[openstack-dev] More on the topic of DELIMITER, the Quota Management Library proposal

Mike Perez thingee at gmail.com
Sat Apr 23 19:18:48 UTC 2016

On 14:54 Apr 18, Jay Pipes wrote:
> On 04/16/2016 05:51 PM, Amrith Kumar wrote:
> >         - update_resource(id or resource, newsize)
> Resizing resources is a bad idea, IMHO. Resources are easier to deal with
> when they are considered of immutable size and simple (i.e. not complex or
> nested). I think the problem here is in the definition of resource classes
> improperly.
> For example, a "cluster" is not a resource. It is a collection of resources
> of type node. "Resizing" a cluster is a misnomer, because you aren't
> resizing a resource at all. Instead, you are creating or destroying
> resources inside the cluster (i.e. joining or leaving cluster nodes).
> BTW, this is also why the "resize instance" API in Nova is such a giant pain
> in the ass. It's attempting to "modify" the instance "resource" when the
> instance isn't really the resource at all. The VCPU, RAM_MB, DISK_GB, and
> PCI devices are the actual resources. The instance is a convenient way to
> tie those resources together, and doing a "resize" of the instance behind
> the scenes actually performs a *move* operation, which isn't a *change* of
> the original resources. Rather, it is a creation of a new set of resources
> (of the new amounts) and a deletion of the old set of resources.

How about extending a volume? A volume is a resource and can be extended in
Cinder today.

Mike Perez

More information about the OpenStack-dev mailing list