around and I'd<br>
> like to mark anything <= stable/mitaka as EOL. I've highlighted a few<br>
> projects on the subject line:<br>
><br>
> QA: Are the older branches of grenade safe to go? IIUC we don't use<br>
> them as we don't do grenade testing on $oldest stable branch<br>
> group-based-policy: In the past you've requested your old branches stay<br>
> around Do you still need this? Is there value in<br>
> the *all* staying active?<br>
> zaqar: I see that liberty was EOL and then reactivated do you still need<br>
> liberty2?<br>
> packaging_deb: As these repos have the $project origin using the<br>
> standard series-eol tag doesn't make sense for exaxple<br>
> deb-nova gets a mitaka-eol from the nova repo. So I've<br>
> picked mitaka-eol-dpkg.<br>
> fuel, networking-*: There are several entries for these projects groups<br>
> so I'm calling them out here for attention.<br>
><br>
> I'm proposing we do this removal during the PTG. Once we've done the<br>
> series based branches we can look at old versioned releases like<br>
> stable/16.04 etc.<br>
><br>
> It's hard to present the data in a clear way so given infra will be the<br>
> ultimate actioners of this list I present this as a shell script:<br>
<br>
</span>Per previous discussion here's the list to EOL everything <= mitaka<br>
except for:<br>
openstack/group-based-policy,<br>
openstack/group-based-policy-<wbr>automation,<br>
openstack/group-based-policy-<wbr>ui,<br>
openstack/python-group-based-<wbr>policy-client<br>
and openstack/networking-bigswitch<br>
<div><div class="h5"><br>
---<br>
eol-branch.sh -- stable/essex essex-eol openstack/anvil<br>
eol-branch.sh -- stable/folsom folsom-eol openstack/anvil<br>
eol-branch.sh -- stable/grizzly grizzly-eol openstack/anvil<br>
eol-branch.sh -- stable/havana havana-eol openstack/openstack<br>
eol-branch.sh -- stable/icehouse icehouse-eol \<br>
openstack/astara openstack/networking-brocade \<br>
openstack/networking-cisco openstack/networking-mlnx \<br>
openstack/networking-odl openstack/networking-plumgrid \<br>
openstack/nova-solver-<wbr>scheduler \<br>
openstack/sahara-image-<wbr>elements openstack/tricircle \<br>
openstack/trio2o openstack/vmware-nsx<br>
eol-branch.sh -- stable/icehouse icehouse-eol-dpkg \<br>
openstack/deb-networking-cisco \<br>
openstack/deb-networking-mlnx openstack/deb-networking-odl<br>
eol-branch.sh -- stable/juno juno-eol \<br>
openstack/astara openstack/astara-appliance \<br>
openstack/astara-horizon openstack/astara-neutron \<br>
openstack/group-based-policy \<br>
openstack/group-based-policy-<wbr>automation \<br>
openstack/group-based-policy-<wbr>ui openstack/mistral \<br>
openstack/mistral-dashboard openstack/mistral-extra \<br>
openstack/networking-bigswitch \<br>
openstack/networking-brocade openstack/networking-cisco \<br>
openstack/networking-mlnx openstack/networking-odl \<br>
openstack/networking-plumgrid \<br>
openstack/nova-solver-<wbr>scheduler \<br>
openstack/openstack-resource-<wbr>agents \<br>
openstack/powervc-driver openstack/proliantutils \<br>
openstack/puppet-n1k-vsm openstack/puppet-vswitch \<br>
openstack/python-group-based-<wbr>policy-client \<br>
openstack/python-mistralclient \<br>
openstack/python-muranoclient openstack/vmware-nsx<br>
eol-branch.sh -- stable/juno juno-eol-dpkg \<br>
openstack/deb-mistral openstack/deb-networking-cisco \<br>
openstack/deb-networking-mlnx openstack/deb-networking-odl \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>mistralclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>muranoclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>proliantutils<br>
eol-branch.sh -- stable/kilo kilo-eol \<br>
openstack-dev/grenade openstack/murano-apps \<br>
openstack/networking-h3c openstack/requirements<br>
eol-branch.sh -- stable/kilo kilo-eol1 \<br>
openstack/group-based-policy \<br>
openstack/group-based-policy-<wbr>automation \<br>
openstack/group-based-policy-<wbr>ui \<br>
openstack/python-group-based-<wbr>policy-client<br>
eol-branch.sh -- stable/kilo_v2 kilo_v2-eol openstack/networking-bigswitch<br>
eol-branch.sh -- stable/liberty liberty-eol \<br>
openstack-dev/grenade openstack/ceilometer-powervm \<br>
openstack/ceilometer-zvm openstack/ceilometermiddleware \<br>
openstack/fuel-plugin-calico openstack/group-based-policy \<br>
openstack/group-based-policy-<wbr>automation \<br>
openstack/group-based-policy-<wbr>ui openstack/mistral-extra \<br>
openstack/networking-infoblox openstack/networking-powervm \<br>
openstack/networking-zvm openstack/nova-powervm \<br>
openstack/nova-zvm-virt-driver \<br>
openstack/python-group-based-<wbr>policy-client \<br>
openstack/requirements openstack/swiftonhpss<br>
eol-branch.sh -- stable/liberty liberty-eol-dpkg \<br>
openstack/deb-aodh openstack/deb-barbican \<br>
openstack/deb-ceilometer \<br>
openstack/deb-<wbr>ceilometermiddleware openstack/deb-cinder \<br>
openstack/deb-congress openstack/deb-designate \<br>
openstack/deb-designate-<wbr>dashboard openstack/deb-glance \<br>
openstack/deb-heat openstack/deb-horizon \<br>
openstack/deb-ironic openstack/deb-ironic-inspector \<br>
openstack/deb-keystone openstack/deb-magnum \<br>
openstack/deb-manila openstack/deb-manila-ui \<br>
openstack/deb-mistral openstack/deb-murano \<br>
openstack/deb-murano-agent openstack/deb-murano-dashboard \<br>
openstack/deb-networking-<wbr>arista \<br>
openstack/deb-networking-cisco \<br>
openstack/deb-networking-<wbr>hyperv \<br>
openstack/deb-networking-l2gw \<br>
openstack/deb-networking-<wbr>midonet \<br>
openstack/deb-networking-mlnx openstack/deb-networking-nec \<br>
openstack/deb-networking-odl openstack/deb-neutron \<br>
openstack/deb-neutron-fwaas openstack/deb-neutron-lbaas \<br>
openstack/deb-neutron-vpnaas openstack/deb-nova \<br>
openstack/deb-openstack-trove \<br>
