[openstack-dev] [Neutron][policy] Long standing -2 on Group-based policy patch
sumitnaiksatam at gmail.com
Mon Aug 4 17:16:30 UTC 2014
The first patch of this high priority approved blueprint
targeted for Juno-3 has been blocked by a core reviewer’s (Mark
McClain) -2 since July 2nd. This patch was at patch-set 13 then, and
has been repeatedly reviewed and updated to the current patch-set 22.
However, there has been no comment or reason forthcoming from the
reviewer on why the -2 still persists. The dependent patches have also
gone through numerous iterations since.
There is a team of several people working on this feature across
different OpenStack projects since Oct 2013. The feature has been
discussed and iterated over weekly IRC meetings, design sessions
spanning two summits, mailing list threads, a working PoC
implementation, and a code sprint. Blocking the first patch required
for this feature jeopardizes this year-long effort and the delivery of
this feature in Juno. For many, this may sound like an all too
familiar story, and hence this team would like to mitigate the
issue while there is still time.
Mark, can you please explain why your -2 still persists? If there are
no major outstanding issues, can you please remove the -2?
Neutron-PTL, can you please provide guidance on how we can make
progress on this feature?
For the benefit of anyone not familiar with this feature, please see .
Group-based Policy Team.
More information about the OpenStack-dev