openstack/deb-python-automaton \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>barbicanclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>ceilometerclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>ceilometermiddleware \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>cinderclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-cliff \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>congressclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>debtcollector \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>designateclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-django-<wbr>openstack-auth \<br>
openstack/deb-python-futurist \<br>
openstack/deb-python-glance-<wbr>store \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>glanceclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>heatclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-ironic-<wbr>inspector-client \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>ironicclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>keystoneauth1 \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>keystoneclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>keystonemiddleware \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>magnumclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>manilaclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>mistralclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-mox3 \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>muranoclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>neutronclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>novaclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>openstackclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-os-brick \<br>
openstack/deb-python-os-<wbr>client-config \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.<wbr>cache \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.<wbr>concurrency \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.<wbr>config \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.<wbr>context \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.db \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.i18n \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.log \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.<wbr>messaging \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.<wbr>middleware \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.<wbr>policy \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.<wbr>reports \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.<wbr>rootwrap \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.<wbr>serialization \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.<wbr>service \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.<wbr>utils \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.<wbr>versionedobjects \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.<wbr>vmware \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslotest openstack/deb-python-pbr \<br>
openstack/deb-python-pycadf \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>saharaclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>swiftclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>tackerclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-taskflow openstack/deb-python-tooz \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>troveclient openstack/deb-python-yaql \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>zaqarclient openstack/deb-sahara \<br>
openstack/deb-stevedore openstack/deb-swift \<br>
openstack/deb-zaqar<br>
eol-branch.sh -- stable/liberty liberty-eol1 \<br>
openstack/networking-bgpvpn openstack/networking-odl \<br>
openstack/zaqar<br>
eol-branch.sh -- stable/liberty2 liberty2-eol openstack/zaqar<br>
eol-branch.sh -- stable/liberty_ksv3 liberty_ksv3-eol openstack/networking-bigswitch<br>
eol-branch.sh -- stable/liberty_v2 liberty_v2-eol openstack/networking-bigswitch<br>
eol-branch.sh -- stable/mitaka mitaka-eol \<br>
openstack-dev/grenade openstack/ceilometer-zvm \<br>
openstack/cloudkitty-dashboard openstack/cloudpulse \<br>
openstack/collectd-ceilometer-<wbr>plugin \<br>
openstack/daisycloud-core openstack/fuel-agent \<br>
openstack/fuel-astute openstack/fuel-docs \<br>
openstack/fuel-library openstack/fuel-main \<br>
openstack/fuel-menu openstack/fuel-mirror \<br>
openstack/fuel-nailgun-agent \<br>
openstack/fuel-nailgun-<wbr>extension-cluster-upgrade \<br>
openstack/fuel-nailgun-<wbr>extension-converted-<wbr>serializers \<br>
openstack/fuel-nailgun-<wbr>extension-iac \<br>
openstack/fuel-noop-fixtures openstack/fuel-octane \<br>
openstack/fuel-ostf openstack/fuel-plugin-calico \<br>
openstack/fuel-plugin-detach-<wbr>database \<br>
openstack/fuel-plugin-detach-<wbr>haproxy \<br>
openstack/fuel-plugin-detach-<wbr>keystone \<br>
openstack/fuel-plugin-detach-<wbr>rabbitmq \<br>
openstack/fuel-plugin-<wbr>external-lb \<br>
openstack/fuel-plugin-<wbr>purestorage-cinder openstack/fuel-qa \<br>
openstack/fuel-ui openstack/fuel-virtualbox \<br>
</div></div> openstack/fuel-web openstack/k8s-docker-suite-<wbr>app-murano \<br>
openstack/network-checker openstack/networking-6wind \<br>
<span class=""> openstack/networking-brocade openstack/networking-infoblox \<br>
openstack/networking-mlnx openstack/networking-nec \<br>
openstack/networking-ovs-dpdk \<br>
openstack/networking-plumgrid openstack/networking-zvm \<br>
openstack/nova-zvm-virt-driver \<br>
openstack/openstack-chef-repo \<br>
openstack/openstack-resource-<wbr>agents \<br>
openstack/puppet-midonet openstack/python-<wbr>cloudkittyclient \<br>
openstack/python-<wbr>cloudpulseclient \<br>
</span> openstack/python-fuelclient openstack/release-test \<br>
<div class="HOEnZb"><div class="h5"> openstack/requirements openstack/shotgun \<br>
openstack/storlets openstack/timmy openstack/tuning-box \<br>
openstack/yaql<br>
eol-branch.sh -- stable/mitaka mitaka-eol-dpkg \<br>
openstack/deb-aodh openstack/deb-barbican \<br>
openstack/deb-ceilometer \<br>
openstack/deb-<wbr>ceilometermiddleware openstack/deb-cinder \<br>
openstack/deb-congress openstack/deb-designate \<br>
openstack/deb-designate-<wbr>dashboard openstack/deb-glance \<br>
openstack/deb-heat openstack/deb-horizon \<br>
openstack/deb-ironic openstack/deb-ironic-inspector \<br>
openstack/deb-ironic-ui openstack/deb-keystone \<br>
openstack/deb-magnum openstack/deb-manila \<br>
openstack/deb-manila-ui openstack/deb-mistral \<br>
openstack/deb-murano openstack/deb-murano-agent \<br>
openstack/deb-murano-dashboard \<br>
openstack/deb-networking-<wbr>arista \<br>
openstack/deb-networking-<wbr>hyperv \<br>
openstack/deb-networking-l2gw \<br>
openstack/deb-networking-<wbr>midonet \<br>
openstack/deb-networking-mlnx openstack/deb-networking-nec \<br>
openstack/deb-networking-odl openstack/deb-neutron \<br>
openstack/deb-neutron-fwaas openstack/deb-neutron-lbaas \<br>
openstack/deb-neutron-vpnaas openstack/deb-nova \<br>
openstack/deb-openstack-trove \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>aodhclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-automaton \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>barbicanclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>ceilometerclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>ceilometermiddleware \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>cinderclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-cliff \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>congressclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>debtcollector \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>designateclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-django-<wbr>openstack-auth \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>fuelclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-futurist \<br>
openstack/deb-python-glance-<wbr>store \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>glanceclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>heatclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-ironic-<wbr>inspector-client \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>ironicclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>keystoneauth1 \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>keystoneclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>keystonemiddleware \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>magnumclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>manilaclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>mistralclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>monascaclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-mox3 \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>muranoclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-neutron-<wbr>lib \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>neutronclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>novaclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>openstackclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-os-brick \<br>
openstack/deb-python-os-<wbr>client-config \<br>
openstack/deb-python-os-win \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.<wbr>cache \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.<wbr>concurrency \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.<wbr>config \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.<wbr>context \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.db \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.i18n \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.log \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.<wbr>messaging \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.<wbr>middleware \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.<wbr>policy \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.<wbr>privsep \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.<wbr>reports \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.<wbr>rootwrap \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.<wbr>serialization \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.<wbr>service \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.<wbr>utils \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.<wbr>versionedobjects \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslo.<wbr>vmware \<br>
openstack/deb-python-oslotest \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>osprofiler \<br>
openstack/deb-python-pycadf \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>saharaclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>scciclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>senlinclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-shotgun \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>swiftclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>tackerclient \<br>
openstack/deb-python-taskflow openstack/deb-python-tooz \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>troveclient openstack/deb-python-yaql \<br>
openstack/deb-python-<wbr>zaqarclient openstack/deb-sahara \<br>
openstack/deb-sahara-dashboard openstack/deb-senlin \<br>
openstack/deb-senlin-dashboard openstack/deb-stevedore \<br>
openstack/deb-swift openstack/deb-trove-dashboard \<br>
openstack/deb-zaqar<br>
eol-branch.sh -- stable/mitaka-hpb mitaka-hpb-eol openstack/networking-arista<br>
eol-branch.sh -- stable/mitaka-hpb mitaka-hpb-eol-dpkg openstack/deb-networking-<wbr>arista<br>
---<br>
<br>
Yours Tony.<br>
</div></div><br>______________________________<wbr>______________________________<wbr>______________<br>
OpenStack Development Mailing List (not for usage questions)<br>
Unsubscribe: <a href="http://OpenStack-dev-request@lists.openstack.org?subject:unsubscribe" rel="noreferrer" target="_blank">OpenStack-dev-request@lists.<wbr>openstack.org?subject:<wbr>unsubscribe</a><br>
<a href="http://lists.openstack.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/openstack-dev" rel="noreferrer" target="_blank">http://lists.openstack.org/<wbr>cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/<wbr>openstack-dev</a><br>
<br></blockquote></div><br></div>